4 ms·
Flash shouldn't have died. It was an incredibly accessible authorship tool that produced cross-platform single-file animations that were low-bandwidth and scal
by echelon 3y ago
Flash shouldn't have died.
It was an incredibly accessible authorship tool that produced cross-platform single-file animations that were low-bandwidth and scaled.
We still haven't made up for its loss. Javascript + canvas + web stack is a mess. If the Ruffle runtime could quickly start up, I'd start authoring new Flash.
- neverdied 3y agothe only thing that really died was adobe's support (if you can call it that) and the web plugin I was kind of shocked how big the community still is
- o11c 3y agoThere was the teensy problem of being an unending bag of security vulnerabilities. Java Applets were its only competitor, and Java had the disadvantage of being fundamentally designed without security in mind.
- neverdied 3y agopeople making login systems in flash should honestly be ashamed of themselves
- lmm 3y ago> Java had the disadvantage of being fundamentally designed without security in mind. Nonsense. Java is one of very few languages that was designed to handle untrusted code from day 1, and it showed in having far fewer vulnerabilities than Flash. Unfortunately the JVM was slow to start up, so you had an even worse "grey rectangle effect" than Flash, and applets like all plugins were poorly integrated with the rest of the page. Top that off with Java not being particularly great for writing UI or video in (it's fine, but it's not great) whereas Flash had excellent tools for doing vector animations and you can see why Flash was more popular.
- o11c 3y agoThe very idea of having a `SecurityManager` that runs in the same VM is nonsensical, but that's what Java did. Java was designed - and widely used - as a general-purpose language with full platform capabilities. Flash at least implemented a VM with a fairly minimal surface. It can only blame its quality of implementation.
- lmm 3y ago> The very idea of having a `SecurityManager` that runs in the same VM is nonsensical, but that's what Java did. Lolwhat? It's fine. It worked great. (It had some vulnerabilities in its history, but so does every sandbox/hypervisor/what-have-you out there)
- cyberax 3y agoNot really. The whole SecurityManager thingie was a fiasco from the start. It granted access to _code_, not to the environment. Basically, you declared in the manifest that "com.mycompany.blah.*" wants to have full access rights, and SM granted permissions to that _code_. So it was predictably easy to subvert this, because Java code was not typically written in defensive style, sanitizing all the input data. All the modern sandboxes instead isolate the environment.
- strken 3y agos/Java had the disadvantage/Flash had the disadvantage/ perhaps?
- jcranmer 3y agoDon't forget stability issues. Flash was (before being banished to a separate process) the single largest contributor of crashes in Firefox, responsible for about ⅓ of them. Even in its dying days, I'd "fix" a slow page by wandering over to a terminal and typing "kill -9 plugin-container" to kill all the Flash instances on the page. I shed tears for the Flash games that were killed off by the demise of Flash. I don't shed any tears for Flash itself.
- Jnr 3y agoJust tried the Ruffle demo, it crashed my Firefox. :D
- taylorius 3y agoBack in the day, before flash added 3d I wrote a flash player emulator in a Java Applet, as a "UI System" for our 3D engine. Looking back, I've literally no idea what the hell I was thinking. :-)
- mcpackieh 3y agoIt's a pity the demise of flash killed a games/art scene, but the rest of the web is better off with flash gone and nothing new to fill that role. The way some people used to make entire websites as flash apps that would bring old computers to their knees is not something I miss. Websites that should have just been static html, like a restaurant's website for their menu, were getting turned into monstrously inefficient interactive nightmares that wouldn't even load at all if you didn't have flash (which btw, broke constantly with Linux.) This kind of superfluous interactivity is still possible with javascript/etc, but it seems to be less popular and is more likely to gracefully degrade (usually the relevant content still displays even if you have JS disabled.)
- matteoraso 3y agoWebsites have gotten way more bloated since Flash died. I used to have a smartphone with 2GB of RAM, and certain websites would just crash the browser because it used up too much resources. Flash apps look light by comparison.
- inferiorhuman 3y agoYeah the beauty of flash is that it would crash your browser using way less than 2GB of RAM.
