29 ms·
I forget what exactly caused me to stop visiting Slashdot. Probably the redesign was when I started finding other sites to visit. Same with Fark. Another big cr
by ryandrake 3y ago
I forget what exactly caused me to stop visiting Slashdot. Probably the redesign was when I started finding other sites to visit. Same with Fark. Another big crappy redesign that drove users away. Then Reddit. When will sites learn?
- bryan_w 3y agoFor me it was when they evolved into daily "Windows vs Linux" articles that they would pump for content. You could see the manipulation from a mile away.
- slater 3y agoNew tagline for /. - Enshittification pioneers since 1997
- philjohn 3y agoFor me it was Digg (pre redesign) then Reddit and hn
- vinaypai 3y agoSelection bias at work here. Most sites that have been around along time have redesigned at some point, and you always get some vocal users complaining about it.
- pixl97 3y agoEh, I have to say it's probably not just selection bias directly. Most of the time you have to ask the question, who is the redesign for, and what is it attempting to accomplish. Especially in the case of sites where you have mostly a base of technical users and the site is looking for more generalist users to join to "increase engagement for profitability reasons" then don't be surprised when all the technical users are pissed.
- TedDoesntTalk 3y agoFor me it was the copious anonymous posters who ruined the comment sections with garbage.
- slater 3y agoThat's what the comments settings were for!
- sumtechguy 3y agoI was a AC for a long time. I made a comment someone didnt like and they followed me thru all the discussions to keep the conversation going. So I just posted AC and moved on with my life. The funny one was someone on soylent posting AC and then would sign each one with their name. Never got that one...
- mattbee 3y agoThe in jokes became racist and nobody seemed to care. Seemed like a sad end to a site that was pioneering in community moderation.
- gopher_space 3y agoThe tone went from rough-and-tumble, big tent libertarianism to hate filled right wing politics. From weird and funny to stupid and rude. I didn't want to be contaminated by that thinking or have my name associated with it, so I moved to Reddit where eventually the same thing happened. There's some kind of Godwin's Law corollary here that revolves around whether your board removes "I'm just asking questions" posts or not.
- mattbee 3y agoI don't see Reddit as one place like Slashdot was one place. I'm sure it still has horrific subs, but the ones I'm on are little islands of well-moderated chit-chat, local jokes and retro-computing.
- Loughla 3y agoRedesign hit right when reddit started to blow up. That's what killed /. For me. I didn't want to learn a new system and old reddit was STUPID easy to slot into and start using.
- tastyfreeze 3y agoSlashdot->Digg->Reddit->HN for me. Almost exclusively on HN these days. For me the transition from one to another was graduated where I visited multiple sites daily. As the "new" grew and covered more of what I liked to read about I stopped using the "old". Quality of comments and discussion is the secret sauce for me. Redesigns never really bothered me. Slashdot holds a special place for me though. It just happens to be the first place I commented and joined in discussion with a large group of strangers.
- alberth 3y agoThis was exactly my same progression.
- echelon 3y ago"Same" would be a low-effort comment; I think this was the path a lot of us have taken. Today's Reddit is a mire of ephemeral pop commentary, censorship, and automated flagging. It's like the leadership cares about engagement, not discussion, and they're willing to let people talk into the ether to drive the numbers up. The audience quality bar has substantially dropped in all but the most niche topical subreddits as well. Twitter and the spinoffs are all too high drama for me to engage in regularly. Everyone is playing morality sports or trying to game for traction. I miss being able to hold a no-stakes, high quality discussion amongst peers. I feel like we need anonymous P2P social networking. I don't like other parties being the arbiters of information flows, and I also don't like bad agents seeking to tear down those that go against their personal brand of ideology.
- downWidOutaFite 3y agoThe network effects are way stronger these days so they're able to withstand user-hostile actions like ad-friendly redesigns. Since the social networks are much bigger now and network effects are n^2 they're becoming unstoppable. I think we're stuck in this local optimum for a while. I kind of hope AI bots ruin it for everybody and we forced to come up with something new.
- acomjean 3y agoAnd everyone dunks on Craigslist for not modernizing it’s design….
- hotnfresh 3y agoIt's the only major(?) site my elderly dad can consistently use without assistance. One big factor: once he learns where something is, it doesn't move.
