10 ms·
How to leave academia (for science PhDs)
- telemachos 15y ago> Also, if your degree is in English, the best I can do is point you here (link to Starbucks job page). I know it's supposed to be funny (i.e., it's "just a joke") and I grant I may be sensitive since I have a BA in Comparative Literature (a graduating class of 1 in my major) and a PhD in Classics, but this came across as completely obnoxious and unnecessary. Don't know anything about Humanities? Fine. Don't talk about them. Still, thanks for the link to Software Carpentry. I didn't know the site, and it looks like a good place to point people for introductory material on the shell, make, and so on.
- oskarth 15y agoSlightly offtopic question: I re-read Odysseus a couple of weeks ago and was wondering about the name Telemachos. My rudimentary knowledge of etymology tells me that he's a "far away man". Given your username and the fact that you have a PhD in classics: what's your opinion of how the name/etymology of the character relates to the role that Telemachos plays in the epic? Obviously he's far away when Odysseus is out and about, but he's quite present in the beginning and end. It seems like there's more to it than that. (For those who don't remember / haven't read it, Telemachos is the only son of Odysseus in the epic. He's pretty much a younger copy of Odysseus.)
- jules 15y agotele = far machos = battle Perhaps it means that he was far away from the battle or it means that he battles from afar? The latter would seem a better fit for Odysseus himself.
- telemachos 15y agoYou said it much more succinctly than I did. He "battles from afar" - that is with a bow - hits it on the head. It would not have been so unusual for a son to be named for an excellence of his father.
- telemachos 15y agoHis name is usually taken to be a nod to his father's skill with a bow. You're right about the 'far' part, but the second part I think is different (the Ancient Greek word for man is anēr, andros - the root being andr): tele means "far away" or "from afar" (think 'television' it sees things from afar). The mach root comes from a word meaning "fight". So "Telemachos" is a "far-fighter", i.e. a bowman. Odysseus is primarily famous as an archer (as opposed to Achilles who is primarily famous for fighting with a spear). I think that etymology is pretty well accepted. It certainly was when I was a student. I'm not sure that there's a completely accepted explanation for how the name fits into his place in the epic. Here's my take: Telemachus must prove that he can grow up into as good a man as his father. He does that throughout the poem, as he goes from being a very immature teenager to eventually fighting alongside his father at the end of the poem. Before the trial of the bow (when all the suitors attempt to string Odysseus's bow and win Penelope), Telemachus tries to string his father's bow himself. Here's a translation of the scene I have in mind by Samuel Butler[1]. The 'he' refers to Telemachus: > As he spoke he sprang from his seat, threw his crimson cloak from him, and took his sword from his shoulder. First he set the axes in a row, in a long groove which he had dug for them, and had made straight by line. Then he stamped the earth tight round them, and everyone was surprised when they saw him set up so orderly, though he had never seen anything of the kind before. This done, he went on to the pavement to make trial of the bow; thrice did he tug at it, trying with all his might to draw the string, and thrice he had to leave off, though he had hoped to string the bow and shoot through the iron. He was trying for the fourth time, and would have strung it had not Ulysses made a sign to check him in spite of all his eagerness. So he said: > "Alas! I shall either be always feeble and of no prowess, or I am too young, and have not yet reached my full strength so as to be able to hold my own if any one attacks me. You others, therefore, who are stronger than I, make trial of the bow and get this contest settled." In that scene, I've always thought that Telemachus proves he is capable of becoming his father (he might have strung the bow), but he is willing - as a good son should - to yield to his father while he is still alive. At the same time, he also proves he is a good liar - like his father - since the little speech he gives at the end helps to encourage the suitors and think he is nobody to fear. When the fighting begins, however, he proves otherwise and he helps his father kill the suitors. [1]: http://classics.mit.edu/Homer/odyssey.21.xxi.html http://classics.mit.edu/Homer/odyssey.21.xxi.html
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- hogu 15y agoAnd also wrong. My wife left academia from philosophy and is pulling in north of 100k right now doing project management stuff. She got there within 3 years, though we're in NYC so it's easier to get more cash here. It was a hard to transition, most employers don't know what to do with a humanities degree, but she was able to do it. A programmer coworker of mine also worked in philosophy, and transitioned to programming and is doing rather well for himself. He did this over the past few years, so long after computer science was well established. Transitioning out of humanities academia into non-academic jobs is difficult, much harder than for those in the sciences, but it's quite doable
- robrenaud 15y agoPhilosophy majors tend to be a lot smarter than the rest of the humanities. http://www.ncsu.edu/chass/philo/GRE%20Scores%20by%20Intended%20Graduate%20Major.htm http://www.ncsu.edu/chass/philo/GRE%20Scores%20by%20Intended... http://www.umsl.edu/~philo/ETS%20LINK.pdf http://www.umsl.edu/~philo/ETS%20LINK.pdf
- anotherthrow 15y agoTheir salaries are not bad too: http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/info-Degrees_that_Pay_you_Back-sort.html http://online.wsj.com/public/resources/documents/info-Degree... As a philosophy PhD, I find the Philosophy > Starbucks meme obnoxious, but it's especially silly when philosophy is amongst the best Art/Humanities degrees one can do from that perspective (particularly if one then goes on to do something like work for an international law firm for a while - the rather conventional switch I've taken).
