4 ms·
Cancer is a pretty major health concern for most people and the idea of this general treatment is interesting even if it’s understood to be a very hard problem.
by acdha 3y ago
Cancer is a pretty major health concern for most people and the idea of this general treatment is interesting even if it’s understood to be a very hard problem. HN also has a lot of people who have worked in or adjacent to scientific research so I think there’s always an appreciative upvote for something which starts to look like positive results from something generations of scientists have worked towards.
- elromulous 3y ago+1 Also something showing positive results in humans. So many things have been cured in mice, but don't translate.
- pie420 3y agoAny major examples? I've heard a lot about animal trials succeeding and then the human trials failing, but would love to read into it if you have any sources.
- refurb 3y agoBut what makes this unique versus the hundreds of other early studies that show "encouraging results"? The technique of CAR-T isn't exactly groundbreaking any more with 3 products already on the market. And the ORR of 59% is kinda of in line with current CAR-Ts. I'm going to ESMO and this would be interesting but certainly not the highlight of the data releases. Don't get me wrong, this may turn out to be very exciting, but it's very early data, and similar to other development programs has a 90% chance of failing.
- f6v 3y agoCAR T hasn’t achieved much success in solid tumors yet. Making it work for non-blood cancers would be truly a major milestone for humanity.
- acdha 3y agoYour initial question was why the link was getting upvotes. I don’t think anyone is claiming it’s a medical revolution but a lot of people have or know someone who has been affected by cancer, and anything which offers hope for the future is going to get attention. I don’t mind that, it’s a pleasant change from yet another JavaScript framework.