6 ms·
The Homomorphic Encryption patent land rush
- noonespecial 15y agoLets get together and fool the patent lawyers into thinking that quantum teleportation of matter is just around the corner. Perhaps they'll spin their wheels adding "...but with teleporters!" onto the end of every conceivable human activity and let us makers get some work done.
- Natsu 15y agoThe functions necessary for some of these "inventions" might not even exist. So this might end up being almost as good in the end.
- ddlatham 15y agoEven better, if we can get speculative patents now on all sorts of future technology that will take at least 20 years to develop later, the patents will all be expired by the time the tech is ready.
- stcredzero 15y agoThe thing is, companies often keep patents alive by coming up with little variations or extensions of existing patents. The fact that people can speculatively patent anything to begin with is a glaring sign something is severely broken. (Do a patent database search for Internet and Video. Note how many and how vague they are and how far the dates predate Youtube.)
- beatle 15y agoa patent on homophobic encryption? patent lawyers are shameless!
- willvarfar 15y agoI wonder if this prevents this area being researched and discovered?
- gcp 15y agoNot so much in academia. But yes, this would hamper or delay practical/field deployment. See EC crypto etc.
- tptacek 15y agoECC is widely used in industry. DJB seems skeptical of its patent encumbrances: http://cr.yp.to/patents.html http://cr.yp.to/patents.html I do agree there was a time when ECC patents were an issue (particularly Certicom's), but it was certainly not as big a deal as the RSA patent.
- jandrewrogers 15y agoNot necessarily. There are an unlimited number of algorithms available to implement any particular concept so people are always looking for faster, more efficient algorithms for implementing the same mathematical concept. However, the marginal value of doing the R&D to find additional algorithms diminishes as more are described even if they all are patented. This is not a side effect of patents per se but a side effect of how algorithm research works. Companies often spend millions of dollars on the computer science R&D required to generate a new algorithm so there is a return on investment calculation. For the R&D to be worthwhile, they either need to produce an equivalent new algorithm for less money than licensing it or believe that they can find a materially better algorithm than the current licensable algorithms such that they have a market advantage. It is very similar to chemical process R&D.
- johnpaulett 15y agoGranted, I am neither a patent expert nor a homomorphic encryption expert, but how is this patentable since homomorphic encryption is just a mathematical formula? From Wikipedia [1]: Homomorphic encryption is a form of encryption where a specific algebraic operation performed on the plaintext is equivalent to another (possibly different) algebraic operation performed on the ciphertext [1]: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homomorphic_encryption http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homomorphic_encryption
- mistercow 15y agoThe general rule in the US patent system is that mathematical formulas are not patentable, and so neither are algorithms. But a device or system that uses an algorithm is patentable. So they don't patent the algorithm itself, but "a method and system". In other words they're patenting the idea of running the algorithm on a computer. Insane, yes, but upheld by current precedent.
- brlewis 15y agoIn the Bilski case, the Supreme Court reminded us that Benson, Flook and Diehr are still good precedent. So patenting the idea of running the algorithm on a computer is also not upheld by current precedent. Oh, they also said to ignore State Street, the precedent that upholds software patents. But they're just the Supreme Court. Nobody listens to them in this area anyway. I know I sound sarcastic, but I'm serious.
- mistercow 15y agoI had forgotten about Bilski. Still, if the courts don't listen to a precedent, is it really a precedent?
- excuse-me 15y agoYes, all you have to do is hire more lawyers than Apple/IBM/Microsoft or whoever. Go to court in East Texas and persuade a jury that a bunch of damn Yankee judges up there in Washington know better than an honest American corporation.
- ktizo 15y agoWell, if no solution exists, I am going to patent the business process of finding a solution to homomorphic encryption. My process largely involves hiring mathematicians and buying lots and lots of coffee.