- apdinin 15y agoI'd also add (as an English PhD) that maybe the author of the post should read up on his Paul Graham: http://paulgraham.com/hp.html http://paulgraham.com/hp.html
- hcayless 15y agoHa! Another Classics Ph.D. here :-). And there are lots of people in programming with advanced Humanities degrees. STEM majors aren't the only smart people around.
- squishypirate 15y agoAgreed. I'm an English PhD working in the tech industry and I am very happy. Left a great postdoc a year ago and it took me all of 3 weeks to find a job in industry. Not to mention I'm making double what I would have been making as a starting TT faculty member.
- jseliger 15y agoHave you written a blog post about your experience? Or something at length in another forum?
- FreakLegion 15y agoSalve! I too tend to react negatively to summary judgment of humanities degrees. But the truth is that you and I and hogu's wife are outliers. For most humanities PhDs, those judgments are accurate. In fact, part of the reason I mastered out of my English PhD program was that the faculty and other students just weren't particularly bright (the other part was the academic politics). The humanities themselves are absolutely crucial subjects that all smart people should study -- but most people who study them aren't very smart.
- LetBinding 15y agoHumanities are the hardest discipline to get a PhD in. The leap from a top student in a CS undergrad program to a CS PhD program is not a big one. Most top students in an undergrad CS program can make the intellectual leap necessary to get a PhD in CS. But for an undergrad in a humanities discipline, making the leap to getting a PhD is a significant intellectual challenge. Reasoning about ideas, communicating them, and validating them, are infinitely harder in humanities than in CS. I would say, in terms of raw critical thinking skills, i.e., not pertaining to a specific discipline-specific problem, humanities PhDs would outperform CS PhDs. And I say this as someone who is currently in a CS PhD program. I can read other engineering PhD theses and still make sense of it. When I read a humanities theses, I am completely lost.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoBy the way, if anyone has good links, particularly on the topics where I've admitted ignorance, please email me. My info is in my profile.
- narkee 15y agoI'm finishing my PhD, and starting a post-doc in the fall. I had wanted to break out into industry, because I didn't see myself in academia in the long term, but I didn't get anywhere with job applications, so here I am. I have a few questions: 1. My work consumes most of my time and energy - how would one find time to work on side projects and build a portfolio, when the academic workload is so all-consuming 2. I felt like I had to apply for industry jobs in my niche, otherwise I would be competing against a much larger pool of general engineers/science graduates. Considering that I've spent most of the last 5-6 years focusing on work in a specific niche, how can this be used for leverage for more general technical positions? Thanks for the interesting article!
- jakobe 15y agoConcerning the workload: As far as I'm concerned, the academic workload is definitely not all-consuming. From watching my colleagues, I came to the conclusion that everybody chooses their own workload. Some of my coworkers come at 9AM and leave at 4PM; others think they absolutely must finish that experiment and stay until 10PM. Some people think they must immediately rush to the lab if their supervisor sends them an email on Saturday afternoon; others just ignore the email until Monday morning. I have never heard of anybody getting into trouble for turning their computer off on the weekend, or working normal hours; I think much of the pressure is self-inflicted. Personally, I currently work in academia (doing my PhD), and I run a profitable business on the side (selling my own software). Sometimes this is a bit stressful (when you have to prepare a talk and keep getting emails from customers because of a nasty bug you introduced in the last release), but most of the time this works out just fine.
