3 ms·
> Ten thousand attempts but you didn't seem to feel that the specifics of a single one would illustrate your point? Do I need to? The Soviet Union, Communist C
by WalterBright 3y ago
> Ten thousand attempts but you didn't seem to feel that the specifics of a single one would illustrate your point?
Do I need to? The Soviet Union, Communist China, North Korea, Cuba, Pol Pot's Cambodia, Venezuela, Chile's regular dips into Marxism, the Summer of Love in Seattle, the Summer of Love in San Francisco, Woodstock, and the Jamestown and Plymouth settlements.
The kibbutzen require state subsidy to operate, funded by taxes levied on capitalist businesses. Otherwise they'd all starve.
> except in a handful of TNG episodes
Those are the only ones I saw. I stopped watching STTNG after it became less about scifi and mostly about pushing a narrative. From each according to his ability, to each according to his need.
Marxism is the opposite of free markets.
> remotely Marxist about it
The capitalist Ferengi with their ugly faces and sharp nasty teeth said it all. The Enterprise community was the post-Marxist world where everybody was equal and everybody shared and pulled together.
> You're objecting to utopianism.
Marxism is utopianism.
- maxbond 3y agoHey unrelated but check out Star Trek Deep Space Nine. I think you'll enjoy it. It's sort of a criticism of the utopianism in previous Star Treks. It's gritty and the characters have to make hard choices, where "everybody wins because it's a utopia" isn't an option. Some characters are literal terrorists and the show does a pretty good job of letting that be morally gray. It asks the question, "what happens when a utopian society must go to war? Is the benevolence a facade masking a core which is authoritarian or fascistic?" If you only watch one episode, make it "The Siege of AR-558." You once told me in Memphis Belle you could see the "fear in their faces, the bravery, the hurt, the relief." Actors of course can't do what documentary subjects can, but that is what this episode aims for. Also check of Andromeda. It's similarly critical, it's like Star Trek if it was a dystopia where the federation had collapsed because their utopianism had made them vulnerable to betrayal by their closest allies (who are literal nihilists). My understanding is Roddenberry came up with the idea but passed away before it could be realized. It asks the question, "okay, we have this techno-utopian concept, but how does that grapple with the existence of evil in the world?" Don't sleep on TNG either. Did you watch until the Borg were introduced? The Borg are a foil for the Federation I think you'd enjoy, a dystopia of enforced uniformity, a grotesque socialism. Each receives according to their need and gives according to their ability, but through means sickening and unconscionable. Skipping around to just the Borg episodes might be interesting. That reminds me of Animal Farm, a novel I bet we've both enjoyed. I'm due for a reread. I'm sorry if I said anything hurtful or frustrating. I hope next time we see each other around HN there won't be hard feelings. I consider your commentary on the intersection of aviation and software development to be must-read, and I have a lot of respect for you.
- maxbond 3y agoI've been reading a book I saw recommended on HN called The Chuang Tzu. I'm reminded of a story in there, where the author character berates someone who smashed all of the gourds they had grown because they couldn't fit them neatly into the categories of gourd they imagined useful. "Clearly," chides Chuang Zhou, "your head is full of underbrush." I thought if I pointed out the underbrush you'd see it was obscuring your vision. But now I wonder if maybe you regard what's beyond as an eyesore, and the underbrush as a tool to keep it from your view. Maybe you're right, maybe it's more important to be happy than to see clearly. I wish you the best.
- WalterBright 3y ago> Maybe you're right, maybe it's more important to be happy than to see clearly. The historical record of Marxism/Communism is quite clear. I'm curious what you'd think of "critical thinking experts" who theorize that the Earth is flat, write Nebula award-winning novels about flat Earths, etc.?