7 ms·
LIGO Surpasses the Quantum Limit
- Zamicol 3y ago"frequency-dependent quantum squeezing" Very exciting!
- speedylight 3y agoI mistakenly read that as “frequency-dependent quantum sneezing.” I should go to sleep…
- femto 3y agoSqueezing has been around for a while, in that I remember studying it in 1989. Squeezing means you can go below the limits imposed by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle for a short period of time, provided the average uncertainty is above the limit. It seems that LIGO is using squeezed light in their interferometer. [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squeezed_states_of_light https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Squeezed_states_of_light
- vlovich123 3y agoMore specifically it looks like they can do squeezing dynamically around a target frequency whereas before they had to pick a fixed frequency a priori.
- eigenket 3y ago> Squeezing means you can go below the limits imposed by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle for a short period of time This is not entirely accurate. The Heisenberg uncertainty (or Schrödinger/Robertson) uncertainty limits still work. If you somehow break those limits you disprove quantum mechanics. Squeezing just reduces the uncertainty in one observable by increasing the uncertainty in the other observable.
- xref 3y ago> provided the average uncertainty is above the limit > reduces the uncertainty in one observable by increasing the uncertainty in the other observable Seems like you’re both saying the same thing with different wording
- eigenket 3y agoI somewhat disagree. You can check out the Heisenberg uncertainty principle here https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Uncertainty_principle As you can see there is no mention of time in any of the standard inequalities (excluding the energy/time "uncertainty principle" which is not relevant here). You can not go below the limit imposed by the Heisenberg uncertainty principle for any duration of time without disproving quantum mechanics. What LIGO does is break some metrological "limit" which is derived by combining the uncertainty principle with some assumptions about what your measurement procedure looks like and what your states are. Unsurprisingly if you use different states you can break this "limit".
- nyssos 3y agoIt's not an average. The limit is σ_x * σ_p >= hbar/2, where x and p are any two conjugate variables.
- omgJustTest 3y agoThis is a better interpretation and also conforms to experimental / theoretical backing that tries to deemphasize “time” as a measurable. Refining the time metric in the Heisenberg limit to be couched in entropy is also common. Time is not really trusted as a fundamental quantity due to lack of observerless descriptions, and entropy and time have ultra similar properties, and indeed may be fundamentally linked. They both seem to flow in one direction and are impossible to reverse in the absolute sense. The point of “squeezing” is to push a lot of uncertainty in one variable so that one could measure much lower variance in the other variable post-squeeze… both pre and post squeeze are Heisenberg bound, but post-squeeze uncertainty is lower than pre-squeeze and therefore “under the limit” pre-squeeze. When I spoke to ligo for a position they were talking about amplitude / phase uncertainty trade offs.
- tzs 3y agoThe articles says it originated theoretically in the late '70s, and was first demonstrated experimentally in 1986.
- rpmisms 3y agoSo the "Heisenberg Compensators" in Ster Trek's transporters now have a basis in reality. Denise and Mike Okuda should be proud.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- queuebert 3y agoSeems like 'limit' is a misnomer here.
- magicalhippo 3y agoIt's a limit similar to how the resolution of a N-bit analog to digital converter (ADC) is limited to 1/2^N. You can break that limit by adding noise, known as dithering[1], to get even better resolution. Like with the squeezed light in LIGO there is no free lunch, but the idea in both cases is to pay for the lunch with something you have plenty of or otherwise don't care that much about, rather than your limited amount of money. With dithering you have to filter out the noise, but if your ADC can sample faster than you require then you just oversample and average. For LIGO they care very much about the phase accuracy but not so much the amplitude, so they pay by having worse amplitude certainty[2]. [1]: https://www.allaboutcircuits.com/technical-articles/what-is-dithering-using-noise-dithering-for-eliminating-the-quantization-distortion/ https://www.allaboutcircuits.com/technical-articles/what-is-... [2]: https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/video/ligo20231023v2 https://www.ligo.caltech.edu/video/ligo20231023v2
- queuebert 3y agoI would argue that dithering is fake resolution, so you're not exceeding the limit in the information theoretic sense. Perhaps a better analogy would be compressed sensing on a sparse, structured signal where you can seemingly violate Nyquist but only because you have additional information about the sampled signal.
- tomaszs 3y agoI wonder if there was a collision of super heavy black holes, would we feel the gravitational waves by ourselves
- platz 3y agono
- fooker 3y agoIf you're close enough to feel gravitational waves, it's unlikely for humans (or even planets) to survive intact.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoI don't think so, or as someone else pointed out, it would rip the earth apart before we felt it. I'm no physicist, but, the earth is massive so is influenced a lot more by external gravity than the specs on its surface that are people. Take the moon, it's a huge object hovering over the planet (effectively, it's slow moving, the earth rotates underneath it), its gravity pulling on seawater and causing ebb and flow. But we cannot feel its gravitational effects ourselves.
- jjk166 3y agoColliding super heavy black holes wouldn't do it. For us to feel a gravitational wave, it's wavelength would have to be small compared to a human body, which in turn means the pair of bodies emmitting those gravitational waves would have to be separated by at most a few meters, but supermassive black holes would merge long before they got to that point. Indeed a pair of bodies capable of producing gravitational waves with both the frequency and the amplitude probably can't physically exist. One could imagine though some configuration of many pairs of black holes, orbiting at different frequencies to interfere with one another and produce a sharp beat, perhaps with other mass configured to act as focusing lenses. Still almost certainly wouldn't exist in nature but a cool potential scifi concept.
