3 ms·
For a while I've wanted an SVG map with a JS API where you can input latitude and longitude and show the point on it. I hope this will do that! The reason I wa
by keepamovin 3y ago
For a while I've wanted an SVG map with a JS API where you can input latitude and longitude and show the point on it. I hope this will do that!
The reason I want that is, almost all humans have a GPS device in their pocket. You could easily get your approximate location from this, even without cell service. Implementation could be a PWA.
- jack_riminton 3y agoBut protomaps is still getting the map data from a CDN, do you mean that the map data would be cached on the device?
- keepamovin 3y agoYes. With the tradeoff that it would be radically simplified.
- wiredfool 3y agoYour best bet for this is something like OsmAnd or organic maps, which download countries worth of osm data and make it available offline. The amount of map data for any reasonable area is going to be too large for a PWA, though it would technically be possible to do with existing map viewers and this format. (Eg maplibre or leaflet)
- keepamovin 3y agoThanks. I'm OK with a single layer just showing the outlines of coastlines and regions, including the names of regions. I think a suitable simplified world map could fit all this in SVG. edit: Initially underestimated so did some calculations below Key Data Points for Estimate of SVG Size - Radius of Earth: 6371 km - Surface Area of Earth: 510e6 km^2 - Approximate Number of Countries: 250 - Land Area of Earth: 29% of Surface Area = 150e6 km^2 Corrections and Estimations Based on Average Country Size - Average Land Area per Country: 150e6 km^2 / 250 = 6e5 km^2 - Country Closest to Average Size: Ukraine, with 603550 km^2, or roughly 6e5 km^2 - World Resources Institute Measure of Ukraine Coastline: 4953 km, or around 5e3 km Assumptions for SVG Complexity 1. Only coastlines matter for the paths. 2. Resolution set at 10 meters. SVG Data Calculations and Estimates - Coastline Points for Average Country: - 5e3 km = 5e6 m - Equals 5e5 X,Y points (at 10m resolution) - Total Points for All Countries: - 250 countries * 5e5 points = 1.25e8 X,Y points - Storage Requirement for Each Point: - 6 figures per coordinate + delimiters = roughly 15 bytes - Total Storage = 1.25e8 points * 15 bytes = ~1.875e9 bytes or about 1.875 GB Even with a simplified approach, we're looking at an SVG that'd be almost 2 GB, just for coastlines at a 10m resolution. Definitely some hefty complexities in play here. What about 1000m resolution? 20 megabytes. Much more achievable.
- Someone 3y agoI would expect border length scales with the square root of country area, so smaller countries have disproportionally longer borders than larger ones. There also must be more countries smaller than the average country than there are larger ones (https://www.worldometers.info/geography/largest-countries-in-the-world/ https://www.worldometers.info/geography/largest-countries-in... confirms that. Ukraine is 45th of 223, or about 20% down.) So, I guess yours is underestimating the size. You probably get a better estimate by using the Ukraine to estimate the scaling constant (√603,550km²)÷4953km and then use a list of land areas to estimate border lengths.
- keepamovin 3y agoI like your refinements! I may take a look at reviewing the estimate later! Thank you for making this contribution, it's really valuable that you share your intuitive statistical knowledge here :)
- wiredfool 3y agoCountries with coastlines, especially with fjords, have disproportionately longer borders. Scaling constants aren't going to do it for something like Chile.
- mlunar 3y agoSVG is kind-of terrible for maps, but you can get pretty small with GeoPackage (read: sqlite). I recently spent a bit too long on exactly this problem and ended up with the following. 116KB - 5MB for country borders 16MB - 52MB for ~50K city/county level borders based on geoBoundaries The range of sizes depends on how much custom compression/simplification you put into it. The source files are about 10x bigger, but that's already pretty small. Topojson might be even smaller though. Check the repo for details /selfplug https://github.com/SmilyOrg/tinygpkg-data https://github.com/SmilyOrg/tinygpkg-data
- keepamovin 3y agoThank you we forked your repo! What makes you say SVG is kind-of terrible for maps?
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]