- sunahsuh 15y agoSeconded. Some of the most successful academics I know keep regular 9-5 hours and leave their work at the office, have spouses and children, etc. I've noticed a lot of them are fantastic at time-boxing and that some of my less successful colleagues aren't so much, and the freedom the academic schedule gives them ends up being more of a hindrance than a help.
- ckas 15y agoWhich EE specializations are generally best for maximizing backup options in industry in govt/finance/data science?
- noelwelsh 15y agoIf you want a job, go get a job. Don't undertake 6 years of PhD study unless you love what you're doing.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoThat's silly. Most people with a PhD don't get academic jobs. It would be foolish not to plan for that possibility. I don't know much about EE, but I'll talk about math. It's unlikely you would enjoy research on nonlinear wave equations but hate stochastic PDEs. If one has far better job prospects, it's silly not to focus on that one unless you are dead certain you'll win the academic tournament.
- noelwelsh 15y agoPhDs make marginal improvements on one's employment prospects vs a Masters degree. If you're doing it for the cash don't even undertake a PhD. Go get an MSc, go get a job, save four years of your life. If you're gambling on getting into academia, you won't get the publication record you need if aren't motivated to do the work, and you won't be motivated to do the work if you don't enjoy what you're doing. If you don't get into academia but do have a quantitative PhD you will get a job quite easily, so why worry about your particular field. My conclusion is that there is simply no point doing a PhD unless you really enjoy the work you're doing.
- yummyfajitas 15y ago...you won't get the publication record you need if aren't motivated to do the work, and you won't be motivated to do the work if you don't enjoy what you're doing. The point I'm making is that if you are unmotivated in elliptic PDEs, you'll probably be unmotivated in control theory as well. The fact is that research is research. You might hate experimental physics and love theory, or hate computation but love experimentation, but these distinctions between subfields (condensed matter vs photonics) that seem huge in academia are not that big in reality. If these small distinctions can give you a big advantage 50% of the time, it's a tradeoff worth making.
- _delirium 15y agoIf you're in the right areas of computer science, esp. machine learning, the answer seems to be that you have to make active effort to resist leaving academia, but not much active effort to let yourself get hired away. The recruiting at grad schools and even academic conferences from folks like Palantir has gotten pretty aggressive lately! They're particularly good at supplying temptation at that moment when a student's finished everything but writing up the dissertation ("ABD").
- elazungu 15y agoI recently did a blog post about a similar issue, the tension between doing software work in academia vs in industry. In a way a kind of prequel to this post. http://elazungu.wordpress.com/2012/03/26/the-researcher-programmer-a-new-species/ http://elazungu.wordpress.com/2012/03/26/the-researcher-prog...
