4 ms·
You know we say magnetic media dont last but my 5.25" Floppy Disk are still readable last time I tested it in 2020 during COVID when I was too bored at home. I
by ksec 3y ago
You know we say magnetic media dont last but my 5.25" Floppy Disk are still readable last time I tested it in 2020 during COVID when I was too bored at home. I have some 8" but the computer that had it wouldn't turn on anymore. The PC with 5.25" and 3.5" still does.
Not the same could be said about CD though. CDs that were pressed are still ok, not so much for burned CD-R. Most of them are full or errors when reading it.
- anonymouskimmer 3y ago> not so much for burned CD-R. Most of them are full or errors when reading it. David Rosenthal tests this periodically. Most recently he tested in August. Notice the first sentence of the quote: https://blog.dshr.org/2023/08/optical-media-durability-update.html https://blog.dshr.org/2023/08/optical-media-durability-updat... > The drives I use from ASUS and LG report read errors from the CDs but verify the MD5s correctly. I didn't notice them reporting any read errors from the DVDs. An off-brand drive fails to read the CDs, but read one of the older DVDs with no read errors. > Surprisingly, with no special storage precautions, generic low-cost media, and consumer drives, I'm getting good data from CD-Rs more than 19 years old, and from DVD-Rs nearly 17 years old. Your mileage may vary. Tune in again next year for another episode. > Last year I found a NetBSD1.2 CD dating from October 1996 whose cksum(1) checksums all verified correctly despite a few read errors. That CD was still delivering good data after nearly 26 years, but this year a couple of the checksums failed.
- gattilorenz 3y agoThat's my experience as well. I recently imaged - a collection of CD-Roms attached to a computer magazine, 1999-2001 - my own collection of stuff downloaded or backed up around 2003-2004; most of it on Verbatim DVDs, but some on CD-R or CD-RW (likely also from Verbatim) I had very few read errors, and it was impressive especially considering it's more than 50 CDs and that I never payed too much attention to how they were stored. Most of the computer magazine CDs were stored directly in a "cardboard sleeve", not even one of those plastic/paper ones...
- zozbot234 3y ago> a collection of CD-Roms attached to a computer magazine, 1999-2001 Please upload these disc images to Internet Archive if not included already, so that they can be preserved for the future. Downloads which used to be publicly available might be worthwhile too, but it could be more of a challenge to sort these out.
- gattilorenz 3y agoThat’s exactly why I imaged those in the first place :) Well, that, and to relive those years, find the games included in those magazines and finally play them on a Voodoo 2 instead of a poor S3 Virge…
- qingcharles 3y agoThank you for doing this. Someone had uploaded a cover CD from 1994 recently and I was able to download my first piece of commercial software :)
- ksec 3y ago>- a collection of CD-Roms attached to a computer magazine, 1999-2001 I still have lots of those as well from the early 90s! Mostly PC Gamer ( UK ) and some other computer magazine. I need to find a weekend and archive those. But a little sad as more than half of my CD-Rs have problems. May be I need to get a new external DVD reader just to test it out again see so many people have no problems with their CDs.
- gattilorenz 3y agoYes, try using a more recent drive. Especially laptop drives are particularly prone to issues, in my experience.
- Tor3 3y agoMy 5.25" ones from the mid-eighties are still readable. As far as I can tell the 8" ones are as well, though I haven't tested many of them. But their density is low, which helps a lot. And that's also why none of my 3.5" 1.44MB floppies are readable - the density is a bit too high for what's feasible for that physical medium. I don't know about later ones, but early CD-R easily failed after less than a year back when I tried to use them as backup media. I quickly abandoned the idea of using them as backup.
- Zardoz84 3y agoMy 3.5 floppy disks from early 90's keeps being fine. I a few months ago, I installed the demo of Hallowen Harry, and the Commander Keen 4 copy that comes with the Gravis Game pad, in a 486 without issues.
- plastic3169 3y agoFrom seeing everyone still archiving on magnetic tape I was under the impression that magnetic media was the gold standard for long time storage.