4 ms·
> Is it possible to teach students critical thinking? I doubt it. Universities claim to teach it, but I don't see it in the graduates. Consider designing airp
by WalterBright 3y ago
> Is it possible to teach students critical thinking?
I doubt it. Universities claim to teach it, but I don't see it in the graduates.
Consider designing airplanes. (I.e. engineering.) If the result doesn't fly, no amount of rhetoric will convince anyone otherwise. This is not true of the humanities, where educated people can and do convince themselves of endless bad ideas.
I'll take the reality checks of engineering over "critical thinking".
- maxbond 3y agoOnce I was riding a train, and the conductor announced that only some cars would open their doors at the upcoming station, because the train was longer than the platform. "I wonder why?" A stranger mused. "I know," her companion sneered, "it's because some engineer designed it." She wasn't wrong per say, an engineer had designed the platform - a hundred years ago, for a different train. The train we were riding had squeeked through the legislature on a shoestring budget, reusing the existing tracks and with only a few new platforms slated to be built. And many of those were axed along the way due to budget overruns and such. It was a political miracle the train existed at all. But this passenger wasn't really looking for context. She had stereotypes and narratives that explained the situation to her satisfaction. Are you quite sure that you are engaging your faculties of critical thinking here, rather than relying on narratives and stereotypes? Does it really seem likely to you that the people doing the work you're most familiar with are the only people capable of thinking critically? Or that the feedback loops that you've had in your career are the only ones available?
- WalterBright 3y agoLet me put it this way. Marxism doesn't fly, and nobody has yet found an example of it flying. But academics continue to push Marxism. That's a massive failure of critical thinking by the people who teach it. As for engineers, they make mistakes all the time. And the mistakes are very hard to talk one's way out of. Our society is built by engineers making things that work. Your car doesn't move by talking it into moving.
- maxbond 3y agoI've definitely met annoying Marxists who say things that you just don't know how to respond to because they're disconnected from reality. But I've also met Marxists who weren't weird tankies, who regarded eg the Societ Union as a failure which demanded their ideas be revised. I've heard the complaint that Marxist academics are corrupting the youth many times but I just don't see any evidence for it. No one I met in school was a Marxist. And not to Godwin the conversation but it's uncomfortably close to the literal Nazi conspiracy theory/propaganda of Cultural Marxism, close enough that I suspect this is the original source of the idea (which is, to be clear, a comment on the heritage of the idea, and not a comment about you or anyone else who holds the idea), so I just can't really give much credence to it. And it feels like we're discussing politics rather than critical thinking here. I think it's valuable to have your ideas challenged and to respond to some kind of feedback loop. Reality provides pretty good feedback loops, we're in agreement there. But there are plenty of times when you can talk your way into a bad engineering decision. Not to touch a nerve, but Boeing talked the FAA into approving various bad decisions about pilot training and tolerating a single point of failure around introducing MCAS to the 737 MAX. You might say this is an exception that proves the rules because they did result in an accident, but then why shouldn't we extend that same grace to the Marxists who aren't weird tankies? I think you're discounting other forms of feedback. In the social sciences you often have limited empirical feedback because you can only analyze natural experiments, and because it's very difficult to infer a cause from statistics alone. But I think you overstate the extent to which rhetoric dominates and reason is subordinate. Sophistry doesn't have an infinite hold across space and across time. Maybe you are able to talk someone into believing a bad theory; that doesn't mean you can convince everyone or that they'll stay fooled forever. You clearly have ideas about topics in the social sciences, at a minimum that Marxism is a failure. And I believe I've seen you comment about monetary theory. So you think that these things are epistemologically tractable, right? That it's possible to know these things? So why shouldn't it be possible to organize a field of inquiry into these topics? And if it's so vague and vulnerable to sophistry, how can you be sure you haven't been taken in yourself?
- WalterBright 3y ago> demanded their ideas be revised. There have been many variations on Soviet Marxism. They all failed, too. > I've heard the complaint that Marxist academics are corrupting the youth many times but I just don't see any evidence for it. Ask any of them how the free market works. They have no idea. The latest generation of youth have leaned quite a bit left. > And it feels like we're discussing politics rather than critical thinking here. Sort of. My thesis is that if someone actually applied critical thinking, they'd reject Marxism. I cannot fathom how someone can claim to be educated in critical thinking yet embrace Marxism, a system that fails every time it has been tried History is full of examples. Did you know that the US has had over 20,000 communes tried? With a 100% failure rate. > why shouldn't we extend that same grace to the Marxists who aren't weird tankies? Because they've had the grace. It still doesn't work. > how can you be sure you haven't been taken in yourself? Tens of thousands of attempts to implement Marxism, with a 100% failure rate. > No one I met in school was a Marxist. Most Marxists deny they are Marxist, but when you listen to their philosophy, it's Marxism. BTW, there is one sphere where Marxism works. Hollywood. Hollywood loves to crank out shows where Marxism works. One of them is Star Trek. Before you all jump on me, I'm a Trekkie myself! But come on. The Enterprise is the perfect Marxist society, presided over by the incorruptible benevolent dictator. His loyal comrades are all selfless, also incorruptible, and utterly lack any ambition whatsoever other than serving the ship. Everyone selflessly shares equally. There's no money, and no crime. The bad guys, the Ferengi, are (naturally) capitalists, with their ugly faces and pointed teeth. They are always wrong about everything.
- trollerator23 3y agoI don't understand why you spend time arguing with these privileged white kinds who never knew a hard life or arbitrary government oppression. (They could easily be Chinese government trolls too) The rest of the world is clearly tripping over each other to come here, particularly from those wonderful Marxist utopias. (Me being just one little example). Just let them whine.
- WalterBright 3y agoI saw the Berlin Wall in its heyday, and I went through Checkpoint Charlie and toured East Berlin. East Berlin was such a utopia the Communists would shoot anyone who tried to leave. That says all one needs to know about Communism.