- sunahsuh 15y agoI recently left my PhD program too (I'm "mastering out" in local parlance ;)) and what this post doesn't address is what I found to be the hardest part: making a decision to leave a world where people that leave are construed as a failures (note: contrary to my expectation, I've only received support in my decision from my awesome and anomalous department.) (Also, I should note that I left a software industry job to do the PhD so I knew I shouldn't have difficulty finding a job.) For anyone who wants to take the leap but is afraid or unsure, I offer some words that were incredibly helpful for me from some of fantastic friends. To quote my amazing advisor from his response to my "I'm leaving" email: 'We had a Head of Department at Lancaster who used to stomp around the corridors moaning - "I've just lost another student to industry. He's got a great job, has a starting salary bigger than mine, is working on a fabulous project with better resources than we have. In what mad world is this judged as a failure?"' And another colleague, who's currently a junior professor: 'You know, most Ph.D.ers are smart and successful people. Hence they have a difficulty in saying “This is not for me”. They instead say “I’ve been successful all my life, and I finished everything I started, so I should finish this as well”. By saying that, they choose to hang in there for many years in a depressed state. Sometimes, the most courageous thing and the best thing to do is to quit when you know you would rather work in another capacity, or when you know you don’t want to work in academia. I congratulate you on your decision and I hope the best for you. ( In case you later decide to come back to academia, it will be waiting for you, so I would not worry about it.)' Best of luck, those of you that are struggling with the decision. If you're anything like me, if you decide to leave you'll feel better than you have in years =)
- eshvk 15y agoThe post is awesome. Having just "graduated" (dropped out of my PhD program) and also interviewed a bunch of really smart folks who are making the transition to the "real world", I cannot emphasize the importance of the following for a good machine learning/engineering interview: 1. It doesn't matter if you have done research in a topic, do brush up on simple machine learning algorithms. The math after going through a PhD should be really easy for you. However, it is hard for an interviewer to gauge how good your math background is when you have done most of your quantitative work in a totally different field and you don't have enough of a common intersection. 2. Write code! If you are joining a small to middling start up, even if you will eventually be doing quantitative stuff, your peers will be people from engineering and they will evaluate you as a programmer. Brushing through something like the Algorithm Design Manual is going to be amazingly useful. Back in school, there was a linguistics professor who wrote most of his code in Scala, used version control and pivotal tracker. If someone who is working towards tenure can do it, there is no excuse for you. :-) 3. Try to work on tiny projects that involve some data analysis and some programming. If you are an R guy, do it in python and vice versa. Most importantly, think of the whole pipeline: taking the data (Infochimps/ AWS public datasets), cleaning it up, processing it using a random machine learning algorithm (pick any, its an easy and awesome learning opportunity), and then visualizing it. Repeat with cooler tools (E.g. d3.js for the visualization etc). The importance of this process is that it moves you away from the traditional anonymized datasets that you see in academia and helps you encounter real world data and gain intuition for that. This is incredibly helpful in the interview process because it allows you to get good ideas about other people's data and how to think about it.
- kentonwhite 15y agoI received my PhD (Physics) in 1999 and went directly to industry. At that time I saw industry as a well paid post doc. My intention was to work a few years and then seek an academic position. In 2001 I had an offer from a top engineering school in Canada to join their faculty. And I said no. Academia attracted me with the promise of intellectual freedom -- the ability to work on what ever problems I wanted to. This is a lie. To be successful in Academia, one needs to pick a narrow field and become the biggest expert in the smallest space. Neils Bohr described this as knowing more and more about less an less until you know absolutely everything about nothing. In Industry I can move around to whatever problems fascinate me most. I've worked in Optical Componetns, designing video games, and now what I call computational sociology on social networks. My pattern has been to work in a field of about five years until I've built up the expertise I desire to have, then move on to a completely different field. For those recently dropping out of academia or considering dropping out, you know in your heart it is the right choice. Don't worry about what people in that little club think. A decade from now they will be looking at you. With envy because you are free to work on the most exciting and interesting problems while they are stuck in the same shrinking field for the last ten years.
- kmm 15y agoI'm doing a Masters in theoretical physics and I've got to ask, is it common to first go work a few years before going into academia? It surprises me how little we are informed of these things. Being locked in is my biggest fear for going for a PhD. I don't want to spend the rest of my life on a single topic, perhaps I don't even want to stay in theoretical physics.
- jakobe 15y agoI did a masters equivalent degree in theoretical physics, now I'm doing a PhD in computer graphics. A coworker who did his PhD in theoretical physics is now doing a post doc in mechatronic. Many people might specialize more and more, but if you don't like that, no one stops you from changing your field.
- kentonwhite 15y ago
- shioyama 15y agoI left a PhD program a few years back (technically graduated, but I don't think of it that way). A year or so before I did, I remember very clearly being out to drinks with my professor and fellow students, and mentioning that I had no intention to continue a career in academia. In fact at the time I was thinking of translation (I've since drifted to web development, but languages and translation are still central to much of what I do). The response (in Japanese, but I'll translate) was "what a waste" ("mottainai"). What a waste. All that potential I had, and now I was just going to waste it on "work", like everyone else. No doubt my supervisor, who said it with a genuinely disappointed look (echoed with a nod by a fellow student and friend sitting beside me, which only made it worse) meant it in a positive sense, but I never forgave him for it. It stuck with me, somewhere very deep inside me, first as something confusing and distressing, then as a kind of symbol, something emblematic of everything that is wrong with academia. To anyone who is hesitating: if your only reason for staying in academia is the fear of what will happen if you leave, then it is time to leave.
