4 ms·
> We have had the capability to develop ourselves to send a colony to mars in 10 years if we really wanted to, for 50 years Like I said, pure delusion. We can
by paxys 3y ago
> We have had the capability to develop ourselves to send a colony to mars in 10 years if we really wanted to, for 50 years
Like I said, pure delusion. We can still barely manage to launch rockets into space, and it still costs thousands of dollars per kg of cargo just to get to LEO. No human has lived in space for an extended period of time at a range beyond the ISS (400 km, while Mars is 400 million km).
- maxlin 3y agoYou're nothing but the harbringer of your own doom with that kind of uninformed loser talk. You know how unrealistic and pointless it sounds like, especially said on HN? Back when Kennedy first harnessed the whole US towards something truly greater, the odds seemed infinitely worse. But they got it done. Including minituarizing a room-sized computer to fit in a box just to serve as cruise control for Apollo.
- actionfromafar 3y agoOn Mars you can build shelter with dirt or in caves. You would be better protected than in LEO. The Moon is very inhospitable, but it's close enough we could have just shuttled an endless stream of ready-to-live habitat modules there, one after another. The tech was there. The will was not. I'm not saying it would have been rational to do it in the 1970s, but we could have! On the other hand, what we actually did do (to the Earth) wasn't exactly rational, either.
- usrbinbash 3y ago> On Mars you can build shelter with dirt or in caves. Really? What machines would be used to build these shelters? How do they get to Mars? How would they be powered? What auxilliary materials will they require and how do those get to Mars?
- notfish 3y agoPretty sure we could design and launch a digging robot in 10 years, I dont really buy that as the bottleneck to mars exploration
- axus 3y agoI'm pretty sure that we could not, I guess our opinions cancel each other out.
- feoren 3y agoHumans have 10 successful missions landing robots on Mars, starting in 1975. Robots have been operating on Mars continuously for almost 20 years. Opportunity was active for 15 years. The helicopter Ingenuity has flown 63 separate times and counting. The Perseverance rover is about the size of a hatchback car and carries seven advanced scientific instruments. Ten years of strong-willed national effort was enough to get us humans landing on the moon. From where we are now, you honestly don't think ten years of strong-willed national (or even international) effort could get us a robot capable of digging holes?
- usrbinbash 3y ago> you honestly don't think ten years of strong-willed national (or even international) effort could get us a robot capable of digging holes? Yes, I do think that. Because there is a big difference between an exploratory vehicle that carries a number of scientific instruments and can be powered by a few solar panels or a small nuclear battery... ...and these beautys: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel_boring_machine https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Tunnel_boring_machine Just for comparisons sake: Perseverances MMRTG provides 110 watts of power. A single metric horsepower is 735.5 watts. I leave looking up the power requirements of even a small machine that would be capable of digging habitats into the martian bedrock, as an exercise to the reader.
- feoren 3y agoI agree it's not realistic to send a full tunnel boring machine, drilling out 200 to 700 meters per week for subways and highways, to Mars in the next 10 years. Such a thing would have to be assembled on Mars with advanced industry already in place. I vehemently disagree that we need a 700 meter/week behemoth, sized for heavy rail, to dig out a habitat for one or two dozen humans. I'm imagining something more like a small-ish Roadheader[1], two to four times larger than Perseverance. It would either need to be Diesel powered (yes, shipping the diesel would suck, but it doesn't need to run forever) or we'd need a small solar farm and a couple Tesla batteries powering the thing (we probably want that anyway, for our habitat). It would take months to dig out a cave large enough for 10 to 20 humans, and there are hundreds of other problems to solve to actually turn a small, potentially unstable Martian cave into a livable habitat. We know the first steps will be slow; that's OK. Besides, we have a decade of engineering to refine the design. Don't underestimate humans. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadheader https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Roadheader
- Wytwwww 3y ago> On Mars you can build shelter with dirt or in caves. You would be better protected than in LEO. Is that true? Maybe if you never ever go outside but you might as well just dig a very deep cave here on Earth if your entire is to prove that humans can live in extremely inhospitable environments.
- lamontcg 3y agoApollo wasn't really fiscally sustainable, particularly given the expansion that you visualize. In 1965 it was 0.75% of GDP per year and NASA was 1% of GDP per year. By comparison the "pork program" SLS is running at 0.018% of GDP so is 40x more affordable. Expanding the Apollo spending in the 1970s probably wouldn't have helped us any when climate change became a concern.