7 ms·
GFiber Labs announces first project: 20 Gig with Wi-Fi 7
- xnx 3y agoMy first connection was a 28.8kbps (advertised) modem, so I am very appreciative of my current connection speed, but I'm still very jealous of those with access to Google Fiber and a 240x faster connection than I have now.
- mchristen 3y agoIt's not all sunshine and rainbows though. I've been lucky to have Google Fiber for a number of years and I still get buffering issues with YouTube and YouTube TV.
- elteto 3y agoI'm still salty about Google Fiber. So much potential and Google just... gave up on it? Google giving up on things is basically a meme now, but back then I couldn't really understand why. Customers raved about it, everyone loved it. You could see the entrenched ISPs in an area magically drop their prices whenever Google Fiber came into town. Then they started facing regulatory hurdles thrown by the incumbents and it felt (or I felt) at that point that they just didn't want the fight. I couldn't understand, this absolute behemoth of a company, just laying down and giving up.
- artimaeis 3y agoIt seemed like they'd given up in 2016 with the announcement to stop expansion. But it seems like they've got the ball rolling again, probably at a slower pace. They announced last year that they're expanding into 22 new areas. Recently here in Charlotte NC they have rolled out access to 5 and 8 Gbps connections. More than I have need for (I don't want to upgrade to > 1 Gbps networking haha), but great to see the investment.
- toast0 3y agoIf you think about why Google was doing Google Fiber, it was to increase users' bandwidth, not really to take over home internet service. Their announcement of city selection resulted in incumbents in those selected areas doing rollouts even before Google could get site selection done. At that point, the mission was accomplished, and Google didn't need to do anything. But, they can't really do that trick a second time, so everybody else is slowly waiting for the existing lines in the ground / on the poles to deteriorate to the point where incumbents have to rollout new stuff.
- elteto 3y agoBut at the same time, they always have struggled in finding alternative verticals to make money from, outside of search and ads. That’s why I always thought their end goal with Fiber was to own the pipe and whatever else was at the other end. They could have become a major ISP in the USA.
- wmf 3y agoBut broadband can't generate Googly margins and they failed to find breakthroughs to reduce fiber costs.
- arebop 3y agoCloud also can't generate Googly margins but they're willing to invest in that.
- toast0 3y agoCloud margins are pretty big. Or they should be given what they charge.
- xboxnolifes 3y agoGoogle already works at a cloud level. I wouldn't be surprised if Google cloud isn't part R&D for internal systems.
- godelski 3y agoI always thought of things like Fiber, Fi, Auto, etc as more "pressure" projects. AT&T is the only service provider in the area and charging $50/mo for up to 20mbps download? Bring in Fiber, and within a few weeks of announcing AT&T introduces a 1Gig plan for $60/mo. I watched this happen in the wild. But the thing here is that anyone being on the internet benefits Google because how much control they have over it. Same goes for phones/android. Auto increases maps (even 3rd parties buying data from Google maps and using it in their own map system). But it is bittersweet. Because it only works if people buy into the google product but then google often does a rugpull. I think most people are probably better off but there are definitely casualties.
- tadfisher 3y agoI think the costs were just too much to expand as rapidly as they wanted. They experimented with "nanotrenching" in Louisville, burying cable directly in 2-inch-deep channels directly in the road surface, which ended up in disaster [1]; shortly after, they "paused" expansion, fired their CEO, and went through layoffs. 1: https://gizmodo.com/when-google-fiber-abandons-your-city-as-a-failed-experi-1833244198 https://gizmodo.com/when-google-fiber-abandons-your-city-as-...
- dead4today123 3y agoI lived in Louisville when this happened, and met the guy who came in second place for Louisville portion of Google Fiber. 1. Yes, the microtrench became a disaster, because the material they used to cover the drench stuck to people's tires when it was hot outside and it pulled up. Paving over it would have solved the problem 2. Google chose to hire a lawyer to run the project. The second place guy had installed fiber his entire life, had personal relationships with the people that owned the right of ways to connection poles (ISP). The ISP folks did not like the lawyer and did not work with him and that's why it really died. (according to mr. second place)
- tadfisher 3y ago> Yes, the microtrench became a disaster, because the material they used to cover the drench stuck to people's tires when it was hot outside and it pulled up. Paving over it would have solved the problem Paving it over would mean digging the trench deeper, meaning it's no longer a "nanotrench" (Google's experiment) but a "microtrench" (a very popular method of fiber deployment). These are trenches that are cut down below the road surface (12-24 inches), filled in, and paved/sealed on top to match the road surface. For this you need conduit, filler material, asphalt sealant, and a bit more labor.
- heroprotagonist 3y agoThat was the point they decided to give up on wires and invested in SpaceX with the intent of blasting the internet into space. Like.. that'd be faster than dealing with the government at every single pole within disputed territory like they had been. Getting the incumbent to come out at a pre-agreed time to be there and check the site before they worked or assist, for example. So they took a moonshot instead. Seems like its starting to work?
