3 ms·
Lewis has had a real knack for picking problematic protagonists in his later career: * The Tuohy family for Blind Side * Kahneman and Tversky --- not really p
by tptacek 3y ago
Lewis has had a real knack for picking problematic protagonists in his later career:
* The Tuohy family for Blind Side
* Kahneman and Tversky --- not really problematic as people! but right in the middle of the reproduction crisis in their field
* Brad Katsuyama, yeesh, who is also the reason Lewis was set up to do a hagiography on SBF
* SBF, of course.
I agree with the "man, can Lewis write" sentiment! He can! You know who else can write, extroardinarily effectively? Malcolm Gladwell. Gladwell is less problematic than Lewis (I can't even imagine Gladwell dismissing Michael Oher as suffering from CTE the way Lewis recently did), but it's an article of faith here that Gladwell isn't worth reading, and not so much with Lewis.
So I think your problem with a book like Going Infinite is: SBF is obviously an interesting subject for a book, and, because Lewis was pre-sold on/to him, he had extensive access, and Lewis can definitely write. So if you're the kind of nerd we all are, you're inevitably going to get a bunch of "good stuff" from the book, and you're not so much going to get bogged down in the deeply problematic circumstances of its authorship and intent because you've already got all that context in resident set in your brain, you know SBF is a crook, you don't have to worry that Lewis is trying to paper over that stuff.
But I think when you're considering the book purely on its merits, that context starts to matter just as much as how good the writing is. This book is getting trashed for I think very justifiable reasons.
- yellowstuff 3y ago1) Kahneman had a chapter in his book about social priming, and endorsed the subfield, which was totally decimated by the reproduction crisis. But Kahneman himself didn't research social priming, and I don't think any of his research with Tversky has been challenged by the reproduction crisis. I think it's unfair to say he was "right in the middle" of it, unless I'm missing something. 2) What's wrong with Katsuyama? If you mean IEX was a dumb idea and HFT is good for markets overall then I agree with that. I think that just means Katsuyama is wrong and self-serving, not problematic.
- tptacek 3y agoRight, so my meaning here is subtle: that it makes a problematic subject for a book intended to have a clear protagonist, not that Katsuyama is a bad person (I don't know anything about them beyond the book).
- yellowstuff 3y agoGotcha. I agree that the main premise of Flash Boys was wrong, HFT is unambiguously better for retail traders than the market makers that preceded it.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- throw0101a 3y ago> So I think your problem with a book like Going Infinite is: SBF is obviously an interesting subject for a book, and, because Lewis was pre-sold on/to him, he had extensive access, and Lewis can definitely write. I've heard the remark: some books have an unreliable narrator,[1] Going Infinte has two: SBF and Lewis. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unreliable_narrator https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Unreliable_narrator