5 ms·
Microsoft seeks EU Digital Market Acts exemption for underdog apps like Edge
- rvz 3y agoMicrosoft will do anything to bribe the regulators in their favour. Hardly surprising. The EU is known to have plenty of corruption scandals. Just add another Big Tech bribe in the mix for more of the same old issues.
- rsynnott 3y agoThe EC has generally been harsher on MS on this issue than US regulators; mandatory browser choice, when it was a thing, was an EU-only thing, for instance. Do you have examples of the EC accepting bribes to ignore corruption issues, or is this just the usual aimless "eurocrats BAD" stuff?
- idle_zealot 3y agoCorrect me if I'm wrong here: Microsoft is trying to get the default browser on the most popular desktop operating system, which they constantly try to foist upon users with every dark pattern in the book, a special exemption from DMA rules so that they can continue harassing and tricking users into using it? And they believe that it deserves this exemption because despite their best efforts users still refuse to use their browser when not forced to (web analytics report low Edge marketshare).
- jsnell 3y agoThey don't need to believe this deserves an exemption to argue for one. It's a low risk, high reward for them. The worst that can happen is that their application is rejected. The best that can happen is that they get a massive competitive edge worth billions.
- onlyrealcuzzo 3y agoIt is quite hysterical when the 2nd largest company in the world pretends like it can't compete - and not that they'd rather get handouts because it isn't worth it to them to make the investment - especially when they can just beg for handouts like a dog instead. The fact that this behavior is normalized is really pathetic. Microsoft should be ashamed of themselves. Instead they're proud that they took an opportunity to seek a handout. Maybe I'm naive thinking there was a world in which large companies ever had a shred of dignity - but if there was such a time - I wish the corporate world would revert back to it.
- hulitu 3y ago> Maybe I'm naive thinking there was a world in which large companies ever had a shred of dignity If they had "a shred of dignity", they would not bribe every government official in sight.
- hulitu 3y ago> on the most popular desktop operating system I guess the correct formulation will be "on the monopoly desktop operating system". I don't use Windows because i like it. I use it because my employer gives no other choice.
- hashtag-til 3y agoPeople go out of their way to install something else and don't use Edge and Bing because they are worse than the competition. Make a better product and people will actually use it. Just so to make the case that not every company is good at everything, Apple Maps, despite recent improvements is also utter crap, and even Apple is not around crying wolf to restrict competition.
- FirmwareBurner 3y ago>People go out of their way to install something else and don't use Edge and Bing because they are worse than the competition. Make a better product and people will actually use it. Well, Edge has objectively been better than Chrome on Windows (faster, less memory usage, longer battery life) for years now, but almost nobody knows this as people still default to installing Chrome out of 10+ years of habit. Humans are creatures of habit and the bad and good impressions from the old days tend to stick around regrades if the current realities have shifted, because people aren't into browser hopping for the sake of experimentation, especially if they're already invested in the ecosystem of one browser (have their cookies already there, have their passwords already stored, have an Android or a Chromebook). Edge could even cure cancer and people still wouldn't use it or give it a try, because the image that the default browser shipped with Windows (IE, Edge, whatever it happens to be called) must automatically be crap and Google's browser must automatically be better. So market success in the browser space is clearly no longer about having the better product, otherwise FF would have a higher market share, but about having the stronger brand and supporting ecosystem.
- skrebbel 3y agoThey just had to give it some more time. But they didn't, Edge a year or two ago was pretty great but they gradually loaded it with crapware.
- hashtag-til 3y agoWhat is the killer Chrome feature, you think? (Sorry I'm not a chrome user for many years, I vaguely remember it was well integrated with google accounts, etc.)
- aeurielesn 3y agoDo Microsoft's legal team has some magic loophole to avoid the antitrust case they're bringing on themselves?
- nazgulsenpai 3y agoThey just received regulatory approval to acquire one of the largest game developer/publishers on the planet for $69b. They're probably feeling pretty invincible right now.
- theknocker 3y ago[dead]
- thrdbndndn 3y agoWhenever the topic of OS-bundled browsers comes up, I always wonder how Apple manages to get away with iOS (Maybe also macOS?) + Safari in the EU, especially considering the fact they even restrict the browser engine (on iOS).
- slimsag 3y agoThey should just call their devices 'game consoles' instead of computers, then nobody would bat an eye!
- yjftsjthsd-h 3y agoIsn't it mostly that their market share is relatively small in the EU?
- mywittyname 3y agoI think society generally thinks of phones and computers as separate concepts. Phones are supposed to be locked down for security, and computers are supposed to be open. Apple's dominance is in the phone sector, and people who use Apple computers are largely used to or supportive of that locked down, Apple knows-best-approach to devices. Apple also knows what mistakes MS made, and can avoid them while slow-walking OSX to the same locked-down ecosystem as their other devices use. I'm curious if Microsoft could build their own iPad knock offs and get away with the same stuff that Apple does, but my guess is no.
- martin8412 3y agoApple doesn't have a large enough market share in the EU that it warrants intervention.
- drdaeman 3y agoWhy can’t they just put a requirement to use Edge in Windows’ EULA? :)
- martin8412 3y agoThey can, and nobody in the EU will care. Unless they somehow convince OEMs to require acceptance of the Windows EULA prior to purchase of a device with Windows preinstalled(and even then they'll need to provide it in understandable terms to the layman), then the EULA doesn't mean anything. Microsoft has had that issue for decades where they're in violation of consumer rights. You're not allowed to require acceptance of additional terms after the transaction has occurred.
- drdaeman 3y ago> Unless they somehow convince OEMs Wait, do they have a different laws about shrink-wrapped licenses in EU? I thought this particular aspect was pretty much universal everywhere, with very minor deviations. My understanding is that you buy a computer with Windows pre-installed, it requires to accept an EULA on the first boot, you either do it, or you can install a different OS (and theoretically ask for a refund, although this is where jurisdictions and realities start to really differ and I don't know about EU). OEMs only put some bits on the device (drive and firmware), but to best of my awareness license acceptance always happen after the sale and is between the user and Microsoft. If EU had tackled this somehow, please let me know (and forgive my lack of awareness). > You're not allowed to require acceptance of additional terms after the transaction has occurred. Surely they can with a new version? Apple does it this way (e.g. just recently watchOS 10.1 came with new EULA, requiring acceptance before an update can be installed) worldwide and I haven't heard of any government having issues with it. In Microsoft's best new traditions they can pester users to upgrade and even make it super Microsoft-friendly, with forced automatic upgrades that spend 30 minutes applying patches, then showing an EULA, then rolling back for another 30 minutes after it's declined.
- hedora 3y agoSince Windows is clearly not exempt, why not spin out “underdog” stuff like edge, and let it compete on its own merits?
- Obscurity4340 3y agoEU were the only exemption