- eqvinox 3y ago> GFiber will be one of the first ISPs to deploy Nokia’s 25G PON technology, Ah yes. PON. The technology designed to block out competitor access to fiber infrastructure. The technology that has been deemed illegal to use by the incumbent in Switzerland¹ because of that. Why exactly is this using PON? [¹] https://www.swisscom.ch/en/about/news/2021/10/05-entscheid-bvg-glasfaserausbau.html https://www.swisscom.ch/en/about/news/2021/10/05-entscheid-b...
- sschueller 3y agoOnly thanks to Init7 for taking them to court. That is one of many reasons I use them as my ISP. Thanks to the ruling Init7 can provide 25gbit today to existing and new p2p connections. All p2mp will be converted in the few years to p2p as well. Init7 has said they are looking into 100gbit as those BiDi modules have become available and the cost has also come down.
- jeffbee 3y agoA court ruling doesn't magically put glass in the ground. Isn't there truth to the Swisscom statement that forcing p2p means fewer people will have access?
- sschueller 3y agoThat is not true as the state wants the expansion and the state is also providing money for it. Also all the illegally installed p2mp that hasn't been activated while the case was going on will need to be converted and Swisscom isn't going to leave those connections lying around. The expensive part of running the fibers into the home is done and is the same for p2p as p2mp. It is only the fiber on the street that needs to be expanded.
- alex_suzuki 3y agoJust here to say that Init7 is awesome. I‘ve been on both their private and business products for years. Very competent and reponsive support by actual humans. You even get a fixed IPv6 „subnet“ for free. I have yet to find a use for it though.
- theideaofcoffee 3y agoUgh, I see PON, my eyes roll. I know it's all the rage for fiber providers since it's cheap, but it's a cop-out and a cheap-out. All new fiber deploys should have home runs. Fiber is so incrediblyt cheap it's stupid not to do so. Otherwise you'll just be stuck with the idiocy of having to manage the worst of both cable in sharing bandwidth in some situations and WDM in having to manage x8 or x16 or even x32 splits and associated power budgets. It's just a lose-lose, even if it's 25G!!!111. Build it right or don't do it at all.
- RationPhantoms 3y agoThis is a hilariously bad take. PON works well for residential and SMB last-mile connectivity. Especially compared to the shitshow that is coaxial troubleshooting.
- ksec 3y ago>This is a hilariously bad take. I am starting to think if I should completely give up Hardware topics on HN. 4G/5G ( 3GPP Rel ), WiFi ( 802.11 ), USB, Thunderbolt, CPU, GPU, FPGA, DSP, Foundry, PON, DOCSIS, DRAM / NAND, Display...... It is getting ridiculous the amount of noise Vs signal in these topic. The only good thing left is at least we still have enough people coming out to correct all the Anti-GPON misinformation.
- eppp 3y agoIf GPON or XGS ends up being a mistake, it can be fixed pretty easily as long as they didn't do distributed splits. As it stands currently, GPON itself is very much overkill in our deployment.
- throw0101c 3y ago> Build it right or don't do it at all. Or build what you can afford/finance now, and expand later. There's no technical reason why active fibre can't first be deployed to the node or curb or top of the street first, with PON going down the rest of block/street to begin with. This allows for must of the gains over co-ax and especially DSL. If Internet use cases ever reach the point where an entire street or floor of an apartment/condo is contending for the full bandwidth of a 25Gb PON fibre run, they can then perhaps split from (say) 1:32 to 1:16, 1:8, etc until each customer gets an individual run. There's only a finite amount of capital, and spending for individual runs for early deployments may delay other people. IMHO it will be a number of years before people can regularly saturate >1Gbps, and much longer before 10Gb use-cases start appearing. As it stands HS-PON (ITU G.9804) can do 50/50, 50/25, or 50/12.5: * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higher_Speed_PON https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Higher_Speed_PON 50Gb split by 32, is 1.5625 per customer before contention starts. Are there particular use-cases where a sustained 1.5Gbps (up and/or down) is not sufficient in 2023? Of course it may be possible to burst higher if the rest of the fibre isn't busy. I currently have 1Gb, and software updates certainly come down faster than my previous 25Mb VDSL, and 4K YT videos don't buffer as much. Though I'm not sure if things would be materially different than if I had (say) 'only' 500Mbps.
- Youden 3y agoFor anyone unfamiliar, PON means that several users will be physically spliced onto one shared fibre. In most of the deployments I'm aware of, it's 32 users per fibre. It also requires specific hardware, not standard off-the-shelf SFP modules like normal FTTH deployments. I suggest "20 Gig" with PON should come with a massive asterisk; when you read "PON", you should think "Comcast" because you're about as likely to get the advertised speed from PON as you are from Comcast.
- rbranson 3y agoYou're always sharing bandwidth. It's not like you have committed capacity end-to-end to every site on the Internet.
- shepherdjerred 3y agoAs much as I hate Comcast, I never had a problem getting the advertised speeds from them.
