3 ms·
Interesting. Notice that 17 USC 512(i)(1)(A) calls for termination of repeat infringers but the rest of the law is careful to talk about alleged infringers. How
by account42 3y ago
Interesting. Notice that 17 USC 512(i)(1)(A) calls for termination of repeat infringers but the rest of the law is careful to talk about alleged infringers. How is a service provider supposed to determine which of the alleged infringements were actually infringements?
- jkaplowitz 3y agoUnstated. I imagine a range of approaches would probably be upheld by the courts. In practice, there isn’t much incentive for the big providers to doubt the takedown notices as applied to most customers. After all, the pushback against them for being too quick to terminate will generally be comparable or milder than that for them being too slow to terminate, given who has the money and influence, plus it takes more work from the provider to be protective of legal reuse than to assume all notices are legitimate. Some cases of reuse-protective approaches by service providers do exist, of course. I suspect this happens when the provider is small enough to either have a reuse-protective ideology or simply to take a personalized rather than automated approach, and also when a big provider views a customer as lucrative or influential enough that they don’t want to punish them incorrectly.
- tzs 3y ago> How is a service provider supposed to determine which of the alleged infringements were actually infringements? Here's an outline of what the service provider has to do when they receive a notice from a complainer about alleged infringing material posted by a user of the service, if the provider wants to take advantage of the DMCA safe harbor. 1. Do a simple check of the complaint to see if it contains the required information (contact information of the complainer, asserting that the complainer is authorized to act on behalf of the copyright owner, description of what specifically is allegedly infringing, etc). 2. If it passes the check remove the alleged infringing material. 3. If the alleged infringer tells service provider that the material is not infringing, the service provider must restore the alleged infringing material, and provide the complainer with contact information of the alleged infringer. After that if the complainer wants to force the removal of the material they have to bring an infringement lawsuit against the alleged infringer. If the complainer does so and wins then the person who was an alleged infringer becomes simply an infringer. The complainer can again ask the provider to take down the material, but this time instead of making a DMCA request they can provide a copy of the judgement from that lawsuit. That makes the provider aware that the material is actually infringing, not just allegedly infringing, and the DMCA safe harbor is not available. The provider must take down the material or the provider itself might be liable for infringement.