3 ms·
> Voluntary Marxism doesn't work, either There's no such thing as “Voluntary Marxism”. > See the 20,000 American communes, which all failed, and the Israel ki
by dragonwriter 3y ago
> Voluntary Marxism doesn't work, either
There's no such thing as “Voluntary Marxism”.
> See the 20,000 American communes, which all failed, and the Israel kibbutzen, which cannot survive without generous subsidy from the government.
Its false to say all American communes have failed (in fact, recent counts have many more with a much larger total population than when they were getting lots of attention, they just aren't an interesting novelty anymore), but there is nothing in Marxist theory that involves small voluntary communities doing their own thing separate from the state they are embedded in. Some communes may have been started by people who were personally Marxist in ideology, but communes in the sense that you are referring to have little to do with Marxism (I suppose that some Marxist might adopt a praxis in which they are seen as a means
to advance a broader revolution which is Marxist, but that's still doesn't make their success or failure relevant to Marxism as a system.)
- WalterBright 3y ago> There's no such thing as “Voluntary Marxism”. Sure there is. They're called communes. > Its false to say all American communes have failed Name one that hasn't failed.
- dragonwriter 3y ago> Sure there is. They're called communes. No, communes aren't Marxism. The American commune tradition predates Marx, in fact. You seem to have a dualistic worldview in which everything either is or is opposed to Marxism, but... there's a lot more than that in the world. > Name one that hasn't failed. https://www.ic.org/directory/search-results/?frm_search=&community_status=Established&country=United%20States&community_type=Commune https://www.ic.org/directory/search-results/?frm_search=&com...
- WalterBright 3y agoHow long has the oldest one lasted? Consider that 80% of business starts fail within 5 years. Does that meant that because they existed for 5 years of losing money, they were successful? Let's start with the very first one on your list: https://www.ic.org/directory/peaceful-valley-village/ https://www.ic.org/directory/peaceful-valley-village/ It has 6 members. 6! And they don't plan on moving in until 2025. Come on. You think Marxism works, find one that works. > The American commune tradition predates Marx, in fact. Correct. Jamestown and Plymouth were (failed) communes. Just because they predated Marxism doesn't mean they aren't Marxist.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dragonwriter 3y ago> How long has the oldest one lasted? The list is right there, answer your own question. At least 89 years, though maybe there is something older. > Come on. You think Marxism works, find one that works. Again, communes aren't Marxist in the first place (though some small minority of communes may be composed of Marxists), but there are several on that list decades older and significantly larger than that one. Also, I provided upthread what I described as the best example of Marxism working, this whole discussion of communes is you trying to beat a strawman that you set up, but failing even at that. > Jamestown and Plymouth were (failed) communes Neither Jamestown nor Plymouth were remotely communes at any point, including in their planning and founding. (While it was merged with a number of other colonies in a later colonial reorganization, I also don't understand what your criteria is for Plymouth failing, unless you mean failing as a commune, which is unsurprising since it never tried to be a commune, being closer to a capitalist republic with a very strong state church, from its founding to when it ceased to be a separate entity.) > Just because they predated Marxism doesn't mean they aren't Marxist. No, institutions which predate the existence of Marxism were not Marxist, but I guess this illustrates your commitment to seeing the world as a duality of things which are Marxism and things which are opposed to it, even where not only does that conflict not exist, but also it is logically impossible for it to exist.
- WalterBright 3y ago> The list is right there, answer your own question. At least 89 years, though maybe there is something older. Why can't you name it and point to it? > I provided upthread what I described as the best example of Marxism working Which is ... ?? Why is it so hard for you to be specific? > Neither Jamestown nor Plymouth were remotely communes at any point Sure they were. They had communal food production - and starved as a result. > institutions which predate the existence of Marxism were not Marxist Ya know, kings existed before someone decided to call them "monarchies".
- deleted 3y ago