5 ms·
The World Solved Acid Rain. We Can Also Solve Climate Change
- 8jkdsa8h4ebjvxz 3y agothe author works for our world on data
- mikestew 3y agoThis is the part where you answer the follow-up question of, "so what?".
- h2odragon 3y ago"acid rain" was much easier to fix; there were only 3 or 4 PR firms really pushing it. "Climate change" has become a cottage industry religion, people will see profits in it for a while yet.
- next_xibalba 3y agoScientific American is not a trustworthy or worthwhile publication. It is yet another outlet that has been captured by ideologues. See the recent controversy about their article entitled, “ The Theory That Men Evolved to Hunt and Women Evolved to Gather Is Wrong”.
- Pet_Ant 3y agoI used to read them in my youth, what is the controversy?
- jrflowers 3y agoThere are a number of concerned science enthusiasts that have pointed out that the archeological record has contracted the woke mind virus because clearly women never hunted
- next_xibalba 3y agoI think that’s an oversimplification (and an equally over-politicization) of that issue. Here is a good write up: https://whyevolutionistrue.com/2023/10/24/scientific-american-is-back-to-distorting-the-facts-to-buttress-its-ideology/ https://whyevolutionistrue.com/2023/10/24/scientific-america...
- jrflowers 3y agoI appreciate this link to the politically neutral blog post about how the author’s hopes were dashed by Scientific American buttressing “progressive” Left ideology and the moral proposition of the worth of women. I look forward to reading more discompassionate sober analyses of data that has no intent to persuade the readers on the Why Evolution Is True blog. I personally love it when discussions about archaeology unrelated to architecture use the word “buttress” six times in one ideologically neutral post. What we need more of in academic analysis of data is someone to ask the tough questions like “if archeologists see evidence of women hunting, isn’t that just buttressing feminism?”, “does feminism need buttressing?”, and “does this buttress Left ideology?”. There is not enough talk about what bones that are dug up buttress, and if they are sufficiently or excessively leftist.
- simmerup 3y agoOf course we can. All signs show we aren’t willing to though.
- gottorf 3y ago> Of course we can. Can we really, without either a massive reduction in population, a massive reduction in standard of living, or a massive centralization of capital and authority to force a switch to alternative energy sources? And if it requires any of those three, is it really a lack of willingness that prevents us?
- _aavaa_ 3y ago> to force a switch to alternative energy sources Let me start with this part of the framing. Fossil fuels have historically and still benefit from incredible amounts of explicit subsidies (e.g. government money) and implicit policies (e.g. unpriced externalities like pollution and CO2). If governments stop providing these subsidies and stop people from treating the atmosphere as a free sewer then nobody has to be forced to use renewables, people will gladly choose them because they're simply cheaper AND better for their personal health and the environment.
- gottorf 3y ago> Fossil fuels have historically and still benefit from incredible amounts of explicit subsidies (e.g. government money) and implicit policies (e.g. unpriced externalities like pollution and CO2). Fossil fuels receive an estimated ~$7T ($1.3T of which are direct "government money" subsidies) subsidies globally[0]. That's about 7.3% of global GDP subsidizing an energy source that comprises over 80% of the world consumption[1]. Honestly, it sounds like a pretty good deal. Are you claiming that without any subsidies, that >80% of all energy consumed (or some substantial fraction thereof) would naturally come from renewable sources? That sounds unrealistic with present-day technology, and optimistic even for the foreseeable future. Besides, renewables aren't free of negative externalities, either. In the end, existence itself is an imposition on the surroundings. Would you tell the caveman not to burn sticks for warmth, out of respect to CO2 emissions? Would you tell the people of the developing world that increased energy expenditure per capita, no matter the source, necessarily results in a greater impact to the environment? No policy is going to "solve" the fact that we live in a world of limited resources that we must economize to bring about maximal human flourishing. Fossil fuels have done a pretty good job at that. I welcome developments in nuclear and renewable technology, but I question your assertion that some kind of panacea can be achieved with renewables where we can maintain our present population and standards of living and have a radically smaller footprint on the environment. [0]: https://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Articles/2023/08/24/fossil-fuel-subsidies-surged-to-record-7-trillion https://www.imf.org/en/Blogs/Articles/2023/08/24/fossil-fuel... [1]: https://www.iea.org/reports/key-world-energy-statistics-2021/supply https://www.iea.org/reports/key-world-energy-statistics-2021...
