2 ms·
You are misreading it. Blackburn is not comparing in state and out state. He's talking exclusively about out of state. The state has no power to regulate out o
by ars 15y ago
You are misreading it.
Blackburn is not comparing in state and out state. He's talking exclusively about out of state. The state has no power to regulate out of state companies. No matter how much the state wants to, it just doesn't have that power.
What Blackurn is saying is that the regulations are imposing burdens on those retailers, and the the state has no legal right to do so.
- dkrich 15y ago> The state has no power to regulate out of state companies. No matter how much the state wants to, it just doesn't have that power. I don't think that's an accurate interpretation. I believe what the judge was saying was that the law, as written, was vague and put an undue burden on out-of-state retailers. That is unconstitutional because it discriminates against a set of retailers by forcing those businesses to complete a unique burden (complex paperwork) that in-state retailers do not. Essentially, the law was intended to create an incentive for internet retailers to collect sales tax by requiring that they complete a ridiculous procedure if they do not. That is the undue burden.
- rprasad 15y agoAll states have the power to regulate companies doing business in their states. However, they cannot discriminate against out-of-state businesses. The same laws must apply to both in-state and out-of-state businesses. Unfortunately, by virtue of their business model, catalog/on-line stores must be discriminated against because they do not operate in the same manner as physical stores.