- bearmf 15y agoSeriously? Learn web development? No one hires PhDs for web development skills. It is only useful if you want to be a pure software developer, not a quant or a data scientist. It might even be a negative when applying for some jobs.
- eshvk 15y agoWell they might not be hired to do just web development but I think learning about the web stack is incredibly useful because it helps you get your work out to people. This is important especially in a (early stage) start up where you might have to rapidly prototype solutions and you can't have your own pet designer to whip up visualizations for you. In fact, if you read the blogs of some of the data scientists at twitter/linkedin, its immediately clear that they have some know-how of the web stack in the way they are organizing and visualizing results. (Everyone likes pretty pictures)
- bearmf 15y agoYou do not need to be a web developer to write a blog. R, MatPlotLib and Matlab make pretty pictures.
- eshvk 15y agoNot saying you need to be a web developer to write a blog. All, I am saying is that the web provides a way to do interactive visualizations in a manner not provided by Matlab/R/matplotlib. For example, colleague at Mozilla did this: http://skedasis.com/d3/smoothers/ http://skedasis.com/d3/smoothers/
- yummyfajitas 15y agoNo one hires PhDs for web development skills, but knowing some basics certainly opens up some doors. I wouldn't want to hire a PhD who would couldn't build at least a demo himself. Could you describe a circumstance where such skills would be a negative?
- 15y ago
- robertskmiles 15y ago> 100 passengers have queued up to board a plane, and are lined up in the order of the seats on the plane (n=1..100). However, the first person lost his ticket and selects a random seat. The remaining passengers will occupy their assigned seat if it is available, or a random seat otherwise. What is the probability that passenger 100 sits in seat 100? It really worried me that I couldn't figure out how to work that out. I thought about what I'd do in an interview if I was asked that, and I figured (if I had my laptop) I'd write some code. So I gave myself 5 minutes by the clock, and wrote a little python program that simulated the situation and counted the results. I ran 5 million iterations, which with pypy took 59 seconds. The number I got out was a 97.335% chance of person 100 being in seat 100. I have 3 questions: 1. Is that the right answer? 2. How are you supposed to work it out? 3. Would working it out the proper way take less than 6 minutes? Edit: It seemed like too high a number, which is part of why I asked. I looked through my code and found a dumb error - I forgot to remove the seat from the 'available' list if the person finds their assigned seat. That's what happens when you write code on a 5 minute deadline. Now I'm consistently getting 49.9%, which seems more reasonable.
- bearmf 15y ago1. Wrong 2. Start with 2 passengers instead of 100 3. Rigorous proof would take a bit longer, say 15 minutes
- dkokelley 15y agoI have no idea if that is correct, but my initial intuition was that it would be a high percentage like you found. However, now that I'm thinking about it, I believe the answer is closer to 50%. When passenger 100 begins to board, there are only two possible configurations he can find the seats in: seat 1 available or seat 100 available. If Passenger 1 sits in seat 100, then passengers 2-99 will sit in their correct seats, leaving only seat 1. If passenger 1 sits in seat 1, passengers 2-99 will sit correctly and leave only seat 100 for passenger 100. If passenger 1 sits anywhere else (say, seat 50), passengers 2 - 49 will fill correctly, passenger 50 will have to sit in seat 1 or 51-100. The moment a passenger randomly selects seat 1 or 100, the remaining passengers will sit correctly (except for passenger 100). It is impossible for any seats other than 1 or 100 to be left for passenger 100 to select. From looking at it, I don't believe there is any bias for the end configuration to leave seat 100 open more than seat 1, and I believe that in an interview situation, you would be expected to intuit this by "talking it out". If I'm right (and I could still be very wrong), this is more of a probabilistic brainteaser than a programming interview question.
