9 ms·
Those sound like trips where you shouldn't call a car at all, but get on the local transit service. Talk to your local politicians about fixing service so that
by bluGill 3y ago
Those sound like trips where you shouldn't call a car at all, but get on the local transit service. Talk to your local politicians about fixing service so that is an option.
Self driving cars are useful to replace various maintenance or delivery trucks in cities, and farm transport. However mass transit is better for most things people are thinking about them for.
- alooPotato 3y agothis is satire right?
- pj_mukh 3y agoAre people this incredulous about public transit? I love autonomous cars, but its not scalable at all. Its obvious to me that public transit is the real future as the population grows.
- alooPotato 3y agoI think if you were building a city from scratch, it's arguable that self driving individual pods is the way to go for the most convenient AND most efficient door to door transport. Maybe you disagree, but its not important because we're not building cities from scratch. For existing city infra and politics that we have, I think self driving is def the best way to go. Suggesting that an individual should lobby their gov't to fix public transit seems like lower probability of success than voting with their wallet for longer self driving trips. Public transit isn't one of those things that can be incrementally fixed. Self driving cars on the other hand can incrementally make everything better, that's why its so appealing imo.
- pj_mukh 3y agoI mean maybe if you're a small town and want to stay a small town. Large cities, should definitely drive most transportation away from personal vehicles/pods. Its simply a space/first principles issue [1]. The math seems 100x less scalable, simply because you hate being around other humans (in which case what are you doing in a big city anyway). [1]: https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8456/7999510360_8e46299621_z.jpg https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8456/7999510360_8e46299621_z....
- alooPotato 3y agoI always see that image referenced and it's kind of BS. it assumes the buses are filled to the brim constantly but the cars only ever have 1 person it. It also doesn't take into account the transport to and from your door on both ends. It also doesn't consider the inefficiency in wait time. The ideal transport would be a cocoon just big enough for you to fit in that picks you up at your door and gets you to your exact destination with minimal energy overhead. I'd argue a self driving car is much closer to that ideal and we can iterate our way much easier to it than public transit.
- pj_mukh 3y ago"It also doesn't take into account the transport to and from your door on both ends." This type of design is terrible for average health outcomes [1]. We should not be optimizing for this. Walking to the bus stop is a good outcome. We should optimize for better more frequent bus routes, but "door-to-door" is unnecessary and counter-effectual. The rest (iteration speed, filling a bus to the brim etc.) are just political problems just as intangible as "lets build better roads (public infrastructure) for autonomous cars", so we can put that aside. [1]: https://www.bu.edu/sph/news/articles/2023/us-neighborhood-walkability-influences-physical-activity-bmi-levels/ https://www.bu.edu/sph/news/articles/2023/us-neighborhood-wa...
- alooPotato 3y agowe don't have to couple exercise with transport. We don't say planes are bad because it reduces the number of cross country hiking trips people take. On filling a bus, I think its a fundamental shortcoming of having fixed routes that they'll never be as efficient as point to point transport, especially electrified transport. i'm not really making a political argument.
- pj_mukh 3y agoI agree with the second point but given as 80% of city transports post-covid is back to being fixed commutes along fixed routes, I'm happy optimizing that along transit ways. I don't really care what happens with the remaining 20%. Right now, nearly 100% of travel is with "personal cocoons", totally unnecessary (other than for political reasons) and creating immense downward pressure on health and social outcomes. In terms of levers the government has on health and social outcomes, transitway design is a big one, and it should use it. The fact that its done badly in America is a political problem, and if you have any political power it should be expended fixing that, not rolling back public transit.
- bluGill 3y agoPods are not the most efficient transport. It is simple geometry. Here is an expert in the field going into more detail. https://humantransit.org/2011/03/how-universal-is-transits-geometry.html https://humantransit.org/2011/03/how-universal-is-transits-g... (read the rest of this site too - lots of good stuff there)
- alooPotato 3y agoI don't see anything in that article that actually states efficient transport. It's just a long winded way of saying that there are a lot of factors in network design. kind of a useless article imo
- bluGill 3y agoRead it again and apply the geometry lessons to pods.
- palata 3y ago> Self driving cars on the other hand can incrementally make everything better Except for energy consumption. If we were in a world were fossil fuels were unlimited and climate change was not a thing, maybe I would agree with you. But we are not. We need to get much more efficient with energy, and cars just can't do enough. Better accept it earlier than later and start building public transports wherever it's possible.
- alooPotato 3y agofor city driving, electric vehicles are crazy efficient. the energy is negligble. basically all the driverless cars are EVs.
- viraptor 3y agoThat's an interesting claim, but have you got numbers to back it up, compared to bus networks which are also largely electric/hydrogen in most recent deployments?
- alooPotato 3y agoGoogle says it costs roughly 4 cents a mile to charge a tesla model 3. Most city rides are a couple of miles so its a really really small fraction of the cost of trip cost (even if you price at public transit prices)
- palata 3y agoCan we talk about energy, and not price? And compare the consumption of a Tesla Model 3 with the average number of passengers (< 1.5?) versus the consumption of electric public transit?
- alooPotato 3y agoWhy? You can convert energy to cost and back - its all the same energy source for EVs vs public transit. Ultimately cost is what matters anyways. Who cares if the energy requirement of public transit vs an EV has a huge delta (spoiler: there isn't a huge delta in terms of energy per passenger mile). They are both super low and efficient.
