4 ms·
> "Governments, companies and investors need to get behind clean energy transitions rather than hindering them," Mr Birol said. Well, yes. There's a lot of inv
by pjc50 3y ago
> "Governments, companies and investors need to get behind clean energy transitions rather than hindering them," Mr Birol said.
Well, yes. There's a lot of investment that will become stranded in the transition, and that's going to try to stop it for as long as possible.
But thanks to other investment, solar cells have become incredibly cheap and we can get a lot of our energy from Big Photodiode.
The battery investment curve is happening as well. Not as fast as anything silicon-based, and you can safely ignore individual dramatic tech announcements, but the power of thousands of engineers each shaving off 0.1% of the cost year on year accumulates.
- pydry 3y ago>There's a lot of investment that will become stranded in the transition, and that's going to try to stop it for as long as possible. I wish more people appreciated this. There's a lot of money available to push covert anti-renewable messages. It gets pumped from think tanks into the media with messaging designed to make the reader feel smart about repeating their "skeptical" take. It then works its way on hacker news with somebody quite honestly saying something like "I'm pro renewables but...", quite unaware of the money flows driving their beliefs.
- RandomLensman 3y agoWho, for example, will be paying for reworking the stock of old housing in a lot of European countries? Stranded assets are not just an issue for big investors and corporations.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoYou can pay for a house refit with future fuel savings and governments can add incentives paid for with lower health costs. The timeline might be long enough that people, especially landlords who don't have to live in the drafty, cold building or pay the fuel costs, won't do it without various carrots and sticks but that's totally different from a stranded asset.
- RandomLensman 3y agoSome of the now paused ideas of needing to modernize buildings would have actually ruled out use of of buildings below certain standards from certain dates - so stranded assets are quite possible. Payback: Maybe over 30-50 years, but not over 20 or so - so for a lot of older people this isn't an economically viable proposition. Lower health costs? Where does that come from?
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoThat's a "stick", not a stranded asset. The NPV of compliance would need to negative for the asset to be stranded. If the older people want to sell their home to someone else then they need to do the work. Again, unless that work costs more than their house, which to be clear, it doesn't, then it's not a stranded asset.
- RandomLensman 3y agoIf you need a few hundred k to convert in order to still live in your place (not sell it), I'd say that is getting pretty close to stranded asset, because you need to find a lot of money to stay in there. If you don't have the money, it is a stranded asset and I am sure some aggressive investor will happily make you a bad offer.
- ben_w 3y agoI'm considering building right now; "a few hundred k" is demolish and redo from the ground up territory for normal housing around here. The only way you're doing that for a mere renovation is if it's a historically significant building.
- RandomLensman 3y agoSomething like 10k per square meter isn't a bad guesstimate for getting to a high energy standard. Then take a large house and you are there. Building and demolishing is way more expensive.
- graemep 3y ago"There's a lot of money available to push covert anti-renewable messages." There is also a lot of money to be made pushing pro-renewable messages. There are huge amounts of money to be made from complete replacement of existing products and infrastructure. You are promoting a mixture of conspiracy theory and a straw man argument.
- mrkeen 3y agoWho paid for you to write this? Edit: You're right. There probably wasn't a money flow driving parent's writing. Stupid idea.
- roenxi 3y agoSpeaking as a greasy capitalist; if I can invest in renewables and make money or resist renewables and make money, why resist? The issue historically has been people have been claiming that renewables are cheap which were transparent lies. The German Energiewende stands as a stark monument to what happened to anyone silly enough to believe the greens in the 2010s. Even now there is reason to be suspect. But if the situation changes then what people do will change too.
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoEnergiewende, even with its various flaws, has been a good investment for Germany. If they'd been a bit more aggressive about EVs, home heating and offshore wind they'd probably be even better off but that all got derailed by complaints about costs fanned by climate change deniers and leveraged by opportunist politicians.
- blitzar 3y agoWithout the cheap renewables subsidising their bills germans would be paying even more for their electricity. If they had maintained their nuclear generating capacity + their current (and ever increasing) renewable capacity - electricity in germany would be on the brink of being free and unlimited.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoThere is no such thing as a cheap renewable when you need to have coal plant running 24/7 as a backup.
- blitzar 3y agoIts cheaper than running everything on coal.
- TheLoafOfBread 3y agoWell that coal runs anyway even if you are not consuming electricity from it.
