3 ms·
Is there anyone to pick up the pieces? Apple: obviously not. but then, ARM charges an arm and a leg and they have a history of architecture swaps... Amazon: w
by baq 3y ago
Is there anyone to pick up the pieces?
Apple: obviously not. but then, ARM charges an arm and a leg and they have a history of architecture swaps...
Amazon: with Graviton, very doubtful
Intel: um
AMD: see Intel
Microsoft/Meta/Alphabet: ...maybe? If they started today, they could have a reasonable product by 2030
ARM: 1% probability of a skunkworks product to have the best risc-v CPU once they're something people actually want
NVidia: wanted to buy ARM, announced ARM CPUs like yesterday - but why not, except that people don't care?
Qualcom: most likely option...?
- logicchains 3y agoAlibaba's already taking the lead on RISC-V, they've even got quad core 2.6 GHz RISC-V laptops: https://www.notebookcheck.net/New-spec-details-and-pricing-for-the-first-RISC-V-laptops-revealed-by-Alibaba.659568.0.html https://www.notebookcheck.net/New-spec-details-and-pricing-f...
- brucehoult 3y agoBy the time Roma shipped it had a 1.5 GHz quad core Chinese SoC with SiFive cores (JH7110), not the Alibaba THead TH1520 SoC which turned out at only 1.85 GHz anyway. You can buy the same JH7110 SoC in a tablet with docking keyboard&trackpad cover (so pretty much a laptop) for $160 from Pine64 (PineTab-V).
- londons_explore 3y agoHas anyone actually got one of those?
- wrycoder 3y ago$1499??
- mst 3y agoI would imagine the target market for these is "people who want a RISC-V development machine" at which point the price to performance ratio doesn't need to be as good for it to still be useful for the potential customers. That or they don't expect to sell a meaningful number and this one has been productised as a public proof of capability exercise rather than primarily for the sake of the product itself.
- monocasa 3y agoIt's dropped significantly since then.
- nine_k 3y agoHow about TI? Microchip? Even Siemens or Bosch?
- bradfa 3y agoMicrochip seem like a likely buyer to me. They have been buying up various silicon semi-specialty companies like mad over the past 10ish years and they already have some RISC-V SOCs for sale. If Microchip could offer a semi-custom chip design business leveraging what SiFive have done, with reasonable minimum order quantities, I think that'd be quite interesting. But I doubt Microchip will pay a billion dollars for such a purchase, they could also probably just go hire away the key engineers for a lot less.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoMicroSemi (which was later bought by MicroChip) had a relationship with SiFive and you could buy a MicroSemi PolarFire FPGA dev board with a preconfigured SiFive U74 soft-core in it. DAMN if it wasn't difficult to configure. Which is my way of saying... yeah... Microchip buying SiFive? Stranger things have happened.
- Wytwwww 3y ago> ARM charges an arm and a leg and they have a history of architecture swaps... Do they? I don't think the details of their contract with ARM are public so they might have a very good deal. Also licensing fees are probably a much smaller issue for companies which have very high margins.
- klelatti 3y agoBut what would they be buying? The ISA is free. A few designs without the engineering teams that built them? Doesn’t seem that attractive.
- OhMeadhbh 3y agoThere's more to a chip than the ISA.
- masklinn 3y ago> Apple: obviously not. but then, ARM charges an arm and a leg and they have a history of architecture swaps... Given Apple’s very special relationship with ARM, and their culture of control, and them literally being a flagship standard bearer on the performance segment I’d be shocked if they paid anywhere near market rate (not that their licensing is even market-available but you get what I’m saying).
- delfinom 3y agoI imagine Apple has an ironclad contract with ARM that likes of which everyone else would be jelly. Even some of the internal architecture changes have long been forbidden by ARM licensing. Not to mention, ARM is about to destroy the market by trying to backtrack on all their licensing. They now want per device royalties paid by the device manufacturer instead of chip maker to get a larger slice of the pie. And they are basically moving to kill Qualcomm's licenses and IP out of spite in a lawsuit.
- p_l 3y agoApple pays nothing, because they do not license ARM cores in any way, instead having a full royalty-free license for ARM ISA (and afaik covering updates too) since before ARM got big. Samsung used to have one, no idea if they still have one, but the mismanagement of the unit that built their custom ARM designs might have killed the whole venture.
- 3y ago
- bhouston 3y ago> Is there anyone to pick up the pieces? I do not know if it matters to the RISC-V ecosystem if someone picks up the pieces, but for the employees involved it does.
- adgjlsfhk1 3y agoI think Nvidia. they wanted to buy arm because they didn't want to depend on external people for their architecture. once that is blocked going to riscv makes sense for them (recent arm chip announcements aren't that relevant to this analysis because their design was before the arm deal was blocked)
- hajile 3y agoIntel seems to have quite a bit of interest in RISC-V. They even have a pipecleaner chip using a SiFive core with all the rest being Intel IP. RISC-V could be their ticket into the phone space. Finally, Intel knows x86 sucks. They've tried FOUR different times to move off of x86 (iAPX 432, i960, i860, and EPIC). Every one has failed spectacularly. RISC-V offers an offramp. Patent all the best methods of combining x86 and RISC-V on a chip the release your backward compatible RISC-V + x86 chip. Businesses will buy that chip for decades to remain backward compatible and your patents will guarantee you another 20 years of profits.
- phkahler 3y agoGoogle is bringing Android to RISC-V. They're quite capable of designing their own chips and even have their own phones to put them in, and chromebooks too. Not that they're going to change the world by doing so.