- ivan_ah 15y agoIn my belief system, working in finance or for the industrial-military complex are //unethical// choices for someone to make. Doing a software startup is the only remaining choice for me then...
- zafiro17 15y ago"When you are ready, the teacher will appear" - Buddhist saying. Getting through a PhD is easier and more fun if your mind is into it. Yours is clearly not, so why try to swim upstream? Go where your mind and soul are telling you that you belong. If you ever decide the PhD is the right move for you, you can re-open that chapter and go for it. I'm getting ready for a change in career, and for the exact same reasons.
- evoxed 15y agoHe's using Hyde and recommending the article's audience to use Django or Rails? If he's going to point out webdev with only some fleeting interest it might be more helpful just to say something like, "HTML/CSS is your new weekend project. Hardcode it in a couple hours or use whatever system gives you the least pain: SSG, framework, blog-based, etc."
- yummyfajitas 15y agoClearly you haven't bothered to look me up. Do you believe I should have used Django or Rails for my personal website? Was Hyde the wrong tool for the job?
- evoxed 15y agoLook you up? I read the article, if that's what you mean. I use a static site generator as well, I was just curious as to why you wouldn't recommend that instead since it's powering your own site. I don't disagree, it just seemed odd.
- yummyfajitas 15y agoI'm CTO of a django-powered startup, which I link to on my website. Django is great for dynamic content, learning it will teach you about databases and help you make nice UI's. My personal site is just boring static pages. Hyde (or Jekyll, for the ruby folks) is the right tool for such things.
- evoxed 15y agoI apologize if my response offended you, maybe I can be clearer with some more detail: it just seemed odd, considering Hyde is linked on the post and Styloot is not (and even there, the only way I know that it has anything to do with django is by finding it under technologies used in your resume). If you want to become a web developer, then sure– django or rails, take your pick (or anything other framework that suits your fancy, though I too would go with django). But that wasn't your point. >No one hires PhDs for web development skills, but knowing some basics certainly opens up some doors. I wouldn't want to hire a PhD who would couldn't build at least a demo himself. Some basics would include HTML, CSS, and Hyde as well, no? Especially if the point is to give yourself a proper web presence such as your own site. I was wrong to call it a 'fleeting interest', that was simply my impression from only looking at the post. However, if you're willing to expand on that bit it would probably be beneficial to those who aren't already aware since they're your target anyway. Aside from all of this, thanks for the Software Carpentry link– this should come in handy the next time I try to help someone dive into programming.
- Rickasaurus 15y agoJust tossing in that Finance isn't your only option for a healthy PhD paycheck in NYC. With exactly those same skills you could work in silicon alley or at a company like mine which does analysis on bank (or other corporate) data. Also, you don't have to sell your soul to work outside of Academia. For example, we find terrorists and drug lord hiding cash in USA banks (Anti-Money Laundering) using machine learning. It's very satisfying and the pay is good too.
- bearmf 15y agoWhere are all this high paying jobs? Average data scientist salary at glassdoor is probably less than 100k.
- Rickasaurus 15y agoGlassdoor doesn't seem to give me any salary results for "data scientist" in NYC.
- bearmf 15y agoYeah, sorry, these hits were some other scientists. So what is the pay like in NYC?
- yummyfajitas 15y agoFor data scientist, probably $100-150, and it can definitely go up.
- msellout 15y agoThe market isn't clearing right now. There are "data scientists" without jobs and there are companies without data scientists. Companies who can pay in that range can hire. Data people who can ask for that salary can get jobs. Sorry if that's cryptic.
- eli_gottlieb 15y ago
- wallflower 15y agoI know a tenured professor who is well respected in his niche of engineering specialization. He has attracted several million dollars in grants. The research center he runs, in his words, is a startup with his own hard working employees. Why work like you are working at a startup in some research lab with no stake?