- piperswe 3y agoI'm on AT&T PON and I get higher than I pay for (I pay for 1Gbps and regularly get 1.2Gbps+ through a 5GBase-T link). It helps that I live in a small town and my neighbors aren't very noisy (in a networking sense)
- tadfisher 3y agoWhat companies do "normal" FTTH deployments? My only other experience is with Quantum (née CenturyLink, née Quest), who definitely use GPON.
- eppp 3y agoI know of a few coops that did active ethernet for future proofing after they got badly bitten by DSL. I doubt they even got that close to paying for the DSL rollout before they ended up ripping it all out for fiber.
- throw0101c 3y ago> It also requires specific hardware, not standard off-the-shelf SFP modules like normal FTTH deployments. What is a "normal FTTH" deployment? What percentage of residential deployments are PON versus non-PON? Because I was under the impression that PON was the (vast) majority of residential fibre deployments, in houses and apartments/condos. And by 'standard OTS SFTP' do you mean Ethernet? Because the IEEE has their own PON standards, but also once you get outside the data centre, office building/tower, or campus, there are all sorts of 'different' technologies you tend to have to deal with WANs depending on distance. We recently switched ISPs at work, and our 10Gb link was a BiDi single-mode fibre and we were provided with a media convertor from which we connected our router-firewall. Depending on distance desired you may (>80km) have to start getting into coherent equipment or optics (CWDM, -ZR).
- leetharris 3y agoI have had Google Fiber in Austin for years and it has been horrible. They farm so much out to third party contractors who have no idea what they are doing. I've had so much downtime (over a month total in the last 2 years) and support just sends the same couple of guys out every time. The first time he showed up, he said that the LED on the front of the router was dim (which it wasn't, exact same from day 1) which indicates it is faulty. Not only does this make no sense, but they have replaced it 4 times with no luck. They downgraded my plan from 2gb to 1gb to "fix" the problem which stopped the constant downtime, but significantly downgraded the quality of the connection and massively increased my latency. I've tried to get them to do anything beyond just replacing my router over and over again, but they just keep sending me to another automated system which sends out the same guy who thinks the LED being dim is the problem. I had ATT Fiber for years before this without a single issue. And because Google Fiber basically bought out the neighborhood I have only one provider option now. Just like everything else Google does, there is horrible support, it is as automated as possible, and if you have any kind of problem you're basically out of luck. When it works it works, but anyone who has ever had trouble with a Google product knows exactly what I'm talking about. When they announce stuff like 20gb connections I can't help but laugh at how insane it is considering they can't get a reliable 2gb connection to one of their pilot cities they've invested billions into.
- 71a54xd 3y agoIt is kind of insane that I had to create a new google account just to change addresses... to another address that had actually had google fiber two years PRIOR to my existing apt... It's insane to me that a company like Google couldn't figure this out. Also, when I created the new account I was locked out of google payments for 2 days because they thought someone was pretending to be me (after I made the new account). Huge nightmare but at least my 2G fiber works.
- verall 3y agoI have gfiber in Austin and it's fantastic, and if I really wanted to I could still get ATT fiber or spectrum cable. How did gifber "buy out the neighborhood"?
- aseipp 3y ago
- 71a54xd 3y agoCan't wait for them to bring this to Austin!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- dmonitor 3y agoI love my google fiber. AT&T forced me to use a massive, shitty all-in-one modem router wifi access point when my fiber was through them. You could put it into passthrough mode, but if it reset for any reason you’d lose your config. Google just gives you a small wall component and an IP address. Whether you use their router is your business. It’s fantastic.
- jeffbee 3y agoThis is how all reputable ISPs operate. My Sonic service just terminates at the wall. They will provide equipment but you can equally well bring your own.
- eppp 3y agoWe provide equipment because 99% of our customers don't want to deal with it. They just want wifi and a decent connection that isn't DSL speeds. I will do a passthrough port if someone really wants it but you are getting an ONT regardless so I can signal test and get outage notifications.
- SparkyMcUnicorn 3y agoWhen I had ATT I told them my gateway was broken and to send a tech out. When they showed up I asked for a dedicated ONT setup, which he was happy to do and asked for a tour of my homelab. Maybe I was lucky and they don't carry that equipment around anymore.
- throw0101c 3y agoSee also IEEE 802.11ay: > 802.11ay is a type of WLAN in the IEEE 802.11 family of Wi-Fi WLANs. It's an improvement on IEEE 802.11ad rather than a new standard.[3][4] It has a frequency of 60 GHz,[5] a transmission rate of 20–40 Gbit/s and an extended transmission distance of 300–500 meters. It includes mechanisms for channel bonding and MU-MIMO technologies.[2] It was originally expected to be released in 2017, but was delayed until 2021.[6] * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ay https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ay * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ad https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/IEEE_802.11ad (precursor) * https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WiGig https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/WiGig (marketing name)
- ksec 3y agoI know 802.11ay, but what has this got to do with the article?
- Balvarez 3y agoCan't wait to not get it in Nashville, except for a couple of buildings.
- jeffbee 3y agoI wonder what the CPE looks like. It must be an integrated ONT+WiFi right? Getting 20gbps from an ONT into a router would be a challenge for UTP.