5 ms·
A shame, but also unsurprising. I never understood how they could have such a high burn rate for a technology that hadn't really taken off in the markets that t
by adastra22 3y ago
A shame, but also unsurprising. I never understood how they could have such a high burn rate for a technology that hadn't really taken off in the markets that they were targeting.
RISC-V is/was vitally important in putting downward pressure on ARM licensing. But large companies were never going to move off ARM for their workhorse CPUs. They'd use the threat of moving to RISC-V as a way of getting sweetheart IP deals from ARM, but no one actually wanted to start over on a new software transition while the move to ARM was still unfinished.
- edrxty 3y agoYou're not wrong. I think the move to riscv will happen but not in any time span we can make predictions inside of (~10 years+). ARM has been awful to license stuff from and riscv has been great for keeping them from going absolutely mad with power.
- adgjlsfhk1 3y agoit's already happening. Nvidia and Western digital are already shipping riscv in production. high performance riscv is likely closer to a decade away, but it's already doing a pretty good job of replacing the embedded zoo
- adastra22 3y agoBut why would NVIDIA ever ship a RISC-V vector unit? They have no incentive to.
- loup-vaillant 3y ago> RISC-V is/was vitally important in putting downward pressure on ARM licensing. Given current laws. I wonder if the world wouldn’t be better off with strong interoperability laws, where ISAs are simply neither copyrightable nor patentable. This would instantly kill ARM of course, but their ISA (well, ISAs) would live on. I love the design of RISC-V, but I find it kind of sick that being forbidden to implement one’s own ARM or x86 core is such a big reason for its success.
- klelatti 3y agoIt wouldn’t kill Arm. They would still license their own cores.
- loup-vaillant 3y agoOops, my mistake, sorry. I still think it would seriously cut into their profits, but you’re right.
- klelatti 3y agoBadly wounded, maybe?!
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- cmrdporcupine 3y agoSounds like the story I have heard told a few times about how companies in the 60s, and 70s would make sure they had the business card of an Amdahl sales rep on their desk when the IBM sales rep came to visit (Amdahl apparently made their business selling mostly/somewhat IBM-compatible but much cheaper mainframes.) All I can say is general comment as a consumer / "prosumer"; I recently went looking to build out a high core count homelab server built on either RISC-V or ARM; because I wanted lower power consumption, higher core count, and, well, was interested in something non-x86 anyways. When I went looking, I found there is still nothing out there in the ARM world other than Ampere servers and that is unavailable to end consumers. We're decades into this ARM thing, but there are entire market segments where ARM looks like it'd be applicable but there are no products (ok, other than Apple). And yet I also found that RISC-V seems to be making early moves into this kind of space - e.g. I can preorder and actually buy the Milk-V SOPHON-base "Pioneer" board, which is a 64-core RISC-V board in mATX form factor I can put in my own case, etc. but nothing like this seems reasonable on the horizon for ARM. Still. My question is: is this a product of the viability (or lack of it) of these segments/ businesses, or does it have something to do with ARM licensing? Anyways, I'm bullish on RISC-V. I played with PicoRV32 a few years ago on hobby FPGA projects; built out my own little primitive SoC on an Artix A7 board, wrote my own little operating system, it was great fun. The openness of all this stuff is fantastic and necessary for producing innovation. I feel like the nature of RISC-V will naturally tend towards producing more diversity of products than ARM has, even if the investment environment goes through a bit of a contraction for a bit.