- pgbovine 15y agoI know this is cliched, but of the ~30 students who started the Computer Science Ph.D. program at Stanford in 2006 with me, maybe 10 have dropped out. A few of those ten have gone onto successful startups and are now far, far, far wealthier than any of us who remained in the program could hope to be :)
- xxbondsxx 15y agoThis is an interesting sample. What happened to those who dropped out but did not strike it rich in Startupland? I think one of the hardest parts about leaving is showing that you are moving onto better things; it's easier to _tell_ people you are leaving if you have a 150k+ offer. Leaving to try a startup would be socially difficult to communicate
- hagy 15y agoWhat about negative anecdotes? Has anyone here regretted his or her decision to leave academia? Particularly, have you found the work less rewarding or interesting? I ask as a grad student with a background in chemical engineering. I’ve known two professors who’ve done the inverse – industry to academia – and they’ve provided convincing stories for academia. In both cases they found academic research (in engineering and the physical sciences) to be more interesting and personally rewarding than industry. Is the situation different in software and related industries? I ask, as I’ve been considering transitioning to such a career myself after grad school (my research is in computational modeling and simulation). My biggest fear is that I’ll find myself in a job that I find boring and will regret my decision. Doubly so, as such a career transition will make it very difficult to reenter my academic field.
- eli_gottlieb 15y ago>What about negative anecdotes? Has anyone here regretted his or her decision to leave academia? Particularly, have you found the work less rewarding or interesting? I left academia after undergrad, despite applying and getting into graduate school. My degree is in Computer Science, my specialty track was Programming Languages and Compilers, and my senior thesis was in Systems Programming Languages. I had job offers and eventually took one. What I found was that industry is smug, deceptive, fad-driven, cares nothing for fundamental problem-solving until you pay them for it, and (of course) near-fatally infected with live-to-work-ism and the Californian Ideology. * Smug: despite many of them having MSc degrees or being PhD drop-outs, most of the professional programmers I've met deride research itself as essentially pointless. Someone once asked me point-blank at lunch why I wanted to publish an invention/discovery of mine in a research paper, why I didn't just go found a start-up based on it. My discovery is in type theory: not exactly the most amenable field for using Ruby on Rails to pump out a "minimum viable product". Further: type-theory results are mathematical rather than empirical, the proofs have to be checked. Peer review has its just place in the world, and thus so does Research Science. * Deceptive: many of the people I met did not know or care whether their software served its intended purpose well, or whether that purpose was a good purpose, or whether (provided it was a good purpose, which I shall note that, say, investment banking isn't) it can be served well. The hiring binge I saw was completely uncorrelated to having an actual workload for the people they wanted to hire. The idea seems to have been to hire everyone's Hackathon friends. * Fad-driven: look at the ads for hiring "rock-stars" and "ninjas", and then realize that most of these people earning six-figure salaries just build web-sites or silly mobile applications. Who thought Groupon was a good idea (I'll note that I never did)? Why should everything be an ad-based web application to the point that things other than ad-based web applications simply don't get built that often anymore? * Cares nothing for fundamental problem-solving: Industry is infected with marketer-thinking (trying to please a perceived primary market of investors and secondary market of customers) rather than fundamental business-thinking (building cars instead of faster horses). The industrial programmers who can possess substantial skill in fundamental Computer Science, or who solve problems in Computer Science, are a vocal but still small minority. Think of Steve Yegge and his "cat-picture problems," and remember that Steve Yegge is talking about major companies like Google and Facebook spending their energy on cat-picture problems. * Live-to-workism and California Ideology: I was astounded and offended to find myself hearing hour-long talks between otherwise intelligent, humane and respectful coworkers on libertarianism and Austrian economics. Further, the software industry is powered by "passion" (a component of the Californian Ideology), which has mostly just become an excuse for long, unbroken workdays, fanboyish loyalty to employers/companies, and programming-centered social events outside work. The programming profession expects you to love your job, no matter what it is. Not enjoy, not like, not perform competently, love. The assumption is that if you didn't love what you were doing, you would leave. Never mind real life, where the state of one's bank account is more than just a way of keeping score, programming jobs are clustered in some of the world's most expensive metro-areas, people have families, and they may have moved to enter their programming job. I'm not quite back in academia yet (only admitted to one graduate school so far, with non-guaranteed funding, two other applications still pending), but I'll be damned happier when I get back there. And of course, unbias this anecdote by accounting for its kvetchiness and negativity, because you asked for a negative opinion about industry.
