3 ms·
This seems to ignore the fundamental reason that billionaires don't pay taxes. It's not that governments don't try to tax billionaires. It's that they're able t
by scythe 3y ago
This seems to ignore the fundamental reason that billionaires don't pay taxes. It's not that governments don't try to tax billionaires. It's that they're able to avoid claiming income when they make money. But following this reasoning, they would likely develop ways to avoid claiming wealth as well. Consider, for example, Warren Buffet's own example of his California properties which have a taxable value well below their realistic market value. Similar sleight of hand would likely be employed (with a few strategically positioned lobbyists having lunch with legislative committees) in order to allow billionaires to minimize their taxable wealth.
The more practical approach, as I understand it, is a tax on securitization of assets: whenever someone takes out a loan against an asset for expenses (which is common among the wealthy to avoid realizing gains), a tax is assessed on the loan value. This makes the tax harder to avoid because it is assessed closer to the actual use of money, which is a documented event. While this may affect the second mortgage and "auto loan" industry, weakening predatory finance doesn't seem like that much of a bad thing.
- rjsw 3y agoI think we will need to abolish trusts as well as imposing a wealth tax.
- VikingCoder 3y agoI love the ancient trick of taxing goods on a ship. You tell me how much the goods are worth. Then it's my choice whether to charge you the tax on that value, or to just hand you the value and the goods are mine now.
- eli 3y agoA wealth tax doesn't need to be perfect to be better than not having one. The wealthy will always have access to the best lawyers and accountants who can find ways to gain an edge here and there. That's o; or at least it doesn't invalidate the approach. Property tax is a fine example: sometimes properties aren't assessed in an ideal way (and to be fair some states also have very convoluted property tax schemes and credits) but overwhelmingly if you have very valuable property you pay more than someone with less valuable property.