- TheDong 3y ago> the rest of the web is better off with flash gone and nothing new to fill that role. What has filled the role of flash for commercial websites is native iOS and android apps, which still somehow end up being way larger than a flash payload and also drain battery faster. The truly magical bit of flash though was the small scale culture of making tiny little once-off things to share for the love of it, for free. Hacker culture, if you will. In the flash days, you could make a little toy for fun as a 10 year old kid without a credit card, post it on newgrounds for free to let others see it, brag to your friends, and feel good. Now, you need to buy a macbook ($1000) and apple dev account ($100/yr) to be able to share your dumb joke with your friends at school. No wonder young kids instead use the even more closed roblox platform to make dumb jokes rather than building iOS apps.
- danaris 3y ago> Flash shouldn't have died. The only way this could ever have been possible is if a widely-available and -adopted Flash runtime was made that was ironclad in security and reasonably performant. Ideally, it would also have been open-source. Honestly, while I absolutely sympathize with you and people who share your feelings on Flash, I genuinely believe that its demise was better for the web, especially given that Adobe very clearly had either no interest in or no ability to make such a runtime. With Flash dead, there was huge impetus to make reasonably open and widely-accepted standards for more explicit layout, animation, and other kinds of presentation on the web—and now we have that! It may not reproduce absolutely everything Flash did (particularly on highly Flash-specific sites like Newgrounds, where you're guaranteed to have people trying to push the boundaries of the medium), but it does reproduce the vast majority of what Flash was actively used for on the web in general. Like, my God, do you remember the restaurants that used Flash just to do simple mouseover drop-down menus? Do you really think that kind of bullshit should still be done in Flash?
- justinclift 3y ago> do you remember the restaurants that used Flash just to do simple mouseover drop-down menus? They've moved to restaurant specific apps (written in Swift or an Android equivalent), that you need to install on your mobile device just to order from their menu. While in their store already. :( :( :(
- danaris 3y agoAnd the user experience is still better.
- silenced_trope 3y agoMy first job was doing Actionscript + mxml. It was fine for the web, even as people talked about things like crashes and/or security vulnerabilities. The same can be said to be true of Javascript today (to a much lesser extent though). But the iPhone and iOS really killed it by not supporting it, at least that's my memory of it. I remember feeling fundamentally "uncool" by doing Flash/Actionscript/Mxml because right when I got that first job out of college was when Steve Jobs was doing the "Flash sucks" rounds. "It's dead." etc. I remember a couple of the Flash folks at my job went to a Flash conference where they would do cool things with art and animation. When they got back they bumped into some members of the iOS team who back then were the new hot commodity (both in demand and salary). And they said to the flash folks: "Oh people still use Flash?" snicker snicker. As an entry-level at the start of my career it made me feel like I was deprecated out of the gate working with legacy tech. I still remember Actionscript fondly though as well as all the web games I'd play.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- phire 3y agoFlash didn't die because it was bad. The reason why Flash became so popular is that while the development tools cost money, the player was free for anyone to install. Browsers eventually started installing Flash by default (mostly so they could solve some of the security issues with prompt updates). By 2005, Adobe had a major monopoly on dynamic web content. And then smartphones and tablets became a thing. Adobe didn't want to keep giving flash away for free, they wanted to exploit their monopoly for profit, by charging phone manufactures 25 cents per device for the right to include the flash runtime on their phones. Many Symbian, Windows CE, and later Android phones were paying this licensing fee to Adobe. I suspect this royalty fee is large part of the reason why Job's "Thought's on Flash" letter came about. The letter mostly talks about need for open standards, and it is right. But I think Adobe's insistence on royalty fees really rubbed Apple the wrong way. Maybe if Adobe wasn't trying to extort smartphone vendors for royalty fees, it would have survived, and Adobe could still be charging money for the flash creative tool today. Hell, if Adobe weren't trying to profit of the runtime, they wouldn't have had any objection to making the runtime an open standard and allowing anyone (including apple) create their own flash runtime implementations. Flash didn't die because it was bad. Flash died because Adobe tried to exploit their monopoly for profit, and the wider industry responded to the threat.
- justinclift 3y ago> Flash didn't die because it was bad. Well, it certainly wasn't helped by the Flash Player being a never ending source of serious security exploits, sandbox bypasses, and more. :(
- phire 3y agoYes, but that's only a problem with the runtime implementation. I remember a number of people pushing Adobe to transform the runtime into an open standard. Then every browser would have been allowed to create their own implementations that actually fit with their security model.
- justinclift 3y ago