4 ms·
What do you mean by the right class background? If you think I’m a white guy who graduated from a prestigious school, I can guarantee you that’s a far from accu
by scarface_74 3y ago
What do you mean by the right class background? If you think I’m a white guy who graduated from a prestigious school, I can guarantee you that’s a far from accurate assumption.
Let’s just say when I walk through my neighborhood I’ve read comments about me in my own NextDoor group about someone “suspicious” and realized they were talking about me or my son…
- lmm 3y ago> What do you mean by the right class background? If you think I’m a white guy This is why I find it so frustrating to talk to Americans. > Let’s just say when I walk through my neighborhood I’ve read comments about me in my own NextDoor group about someone “suspicious” and realized they were talking about me or my son… So you're a member of the class that lives in "good" neighbourhoods where it's suspicious for certain types of people to be? I think you've proved my point.
- scarface_74 3y agoI think you’re more showing your own biases. I never said that the neighborhood was “good”. I just said that there aren’t that many people with my skin color… But back on topic. I base my interviews on behavioral traits that for framing, can be sussed out by asking “tell me about a time when” type questions. You did see the part about I’ve gone through the interview training by the second largest employer in the US didn’t you? It doesn’t matter if you can reverse a binary tree on the whiteboard if I’m looking for someone who “takes ownership”, “digs deep”, and has shown the ability to deal at the level of “scope” that I’m looking for an knows how to “deal with ambiguity”
- blincoln 3y agoI like your "tell me about a time when" approach,[1] and I've used it successfully in the past, but I've never seen a good way to formalize it. Have you ever been able to delegate that responsibility to a team of other people and get results more or less consistent with what would have happened if you'd conducted all of the interviews? My current opinion is that while it's effective, it means there's a significant bottleneck (sometimes a single person) for the hiring pipeline. i.e. you still need at least one earlier tier of interview to winnow the candidates down to a volume that's manageable for the bottleneck, and the earlier tier needs to be something more standardized that can be delegated to a larger group of people. i.e. "can this person explain common technical details A, B, and C of work in this department well enough to demonstrate solid understanding?" [1] I read years ago that border guards in some countries use a similar technique, because if someone is being deceptive, it's unlikely they can handle a random walk to an arbitrary depth of detail.
- scarface_74 3y agoI have a framework now that I’ve been developing based on my time at AWS. I’m now at a company where I’m building out an “application modernization” practice. It’s based on the Leadership Principles at Amazon. Not that Amazon is a great place to work in practice (I just got Anazoned two months ago). But they talk good game. https://managementconsulted.com/amazon-leadership-principles/ https://managementconsulted.com/amazon-leadership-principles... I have a sticky note of the LPs I care about. A lot of times when I just ask a generic “tell me about yourself” question, they will talk about their experience and I can just ask them more details around their project that let’s me get the information I want. Other times, I have to specifically pull out my questions. For instance, I really care about having someone who is willing to speak up in meetings and is willing to express their opinions and even someone who is willing to tell me they think I’m wrong. I speak very authoritatively about my areas of expertise. But I always try to emphasize “strong opinions weakly held”. In LPs terms it’s called “Have backbone disagree and commit”. My favorite question for that is “Say I’m your manager and you are in the meeting with me , the CTO and other managers and we come up with an idea that you think is completely stupid. What would you do?” And that starts an entire conversation. I’ve given a thumbs down to people who give me an answer that I don’t think is a fit for what I’m looking for. I love for people to give me feedback and I hire people who help my team fill in technical gaps. I need people to speak up
- aleph_minus_one 3y ago> [1] I read years ago that border guards in some countries use a similar technique, because if someone is being deceptive, it's unlikely they can handle a random walk to an arbitrary depth of detail. Such people are not necessarily deceptive; in my experience, much more often - the person does not have the best memory, but loves to talk - the person has a tendency to "hallucinate" (i.e. has some mild (typically harmless) schizophrenic traits)
- lmm 3y ago> But back on topic. I base my interviews on behavioral traits that for framing, can be sussed out by asking “tell me about a time when” type questions. > It doesn’t matter if you can reverse a binary tree on the whiteboard if I’m looking for someone who “takes ownership”, “digs deep”, and has shown the ability to deal at the level of “scope” that I’m looking for an knows how to “deal with ambiguity” That definitely sounds like something that would filter more for "went to the right schools" (or, more generically, "mingled with the right people", but schools are the easy way). I could certainly believe it's as effective as "reverse a binary tree", but I very much doubt it's fairer.
- scarface_74 3y agoHow does “going to the right school” have anything to do with having a project at work that you took ownership of and you took the time to learn a new to you technology? Do you realize that scope, impact and dealing with ambiguity is literally in the leveling guidelines stated in some way or the other in every tech company? https://dropbox.github.io/dbx-career-framework/ https://dropbox.github.io/dbx-career-framework/ I’m not looking for someone who just graduated from college.
- lmm 3y ago> How does “going to the right school” have anything to do with having a project at work that you took ownership of and you took the time to learn a new to you technology? The right schools give you the opportunity and mentality to do that (and before that, even more fundamentally, so does having a comfortable upbringing), and then you'll compound that with your experiences in the good jobs that going to the right schools gets you. > Do you realize that scope, impact and dealing with ambiguity is literally in the leveling guidelines stated in some way or the other in every tech company? Everyone does it, that's exactly the point - you limit class mobility by ensuring that the good jobs are only available to the people from the right class. Even if someone from the lower classes has the skills to excel, they never get the chance to take ownership, learn new skills, and expand the scope of their impact because they're never hired for a position in which they can take ownership, take the time to learn, and have impact beyond their narrow position, because they never have a way to show that they can take ownership and learn new skills...