3 ms·
I don't agree entirely with OP, but there is truth in what he says. > The more ugly blue links you serve up, the more time users have to click on ads. Serve up
by mistermann 15y ago
I don't agree entirely with OP, but there is truth in what he says.
> The more ugly blue links you serve up, the more time users have to click on ads. Serve up bad results and the user must search again and this doubles the number of sponsored links you get paid for. Why be part of the solution when being part of the problem pays so damn well?
One thing that to me seems like a no brainer is for google to have user-configurable catalogs, or groups of websites. So, if I am logged in, I should be able to make a group called "Poker" and add the 10 websites that I know have good content to that group. So then when I am doing a search on that topic, I can choose my "Poker" catalog and results will only be returned from sites within that catalog.
This is just one extremely simple idea that would be immensely valuable and greatly improve search productivity, there are many others. That google hasn't thought of this idea, or has thought of it but decided it wouldn't be beneficial to users, seems very hard to believe. They have a vested interest in search being good (better than everyone else), but not great.
- danso 15y agoUm...isn't this what Google+ is supposed to do, in effect? By registering your +1's for sites and users, Google gets a good fix of where you like your information from. However, the solution you propose would fail if similar precedents are to be considered. Users do not like manually curating lists (remember Facebook friend lists?). On a philosophical point, your solution requires that users know what they don't know: that is, they don't know that the "poker" question at a given time might be better answered by a site outside their circle. If users were encouraged to curate their own sources to limit the search for knowledge from, then that encourages the echo chamber phenomenon which ends up hurting the "open" web.
- mistermann 15y ago> Um...isn't this what Google+ is supposed to do, in effect? Maybe, I have no idea. It lacks the manual grouping though. >Users do not like manually curating lists No one is forcing them, I'm not proposing this is the default behaviour, this would be a part of advanced search. >your solution requires that users know what they don't know No, it enables users who do know something to leverage that knowledge (as the existing "site:" qualifier allows with a single site) A very small number of google users even know about any kind of advanced functionality so there'd be no risk of an "echo chamber phenomenon".
- guimarin 15y agodisclaimer I work at blekko. What you are describing is like saying that wikipedia is useless because not everyone edits articles. As it turns out, a very small number of people can curate an enormous amount of content on the web, and you can get very good results. try searching for 'cure for headaches /monte' on blekko. the '/monte' slashtag gives you results for bing, blekko and google, with branding removed.
- guimarin 15y agotry the search engine blekko. see 'slastags' this is exactly what you propose. User curated vertical search engines...