4 ms·
But, posting publicly to social media is almost exactly like a letter to the editor. You send your message to a company, the company reviews it, and then usuall
by ryandrake 3y ago
But, posting publicly to social media is almost exactly like a letter to the editor. You send your message to a company, the company reviews it, and then usually publishes it publicly for all to see.
I would not feel "chilled" if someone (an employer, government, or whoever) trawled through my HN posts and made some kind of judgment or took action over what I post. I would expect it. It's public after all. I certainly moderate what I say here knowing this (maybe that's the chilling effect you mention?)
- bluefirebrand 3y ago> I certainly moderate what I say here knowing this (maybe that's the chilling effect you mention?) Yeah that is the chilling effect. Yes, it's likely there are some things that are better to be "chilled". For instance if you were advocating for violence against public figures. But imagine the day your credit rating gets dinged because you post online that you disagree with some new tax reform bill being proposed. This happens because the agency managing your credit score is also lobbying for this tax reform. Or you criticize a government official online and the police show up at your door, which is something that absolutely has happened throughout history. The fact they are watching your social media isn't the problem. It's how they can (and eventually probably will) abuse that surveillance. Or whoever replaces them next time there is an election.
- psd1 3y agoJust the watching is indeed a problem. It makes me feel violated. Whether or not I have something to hide, or might get a knock on the door, is a completely separate point.
- bluefirebrand 3y agoI don't love the fact that everything is being watched and analyzed, but it's actions taken based on that data gathering that I'm worried about Of course we understand that the only reason to watch and analyze all of this data is to be able to take actions based on it I am definitely in favor of preventing the gathering to guarantee preventing the actions. No one should trust that data is being collected without any intention of using it.
- mecha_ghidorah 3y agoI'd definitely feel chilled, because what I post here isn't under my meatspace identity. I don't think they should have a right to pass judgement over something I'm doing under a pseudonym that can't be attached to me easily
- corobo 3y agoWell sure, but what if you throw in the possibility of mistaken identity? Might not be too chilling.. as long as they get the right person. Best hope other Ryan just parties it up a bit and nothing more sinister if you want to become a teacher.