- demondemidi 3y agoI still visit /., I just avoid the comments because its 4chan-y in there. My first /. account was created in 1997. What I like about /. interface is that there is a summary under each article, and there are only ~10 articles on the main page, and I find the topics more focused on what I'm interested in. HN is just a flood of random stuff and I'm usually only interested in ~10% of what's on the front page, compared to 80% of /. front page. HN needs channels.
- cmdrtaco 3y agoPublic user accounts on slashdot were created in 1998 :)
- demondemidi 3y agoHa! Awesome. Thanks Cmdr. Yeah that was 25ish years ago, as I said in a different post I was living abroad for a year that spanned 1997 into 1998. I was off by a few months apparently.
- gadders 3y agoHow can you tell when your account was created? I know I was reading it pre 9/11 but can't find an "account created on" page.
- demondemidi 3y agoThere's this thing called "human memory", heard of it? :) Kidding. It is easy for me because I was living in Porto for a year and I chose my username to be the street my apartment was on.
- pavon 3y agoIf you go to Achievements in your profile, there is one for years read, which shows a date that I assume is the account creation date. Correction: Doing the math, it looks like the date on which the achievement was earned, so subtract off the years read from the date to get account creation date.
- georgeburdell 3y agoI started going there in 2003 and stopped around 2013. For me it was the shift toward an ever more ornery comment section. Public discussion in general seemed to get a lot worse around the time Obama was elected, and /. was one of the last sites to fall
- randomdata 3y agoReddit seemingly learned. It is why old.reddit.com is still around.
- mattl 3y agoFor now. The .compact view was removed recently.
- OfSanguineFire 3y agoIt doesn’t matter if old.reddit.com is still there. Only a tiny percentage of people know about it and use it. Everyone else is posting from the new website or app, and largely from phones, which absolutely has had an impact on the culture there. For example, subreddits used to have FAQs and wikis in the sidebar. The redesign hid all that, so on many subs people are asking the same questions over and over again. Mods who lock such posts and refer posters to a FAQ, often get lambasted by the community, who can’t see any FAQ. This may have been an intentional part of the redesign, since repetitive posting registers as greater “engagement” for Reddit’s metrics.
- fturst 3y agoI dont think Reddit would want to make their own internal metrics worse, they arent getting paid for that. They needed to go mainstream though, and the best working tactic out there was (still kinda is) simplification and infinite scroll. Reddit did both.
- yetanotherloss 3y agoThey're intentionally killing it slowly through malicious neglect. It's already unable to deal with some things in user profiles and the image galleries which force you into the new awful.
- justsomehnguy 3y agohttps://old.reddit.com/r/bugs/comments/nwv50z/old_reddit_users_see_thousands_of_broken_links/?rdt=33060 https://old.reddit.com/r/bugs/comments/nwv50z/old_reddit_use... 2.5 years.
- hotnfresh 3y ago> Same with Fark. "You'll get over it." Yeah, I never did. I use m.fark when I browse it, even on desktop. The desktop site remains awful. Both are worse than the pre-redesign site.
- romanhn 3y agoAt one point I realized that Slashdot was reporting on stories that showed up on HN days earlier. It was a quick transition for me, despite daily usage of Slashdot since '99 or so.
- artificialLimbs 3y agoOnce they sold to Conde Nast, it went downhill quick.
- ThinkingGuy 3y agoHonestly, for me Hacker News fills the roll that Slashdot did for 20 years. I was reading them both daily for a while, then realized that I could save time by just following HN.
- zem 3y agoI stopped when reddit came along because the reddit engine was simply more pleasant to use. even when I browsed slashdot regularly I almost never commented because something about the ux was off-putting.
- taylodl 3y agoI pretty much stopped visiting /. when CmdrTaco left. A colleague at the time turned me on to HN and I've been here ever since. PS: I just signed into /. for the first time in years. My account is still active and my karma is positive! It's been 26 years since I created that account! It's probably my oldest account on the internet.
- jzb 3y agoTwitter. Twitter caused me to stop visiting Slashdot. I visited /. because I found things out on /. before I read the same thing elsewhere. That stopped happening at some point - I'd see something on Twitter and then see it on /. a day or two or a week later. Gradually I stopped visiting Slashdot at all. And then I read that Rob left, and I was like "yeah... makes sense." Note: Worked for Sourceforge from mid-2005 to mid-2007 on other properties. Met Rob once or twice... wasn't particularly friendly, but this was while Slashdot was still in its heyday and I'm sure he was burned out on making small talk with other folks. Jeff Bates (hemos) was a decent guy, reported up through him for a while IIRC.