- Veliladon 3y agoWe could solve acid rain within the confines of capitalism because we could make money doing it. You could sell large scale market solutions (catalytic scrubbing of exhaust gases) that could entirely solve the problem and have the small costs be passed on to consumers universally in the form of slightly higher electric bills and slightly higher car costs. We could solve climate change within 3 years. We could make a concerted effort by humanity to universally move the world to clean energy. But it's not going to happen, or at least happen way slower than it should, because of capitalism. You can't do what we did with acid rain and transpose it to climate change because it threatens some of the very largest owners of capital and they're not giving up their wealth extraction machine without a very dangerous fight.
- RetroTechie 3y agoSolving acid rain & CFCs was (relatively) cheap & easy to implement. And: effects visible within decades. Decarbonizing our world's economies otoh is a much much bigger project. Running across many sectors & involving big upfront investments. And even if GHG emissions were cut to 0 today, effect of higher CO2 will last for centuries. If no irreversible tipping points are hit. Note that in any case NO effort was made to remove substances from the environment. Only cut emissions. So yeah, one can be hopeful. But we'll be in for a rough ride anyway.
- jjtheblunt 3y agoGenuine data consistency question that i can not answer, but which seems curiously ignored: Why are there mediterranean archeological sites about 2000 years old in 30 feet of water a kilometer or so off the current coastlines?
- mathewsanders 3y agoIt’s probably more due to coastal subsidence than rising sea levels. My favorite is when glaciers retreat there is a rebound effect from pressure which can cause other local land to sink as a sort of equilibrium. I think in the Mediterranean coastal subsidence is mostly due to plate tectonics. I remember reading something about how myth of Atlantis might be due to a real life city that sunk as a result of an earthquake.
- pixl97 3y agohttps://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zanclean_flood https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Zanclean_flood Is always fun to talk about when looking at the geology of the Mediterranean.
- RCitronsBroker 3y agooh course we CAN solve climate change. We have a great deal of knowledge about where the emissions come from. It’s just that both problems, solutions and everything that’s needed inbetween is distorted and obfuscated in the name of profit, power and ideology. It’s undeniable that the mass adoption of nuclear power would be a huge step forward in terms of emissions. It’s statistically safer than fossile fuels, it’s not cyclical, thus more feasible without storage and infrastructure extravaganza. It’s also not perpetually 10 years away like fusion power. But, it’s political, a threat to powerful and profitable industries, and it threatens neocons on their unipolar powertrip. I could go on to list a whole bunch of other promising ideas, but their reasons for not existing are similar to the point of boring me before even writing them down.
- PortiaBerries 3y ago"threatens neocons on their unipolar powertrip"? I haven't noticed that the primary opposition to nuclear power is from the right...
- ramblerman 3y agoIn Western Europe the closing of many nuclear power plants was a top priority of the green parties. And unfortunately they were mostly succesful.
- hulitu 3y agoThank god we have coal. /s
- pixl97 3y agoSorry that nuclear power fucked itself by continued lying about the dangers in the past while it was still dangerous to the point almost nobody trusts anything they say... It's like a kid that lies all the time and everyone sees it, they aren't going to be trusted as adults.
- smallmouth 3y agoI don't get out much and I try to avoid Scientific American, but what is climate change as an issue, and how is it different now than at any given time during the Earth's history?
- exabrial 3y agoI think if people listened to what the opposite side was saying more clearly, they'd see there wasn't such a disagreement, it's just the methods need some negotiation. For examples: than spending federal money on subsidies, leave the money in the would-be taxpayer pocket instead. This makes both sides happy: reduces taxes, reduces pollution, reduces federal government waste. This sort of win-win thinking is covered in the 7 Habits. Unfortunately, environmental issues are hijacked into voting issues and these things _have to be_ us vs them, when in reality both sides are probably reasonable. The two party system is the downfall of the planet.