6 ms·
A bus/tram that shows up every 3 minutes (average wait time 1.5 minutes) is going to generally beat dispatched self driving cars in terms of convenience. 20 bu
by Retric 3y ago
A bus/tram that shows up every 3 minutes (average wait time 1.5 minutes) is going to generally beat dispatched self driving cars in terms of convenience. 20 busses per hour is a completely reasonable level of service for most of the day in a major city and doesn’t need any kind of routings because swapping lines has such a minimal wait time.
However, if you’ve only experienced terrible public transit then it seems like you need fundamental change rather than simply doing the same old things just better. Self driving seems like a solid fit for 2am, but driving empty vehicles only makes congestion worse.
- alooPotato 3y agoyou still have to get to bus stop
- Retric 3y agoSo walking 100-200 feet vs waiting longer, entering your destination, paying more even after checking multiple apps for pricing… I am not in great shape but I know which I prefer.
- alooPotato 3y agoshow me an american city where a bus stops every 100-200 feet every 3 mins. Heck show me where it'd even be possible in an american city. That sounds like the most inefficient bus ever.
- Retric 3y agoThat’s a bus stop every ~1/8th of a mile not 200 feet. You cut it in half because you can walk to the closest stop and cut it in half again before you’re starting at a random point not the worst possibility so 5280/8/2/2 = 165 feet. Except we don’t exit buildings or get on busses in the middle of the street so it’s not random.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoAny bus that has stops every 100-200 feet is unbearably slow. Even every 1/8 of a mile is too much to be an time efficient mode of transportation unless you have BRT imo.
- sk0g 3y ago(On average), for a walk to the stop of 100-200 feet the bus would need to stop every 200-400 feet. 300 ft seems to be roughly 100m, which is probably much too short a distance still. 250m or ~800 ft aligns better to my experience with cities with good transit, and in the worst case scenario you have to walk 125m to your nearest stop.
- Retric 3y agoAlmost. 1/8th of a mile is every 660 feet, but the farthest you can be from one is the midpoint so 330 feet. However for every trip starting at the midpoint there’s another at and the bus stop thus the average would be 1/2 that distance again or 165 feet. Assuming a 1D world, you can beat this in practice.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Retric 3y agoI’ve said it several times but you average ~165 feet when walking to a stop every 1/8th of a mile. Max is 1/2 the distance because you can walk either direction and average is again 1/2 the max because you start at a random point not the worst possibility. 5280/8/2/2 = 165. As to unbearably slow, there’s this idea of express busses and buss only lanes etc. The core of cities really isn’t that big, it takes forever because traffic is slow or mass transit is infrequent.
- HDThoreaun 3y agoFair enough. Not familiar with SF bus system but the bus system where I live, which is considered quite good I think, has each bus line 1/2 mile apart from each other. Almost no one lives directly along a route so there's an extra 1/8 mile average walk just to get to the route, not a stop on it. Fine by me but a lot of people don't seem capable of that for whatever reason. Combine that with the bus not actually going to where you're trying to get and I can see why people aren't huge fans.
- tbcj 3y agoIn September, the rides I took in Cruise required walking farther than multiple bus stops.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoIn San Francisco the current standard is 800–1,360 ft between bus stops depending on the grade. Street car stops are every 2–3 blocks. The MTA's spent years trying to cull stops because many are much closer than that, so no… walking to a Muni stop in San Francisco is perhaps one of the easiest things you can do in the city. Edit: ca. 2008 the policy was 800–1,000 ft for bus stops and 1,000–1,200 ft for street car stops. On grades between 10–15% the standard is 500–600 ft for bus stops, and on grades above 15% the standard is 300–400 ft. Trunk routes have 24x7 service, and (I can't find it now) there are standards about the amount of service on the other routes but it's something along the lines of 80% of residences are supposed to have frequent service ~18 hours a day and reduced service in the wee hours. Currently the tightest headway I can find is 8 minutes for travel during peak hours along the busiest routes. Muni is often inefficient but it can get you pretty much anywhere in the city (including places you can't walk to like Treasure Island) for most of the day. Edit: For reference San Francisco is roughly 7 miles by 7 miles. So you're talking about transiting halfway across town. Cars (with or without drivers) are competing for the same right of way as the bus, so more of them will simply slow everyone down. A 60ft bus can fit, what, about 100 people? A self-driving car can fit, what, 5? The current quantity of Lyft/Uber/Waymo/Cruise vehicles already has a negative impact on traffic. Put enough self driving cars on the street to make up for the capacity that buses provide and you're going to make traffic much, much worse.
