> I will say there is a difference between very impulsive attempts at ending ones own life during a dark episode and more pre-planned attempts. I'd argue that

> I will say there is a difference between very impulsive attempts at ending ones own life during a dark episode and more pre-planned attempts. I'd argue that the people who are seeking out and participating in online forums looking for tips or directions for building devices to allow them die on their own terms aren't "very impulsive attempts at ending ones own life" Nobody should make the decision to end their life impulsively, and preventing people from being able to access information on the topic may actually cause people to act without due consideration. I'd much rather have people taking the time create accounts, reading posts from others who are struggling, and gathering information on what to do or not do then going over that information as they evaluate their options. "keeping knowledge contained" could mean people doing whatever comes to mind the moment it enters their head.