- snovv_crash 3y agoThat sounds like hell. More areas should be walkable and bikeable. Motorized vehicles should be limited to minimal areas so that the rest is quiet, safe and accessible. European cities have it right here - underground transport and quiet walkable surface level.
- alooPotato 3y agoi like tunnels too. Just put cars in them that can easily transition to surface streets for door to door. Bikeable/walkable cities are not an argument against quiet, cheap, ubiquitous, efficient driverless EVs.
- tanseydavid 3y agoCan you expand on that a little bit? What are the reasons that you believe that AVs are "not scalable at all?"
- pj_mukh 3y agoThis picture makes it clear, for the most part. Public transit is a pareto improvement on personal driving pods in terms of scalability. Especially for fixed commute routes. https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8456/7999510360_8e46299621_z.jpg https://farm9.staticflickr.com/8456/7999510360_8e46299621_z....
- Tiktaalik 3y agoRegular cars aren't scalable at all. AVs are not any different than regular cars. In fact AV will increase the amount of cars on the road as more people that can currently not drive, such as children and the elderly, are now more likely to use a relatively low occupancy AV. So we can expect transit to get worse as AVs become prevalent. The only scenario where AV may scale better than cars is if we're talking about autonomous buses, and that will only perform better if they are given the other features of public transit, such as dedicated lanes, which require set routes, and we're pretty much just talking about public transit in general at this point.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- fshbbdssbbgdd 3y agoIf the bus had dynamic routing, so it could show up where I am when I’m ready, and take me where I want to go, I’d be a huge fan. I don’t mean this ironically! I think dynamically dispatched, self-driving buses and vans will eventually save public transit. They’ll enable a much higher quality of service than current bus systems. Which drive around mostly-empty stopping every few blocks so it takes forever to get anywhere.
- Zigurd 3y agoAVs should in principle liberate public transit from a lot of limitations. Surge capacity should be easier to deploy. Smaller busses on smaller routes should be at less of a cost disadvantage. Pick up and drop off could be more flexible. I live in a semi-rural area that used to have a trolley line to the next town where one could catch a train into Boston. It's also a challenge to optimize school bus routes in a sparsely populated area, and AVs could help with that.
- alooPotato 3y agowe've had uber pool for a while. if that's your definition of public transit then sure, self driving pooled cars would obviously be good.
- harambae 3y agoOddly enough they got rid of both Uber Pool and Lyft Shared in most cities. Definitely Boston, but also half a dozen other cities I've visited. It may still exist somewhere. I wish they hadn't, because my commuter card works with the shared rides. So even if a shared ride was the same price as a normal Uber/Lyft (or even more) I'd do it just to be able to use the commuter card.
- xnx 3y agoWas this a covid thing? I wish they would bring it back.
- 3y ago
- minwcnt5 3y agoIt's pure fantasy to think public transit can replace all/most car trips in American cities, even in most of SF. It's not just a matter of "fix service", it's you need to completely rebuild the city with 5-10x the population density.
- alooPotato 3y agowell said
- reverius42 3y agoDoesn't even need to be 5-10x the population density. The "inner ring" of Paris is similar density to San Francisco and supports a metro system that I think most would agree makes car trips unnecessary. But the "rebuild the city" part might still be somewhat necessary.
- pj_mukh 3y ago" it's you need to completely rebuild the city with 5-10x the population density." Which..is exactly what is going to happen [1]? [1] https://www.californiacitynews.org/2021/09/california-says-goodbye-single-family-zoning.html https://www.californiacitynews.org/2021/09/california-says-g...
- BytesAndGears 3y agoLiving in a European city and relying 100% on public transit and walking, with occasional biking for longer distances, it’s easy. It does not require 5-10x the population density, maybe just 2-3x, at least compared to San Francisco (which is already somewhat dense in parts). It is not a major shift in lifestyle easier. The tallest buildings in some cities in the Netherlands are 2-3 stories, and those cities still have regular buses, trams, and trains. There are even some suburbs full of single family homes, with yards, which still have buses every 8 minutes all day long, and long-distance commuter train service every 20 minutes. Yes the US needs more density for this to be feasible. But San Francisco isn’t that far off on the density that it would needs
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- mikebenfield 3y ago> Talk to your local politicians about fixing service so that is an option. Lots of people have been trying to get decent public transit in US cities for decades. There is so much resistance it often seems impossible. So, yes, obviously public transit would be great. But right now, and for the foreseeable future, it's just not an option for most people. "Talk to your local politicians about fixing service" sounds delusional to be honest.
- bluGill 3y agoA small minority has been trying. A larger number of people (but still a minority) get interested in it, but they don't care about fixing transit. They just care about shoveling money to someone else (unions, contractors, artists...) and transit is one way to do that.
- fragmede 3y ago> Talk to your local politicians about fixing service so that is an option. Did you just tell me to go fuck myself? I'll take the bus when the bus route is convenient, which is usually, and I'll take Uber/Cruise/Lyft when I'm in a hurry and it's not. I prefer public transportation but I'm more practical about it. Which includes electric scooters (Spin/Lime), or vespa scooters (Revel).
- bluGill 3y agoIf you don't make an effort nobody will and the world gets worse '
- School-Cotton 3y agoI agree with you in the abstract. The reality of the US political and administrative system is that it’s not possible to build new public transit, but it is possible to develop self-driving cars.