- waterhouse 15y agoJeeeeesus christ, that grep is ugly. grep "[0-9]\{3\}[-]\?[0-9]\{3\}[-]\?[0-9]\{4\}" filename.txt The default behavior of grep appears to be to not treat {}?() as special characters. Which is generally boneheaded in my experience, and certainly in this case. An irritated man will use egrep--short for grep -E, "extended regexes"--i.e. sane regexes: egrep "[0-9]{3}-?[0-9]{3}-?[0-9]{4}" filename.txt This is just a direct translation. If I wrote the regex myself, I would probably also recognize spaces as delimiters (as in "999 999 9999"), and maybe note that the area code might be missing or have parens around it, etc.--depending on just what I was trying to parse. I dunno, maybe he's parsing regular machine output and his original regex would suffice, so I won't go farther than an equivalent translation. But I will, for kicks, mention this: egrep "([0-9]{3}-?){2}[0-9]{4}" filename.txt (Note that - is not a special character in either grep or egrep, although command-line programs in general treat specially any argument beginning with -, so it is a good idea to use [-] instead of - if that happens to be the first character of your string. But after that, no.) Also, for general purposes, grep -P (Perl regexes) is best of all, because it can do *? non-greedy matching. A really irritated man has aliased pgrep to "grep -P --color=auto" in his bash startup file, and has also (perhaps dangerously) aliased grep to it as well. (That breaks fewer things than altering GREP_OPTIONS.)
- dude_abides 15y agoHere's a simple checklist for all you CS (Systems) PhDs not sure what to do next. When writing a paper, which section of the paper are you most excited by? A) Introduction (big picture/motivation/related work): You should remain in academia where you will enjoy writing grant proposals, or be a senior exec (not hands-on) in industry. B) Design/Implementation: Academia is not for you. Join a cool startup or Google/Facebook/... (or of course start your own venture) C) Experimental Evaluation/Results: Join industry (tech or finance) in a quantitative role. YMMV. Also, this is not applicable to PhDs in Theoretical CS or in other Sciences.
- deleted 15y ago[deleted]
- gammarator 15y agoPhDs interested in data science job may find the Insight Data Science Fellowship a good opportunity: http://insightdatascience.com/fellowship.html http://insightdatascience.com/fellowship.html It's a paid six week post-doctoral training fellowship in SV that ends with interviews with companies looking for data scientists.
- imaginaryunit 15y ago"In academia, the end product is a publication and your code needs to work only once." In my experience as ex-academic, the above is all too true in too many computational fields (and many sub-fields of CS). So I ask what scientific value (or any kind of value, for that matter) is being generated by grinding out publications with results that won't be repeatable?
- a_bonobo 15y agoDepends on the journal you're publishing in. Lots of journals (at least in my biological sciences field) require you to submit your code along with your publication so that a) the editor can repeat your results to accept your publication and b) for other scientists to repeat your stuff. Biostatistics AFAIK has an editor responsible solely for reproduction of results. Personally saying lots of my code is repeatedly re-used by colleagues who can't program, for example scripts that parse BLAST-output and get the best result for each query etc.
- imaginaryunit 15y agoYour point is well-taken and (thankfully) there are safeguards in place at top journals. However, Rob Tibshirani examined this a while back with a case study and came up with some unsettling conclusions about reproducibility: http://www-stat.stanford.edu/~tibs/FL/report/ http://www-stat.stanford.edu/~tibs/FL/report/. The case study highlights the importance of debugging not only code, but also the entire experimental process.
- a_bonobo 15y agoTrue! If you want a newer example, here's a very recent paper which looks at the results of a couple of RNA-Seq-papers and after being able to reproduce only 12% of the results, concludes that they all used the wrong assumptions in their statistics: http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fjournal.pgen.1002600 http://www.plosgenetics.org/article/info%3Adoi%2F10.1371%2Fj... Which shows that the editor really needs to know what's going on and why in each paper - I don't think every editor can know everything about his or her field.
- MisterMerkin 15y ago>Also, if your degree is in English, the best I can do is point you here [Tired, old, and stereotypical Starbucks link Hurr durr]. Really? Was that necessary? Why can't someone with an English background learn to code especially with burgeoning fields like NLP.