- xnx 3y ago"but what about tire particles?" is one meme that feels like it is right at the intersection of these forces.
- pjc50 3y agoBird strikes from wind turbines is another. Does the person making that argument know or care about other major sources of bird death - cats, window collisions, habitat loss, pollutants etc? Usually not, it's just a convenient one to bring up to discredit the unknown.
- tzs 3y agoCats and window collisions do kill way more birds than wind turbines, but they are largely birds that are abundant. Wind turbines are often built in places where much less abundant birds, such as eagles and various other raptors, hunt. Wind turbines are particularly treacherous to those birds because they have a ridge over their eyes that blocks forward and upward vision (to keep the sun out of their eyes) when they are looking down to spot prey, so even though they have remarkable vision (hence the phrase "Eagle eyed") they can fly right into a turbine in broad daylight.
- pydry 3y agoWith cats, vehicles and buildings it's something like 100 million annually while wind turbines it's like 100-400k. So, not just way more but 200-500x more. With eagles the numbers killed are in order of hundreds. Newer wind turbine designs also reduce the number of bird deaths considerably. The scale of the problem is clearly small, relatively speaking. It would be ignored under normal circumstances, just like the #1 and #2 deaths for eagles currently are, but the carbon industries gave this story some great PR.
- Gibbon1 3y agoAnytime anyone says that, you can respond with this https://www.bts.gov/content/estimated-national-average-vehicle-emissions-rates-vehicle-vehicle-type-using-gasoline-and https://www.bts.gov/content/estimated-national-average-vehic... Also worth pointing out the weight penalty for EV's has been decreasing steadily over time. One would assume tire emissions would thsu also decrease. Doesn't say tire emissions aren't a problem[1] but it's suspicious people care about it when it's an EV and don't care when it's a 5500lb truck. [1] Particles from exhaust, brakes, and tires aren't the same[2]. [2] 6PPD-quinone from tires is killing salmon in the pacific northwest.
- paganel 3y ago> solar cells have become incredibly cheap and we can get a lot of our energy from Big Photodiode. Hasn't the cost of solar cells gone up by 30% or so during the last couple of years?
- ZeroGravitas 3y agoEven with that blip, they're still incredibly cheap: > Although their costs continue to exceed pre Covid-19 levels, solar PV and onshore wind remain the cheapest option for new electricity generation in most countries. ... > power contracts for the end of 2023 and into 2024 in the European Union, the United States, Japan, Australia and India all indicate wholesale electricity prices two to three times above 2020 averages, increasing the economic attractiveness of wind and solar PV. From another IEA report: https://www.iea.org/reports/renewable-energy-market-update-june-2023/will-solar-pv-and-wind-costs-finally-begin-to-fall-again-in-2023-and-2024 https://www.iea.org/reports/renewable-energy-market-update-j...
- bergie 3y ago> Even with that blip, they're still incredibly cheap Indeed. In the last (boat) solar installations I’ve done, the panels generally have been the cheapest component. The brackets to hold them, and the charge controllers tend to be the more expensive part.
- locallost 3y agoNo, they went temporarily up some time ago when supply couldn't keep up with demand, but this lasted for a few months. Since then it's continued to go down.
- mschuster91 3y ago> But thanks to other investment, solar cells have become incredibly cheap and we can get a lot of our energy from Big Photodiode. Solar cells have become incredibly cheap because the Chinese government is heavily subsidizing their producers, both financially and in terms of lax environment and worker protection regulation. In the end they're running the typical VC playbook: use price dumping to destroy the competition and when no one is left (or the political opportunity is needed), squeeze the locked-in customers for all they have.
- bryanlarsen 3y agoChinese subsidies are fairly small compared to the American ones brought in recently.
- quickthrower2 3y agoHow is anyone locked in?
- blitzar 3y agoPeople are locked in when they have a roof full of solar panels and dont have to worry or pay an electriciy bill for the next 40 years (and make a little every day shipping the excess back to the grid) - oh those poor locked in people.
- makomk 3y agoFactories elsewhere have been shutting down because they can't compete, which locks us in to buying from China since no-one else will have the ability to produce solar panels in meaningful quantities.
- quickthrower2 3y agoUS should do the same. So should f’ing Australia. I dream of the solar farms you could build in the outback here. You could have end to end mining, production and installation of solar power plants and start exporting. Imagine then sending that energy over to europe to power their night too!