- alooPotato 3y agoTwo really popular locations, 3 miles apart, with a direct bus route servicing them and still 40 min travel time. This doesn't work: https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dolores+Park,+Dolores+St+%26,+19th+St,+San+Francisco,+CA+94114/Marina+District,+San+Francisco,+CA/@37.7768012,-122.4338673,14.93z/data=!4m14!4m13!1m5!1m1!1s0x808f7e1779aa70a7:0xa618e4eff1228d60!2m2!1d-122.4271145!2d37.7597704!1m5!1m1!1s0x808580d79ae5a51b:0x3c50fe8f3930832!2m2!1d-122.4370011!2d37.8043849!3e3?hl=en&entry=ttu https://www.google.com/maps/dir/Dolores+Park,+Dolores+St+%26... I'd argue that we'll be able to make this much better with driverless cars than with public transit.
- Panzer04 3y ago
- csharpminor 3y agoA respectful culture is needed for public transit to properly function, and the Bay Area doesn’t have that. Some behaviors I’ve seen on public transit in the Bay Area: loud music, dumping beer and food on the floor, clipping toenails, smoking, jumping up and down on seats, drug deal, fighting, hitting the driver, attacking the bus with a machete. All in the past year. Granted I take transit more than most. And people are generally afraid to speak out against bad behavior because you never know when someone has a knife/gun and is mentally unstable. So I don’t think it’s just a frequency/headway problem. I wish it was better, but I also understand why many people are decide they’d prefer a private car.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoOh whatever. Short of attacking the driver I saw most of that in a relatively short stay in Paris. So, yeah, okay that kind of behavior drives people to private vehicles… where the anti-social behavior involves shooting at each other or running people off the road. e.g. https://www.ktvu.com/news/15-month-old-baby-riding-in-vehicle-shot-in-oakland https://www.ktvu.com/news/15-month-old-baby-riding-in-vehicl... https://sfstandard.com/2023/08/02/man-flashes-gun-drives-backwards-in-bernal-heights-road-rage-shooting/ https://sfstandard.com/2023/08/02/man-flashes-gun-drives-bac... https://sfist.com/2023/06/27/chp-investigating-alleged-road-rage-shooting-on-i-280-in-san-francisco/ https://sfist.com/2023/06/27/chp-investigating-alleged-road-... https://sfist.com/2023/09/06/road-rage-shooting-on-i-280-in-san-bruno-leaves-one-man-injured/ https://sfist.com/2023/09/06/road-rage-shooting-on-i-280-in-... https://news.yahoo.com/sf-road-rage-suspect-leads-040649333.html https://news.yahoo.com/sf-road-rage-suspect-leads-040649333....
- eindiran 3y agoA road rage incident where someone pulls out a gun is notable enough to get a newspaper article. Phone snatching, seeing people smoke meth on BART, encountering disgusting things, etc, etc are daily occurrences. This is not an apples to apples comparison.
- inferiorhuman 3y ago
- xnx 3y ago> driving empty vehicles only makes congestion worse. The number of empty bus seats I see go by is astounding Those buses take up a lot of road space and block arterial traffic when people are boarding.
- bluGill 3y agoBuses that look empty generally have 5 people on them, and so are still more efficient use of space. Either that or at the end of the route and will soon turn around and fill up again.
- justinclift 3y ago> A bus/tram that shows up every 3 minutes (average wait time 1.5 minutes) ... is a completely reasonable level of service for most of the day in a major city When living in London a few years ago (clearly a major city), the wait times between buses were pretty short. They might have been about 6-10 minutes for some of the more central areas (rough guess from memory). I'd be surprised if they were "every 3 minutes (average wait time 1.5 minutes) though". Meanwhile, in Melbourne and Sydney though (substantial cities, but not London sized) the buses are more like 1/2 hour apart. In Brisbane (capital city of the state of Queensland, Australia) the buses are 1 hour apart, and seem to stop about 7pm each night.
- lozenge 3y agoI'm in London and every 4 minutes isn't far off. I live in suburbia like most people and can walk 10 minutes to a high street where there and multiple routes at 8 min frequency each way, which overlap for large parts of their route, therefore some journeys really do have a bus every 3 minutes. And if it's a journey from central London to central London then there's going to be 2+ routes that serve every journey.