- avmich 3y agoI think it's better to write 10 quadrillions rather than 10 thousand trillions. Also I think frequency and power measurement precision are not mutually limited by the Heisenberg principle, as E = ħω .
- Cerium 3y agoAs awkward as "thousand trillion" is, trillion has the advantage that it shows up in the news on a regular basis. I can much better be impressed by cutting a hair by a nation's debt than I can by cutting the same hair into a quadrillion pieces.
- trickstra 3y agoI'd say that people who read about LIGO and quantum limit, also understand quadrillion.
- mikhailfranco 3y agoSome countries have national debt in the quadrillions, e.g. Japan and Indonesia.
- _Microft 3y agoNope, use scientific notation if numbers become so unwieldy.
- Cthulhu_ 3y agoDepends on the audience. Laypeople generally know numbers up to a trillion, hence the choice of language. I only happen to know what a quadrillion is because I've played Cookie Clicker. I have trouble with scientific notation, because I'm not a scientist or mathematician and have no interest in it. TL;DR, know your audience and cater to them if you want people to be interested.
- mnw21cam 3y agoThe problem is that "billion" and "trillion" mean different things to different people[0]. In my opinion they should be regarded as unreliable words and never used. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Long_and_short_scales
- stevebmark 3y agoI hate LIGO because it shouldn't work on paper, and few seem to actually understand it. 1. If you have a light wave in the universe, and you "hang" a mass by each valley and trough of the light wave, and then you squash and stretch the universe, the masses stay connected to the valleys and troughs of the light wave. Said another way, when you squash and stretch space, lightwaves within that spacetime are also squashed and stretched. 2. LIGO claims to work by measuring the squashing and stretching space with light. However, as we just learned, squashing space also squashes light waves. So the LIGO arms and light waves in the arms are all compressed together. Said another way, LIGO can't work because the ruler itself is squashing as space squashes, so you can't measure if space is compressing. LIGO does work, but if you can't explain how it works despite this description, then you don't understand LIGO.
- karlshea 3y ago> LIGO does work, but if you can't explain how it works despite this description, then you don't understand LIGO. So uhh... how does it work in spite of that description?
- nyssos 3y agoIt has two arms at right angles to each other, and measures the difference between the two length changes via laser interferometry. This gets you the component of the wave polarized along the corresponding axes. No clue why GP thinks it "shouldn't work": it's an extremely difficult engineering problem, but the physics of it is relatively straightforward.
- karlshea 3y agoThanks!
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoYeah, the physics is straightforward. Even "laser interferometry" is super simple to explain. It is getting enough resolution and noise immunity from laser interferometry where all the interesting stuff is.
- hereme888 3y agoWhat is the purpose of this? How does this benefit the inhabitants of Earth? I don't have a PhD, so I can't come up with a reason for it.
- ImHereToVote 3y agoWhat's the purpose of a baby? Is it just a future worker, or does the baby have intrinsic value?
- hereme888 3y agoI'm asking an honest question, not slandering the scientific endeavor.
- h4kor 3y agoWhat purpose did the moon landing have? It didn't benefit anyone! But the surrounding research and advancements in all scientific fields did!
- bobsmooth 3y agoThe point of science is to learn. Maybe there's nothing practical to LIGO, maybe in 200 years we have artificial gravity. There's no way to know.
- hereme888 3y agoThanks. It just seems so far out to me that I have a hard time envisioning why spend time and energy in this.
- eigenket 3y agoA reasonable mental model is to view LIGO as a (weird) telescope. Most telescopes work by detecting some form of electromagnetic waves while LIGO works by detecting gravitational waves, but its purpose is pretty much the same as any telescope. To tell us stuff about what is happening out in the universe.
- peter_d_sherman 3y ago>"Now, writing in the journal Physical Review X, LIGO researchers report a significant advance in a quantum technology called "squeezing" that allows them to skirt around this limit and measure undulations in spacetime across the entire range of gravitational frequencies detected by LIGO." Gravitational frequencies -- now that term is going into my 2023 lexicon... (Note that I don't know what it means, just yet -- but it sounds like it could be useful in the future; it sounds like there is an interesting idea (or a series of interesting ideas) there...)
- Vecr 3y agoIt's just the frequency of a gravitational wave, it's not very impressive.
- peter_d_sherman 3y agoI don't believe that I stated an opinion relating to the impressiveness or non-impressiveness of the phenomena (or the purported phenomena) as the case may be... "Interesting" != "Impressive". What would impress me however (greatly I may add!) -- is if you knew how an average experimenter with, say, $100 or less of lab equipment -- could create and test (and therefore know to be real) gravitational waves -- without relying on, or repeating any news articles or other secondhand information source... In other words, with respect to gravitational waves, "I want to see them with my own eyes" -- to believe them... The problem with the media today is that everybody parrots what everyone else is saying (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_(media) https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Echo_chamber_(media) ), nobody seems to think for themselves, and it seems that very few people do actual firsthand experiments to verify media claims... I'm not saying that gravitational waves don't exist -- far from -- but the standard of proof I require is via firsthand experiment -- rather than secondhand hearsay about someone else's experiment... Firsthand experiments usually lead to greater understanding -- whereas secondhand hearsay usually leads to greater confusion... So, show me a guaranteed experimental way that someone with $100 or less of lab equipment could create their own gravitational waves with (and subsequently know them to be real via their own firsthand witnessing of one)... and I'll be impressed! Very impressed, in fact!