3 ms·
Interesting that it uses helium. With a helium shortage [1], I'm concerned about the long-term viability of an airship - so I ran some numbers to understand it
by philip1209 3y ago
Interesting that it uses helium. With a helium shortage [1], I'm concerned about the long-term viability of an airship - so I ran some numbers to understand it better.
Helium is used in medical applications for cooling magnets in MRIs - I found the quote "An MRI unit requires approximately 2,000 liters of liquid helium to keep the magnet cool enough to operate." [2] This is interesting to be because, in a helium shortage, healthcare applications probably get high priority.
Liquid helium has an expansion ratio of 1:745 [3], so the 2000 liters of liquid helium for an MRI is the equivalent of ~1.5 million liters of helium gas.
I can't find the exact volume of helium the Pathfinder 1 requires, but their website says "Pathfinder 1 is 400 feet long and 66 feet wide" [4], which modeled as a cylinder gives a displacement of about ~38 million liters.
So, my rough estimate is that an airship needs as much helium as ~25 MRI machines (with a high margin for error).
To me, that seems like a lot of helium - I bet society would prefer 25 MRIs to 1 airship.
[1] https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/helium-shortage-doctors-are-worried-running-element-threaten-mris-rcna52978 https://www.nbcnews.com/health/health-news/helium-shortage-d...
[2] https://www.rsna.org/news/2023/january/helium-shortage-for-mri https://www.rsna.org/news/2023/january/helium-shortage-for-m...
[3] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_ratio https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Expansion_ratio
[4] https://www.ltaresearch.com/faq https://www.ltaresearch.com/faq
- shipscode 3y agoI doubt society cares that much about MRIs seeing how wasteful they are when used for preventative care. I’ve personally witnessed people get 5 MRIs to diagnose a health condition and still come up short. I’d rather we let Sergei fly his balloon. Maybe if we run out of helium doctors can go back to working instead of helping their imaging partners make bank on MRI machines.
- mensetmanusman 3y agoIt will have on-board nuclear plants to generate helium /s
- jazzyjackson 3y agoisn't the helium shortage affected by the market price of helium? just like we were afraid of peak oil until we broke through the price barrier to distilling oil from tar sands and suddenly there's plenty of oil to go around as long as people are willing to pay $80/barrel ?
- timbit42 3y agoIsn't the liquid helium used in MRI machines captured for re-compression and re-use?