5 ms·
One of the reason pro cyclists clip their feet to their pedals is so they can load the “other” leg through the back of the stroke, and across the bottom as well
by hinkley 3y ago
One of the reason pro cyclists clip their feet to their pedals is so they can load the “other” leg through the back of the stroke, and across the bottom as well by pulling back on the loaded leg. Come unclipped in a sprint and you’re fucked.
Sounds like this is the same thing for running.
- criddell 3y agoHave you ever used an elliptical chainring?
- jph 3y agoYes, elliptical chainrings are great IMHO, especially if you train for elliptical continual exertion. Added 2km to my speed.
- jackmott42 3y agoNo it did not.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt is hard to say if it is implausible without the time unit. 2km/day? I believe it. 2km/s? Seems unlikely.
- jph 3y agoHa! Yes you're right, units matter. For me it was 2 km/hour, on rides for an hour or so typically above 20 km/hour, on a hybrid bike, on long streets in Marin. The ellipticals worked especially well, for me, in combination with bar ends.
- hinkley 3y agoIt's not that far above what some people were claiming when they were new. There were people claiming 1mph improvement. I was... skeptical. Placebo effect? Who knows. I don't think I ever got around to trying one. I was the youngest regular member of our club. Power output was not my primary problem.
- rottencupcakes 3y agoThe idea that your muscles have enough strength on the upstroke to contribute meaningfully to cycling is actually a bit of a misunderstanding. Your leg muscles for lifting are much much much weaker than your leg muscles for pushing - they're designed to only lift up the weight of your leg and not much more. The main advantage of the clips is to keep your leg in contact with the pedal throughout the cycle and make sure the ball of your foot is optimally placed on the pedal. With a traditional pedal you have to keep some downward force on the pedal to create friction to avoid slipping off, so even when that leg is rising up, you can't completely unload the pedal. With clips you can completely unload the pedal.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoAny muscle is trainable. To some extent. If you cycle enough, you will develop muscles necessary to pull the pedal up. Additionally, the goal isn't to double your power output. It is to be better than the other cyclist. Even by just a tiny bit. I personally think that clipping the feet helps more with left right stability. Also, if you are pulling with one leg, you can potentially push more with the other. Normally you can only push as much as you weight, but with the other leg clipped you can push your weight plus the force you use to pull the other pedal.
- justsocrateasin 3y agoThis is true for certain metabolic zones but not others. If you're sprinting then yes, you get a higher power output while pulling up on the pedal. However if you're going for any kind of endurance (longer than a minute) the limiting factor is not muscular but cardiovascular/aerobic, and using less efficient muscles (the ones used for pulling up) will actually hinder your performance since you'll need to be supplying those with oxygen, thus decreasing total cycling economy.
- onetimeuse92304 3y agoI am not versed with cycling economy. But yeah, it makes sense. On a bike, if you want to put up more power you have options to push harder or spin faster. If you had to push harder than your weight, you could always change your gears to rather spin faster.
- Someone 3y ago> Come unclipped in a sprint and you’re fucked. Not necessarily :-) See https://www.eurosport.com/cycling/famenne-ardenne-classic/2023/arnaud-de-lie-somehow-wins-famenne-ardenne-classic-despite-pedalling-to-the-line-on-one-leg_vid2002392/video.shtml https://www.eurosport.com/cycling/famenne-ardenne-classic/20... for an example where that happened and the sprinter still won.
- hinkley 3y agoJesus. Well momentum can be your friend or your enemy. It looks like not only did he pull his foot out, he also clipped his chain or front derailleur with his foot and popped himself down into the small chainring.
- pharmakom 3y agoI believe this was disproven actually. The real reason is security under heavy power output.
- hinkley 3y agoI’m looking at these experiments and I am dubious. How do you explain the effect in OP’s device if this is “disproven”? Nobody seems to have offered an alternative theory.
- jackmott42 3y agoThis is false, even cyclists who think they pull up and pull back do not, and it is less efficient to do so. However it is a VERY common misconception that you should do this.
- hinkley 3y agoWhen the only American who won the Tour de France without drugs tells people to do something, a lot of people are going to do it. Anyway, I can't find any of these so-called studies that admits to knowing what a sprinter is let alone a green jersey, so I'm going to keep my eye out for less flawed studies. In fact, get me one by a team medic or physiologist, and then we can talk. Until then it's nerds in coats coatsplaining things to people actually doing the work.
- andy99 3y agoI'm not disagreeing with the above comments though I am curious about the factor of how much energy output a person is actually capable of. Running isn't leisurely and you can reach (as far as I know) maximum physical (cardiac?) output running. My point being it's not like there is unused capacity to work harder when you're running that's making you slower. So there must be more to it than just doing more at times you'd otherwise be idle.