6 ms·
We should do more social studies research into US subcultures that have significantly different marriage norms than the mainstream US. Mormons and Asians both h
by rayiner 3y ago
We should do more social studies research into US subcultures that have significantly different marriage norms than the mainstream US. Mormons and Asians both have strong taboos against divorce, and also have strong rates of upward mobility (i.e. much higher odds of kids from low income households ending up as high earning adults).
There is some research supporting the link, but not nearly enough: https://www.brookings.edu/articles/how-marriage-and-divorce-impact-economic-opportunity/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/how-marriage-and-divorce-... (“A child born to a never-married mother in the bottom fifth of family income is 3 times more likely to stay in the bottom fifth than a child born to a continuously married mother with equally low income.”).
It’s possible that it’s not marriage per se. Both Mormons and Asians socialize children into “do what you’re obliged to do, not what you want to do.” Marriage is one aspect of that—you get married, and you stay married, and what you “want” doesn’t really matter. But it might be that mentality that also drives upward mobility rather than marriage per se.
- curiousfiddler 3y agoBoth Mormons and Asians socialize children into “do what you’re obliged to do, not what you want to do.” Wow, that's incredibly reductive. Asia has approx 4.7 billion people!
- huytersd 3y agoHonestly, this thing holds true for most of them.
- DarknessFalls 3y agoHe said "US Mormons and Asians".
- squigz 3y agoTechnically, no, he didn't; note the period before Mormons
- tomjakubowski 3y agothe comment is about "US subcultures"
- _lvbh 3y agoI’d agree if not for the fact that this is somewhat true in much of Asia: China, India, Korea, Japan, Southeast Asia (Thailand, Malaysia, etc). I’m sure there are exceptions but it’s hard find counter examples
- huytersd 3y agoThe Bhagavat Gita is literally a tome that argues why it’s more important to do your duty/obligation over what you want.
- diogenescynic 3y ago>Wow, that's incredibly reductive. Asia has approx 4.7 billion people! Asian cultures are generally more collectivistic than individualistic compared to the West.
- anon291 3y agoThe west used to be much more collectivist. Christianity as it's been practiced for most of history is a collective religion. The rise of individualism corresponds to the rise of atheism and agnosticism and 'nones' in the west.
- redserk 3y agoAre you able to back this up? American individualism has existed for multiple generations, well before the rise of acceptance for atheism/agnosticism/“Nones”.
- rayiner 3y agoAmericans have always had an individualist streak, fueled by Protestant Christianity, the cultural influence of Appalachia, and cultural diversity. The communitarian parts of Christianity held that somewhat in check. But as even that falls away, america has become hyper-individualized and morality has become almost completely personalized.
- lapcat 3y ago> the cultural influence of Appalachia That's an incredible stretch. There are a number of other factors worth mentioning: - The philosophy of John Locke, who greatly influenced the founders - The US is a very new country, compared to those in Europe and Asia. The only preexisting culture was the Native Americans, and you (should) know what happened to them... - The US is a nation of immigrants who left (sometimes voluntarily, sometimes involuntarily) their previous countries and cultures. - The US is geographically very large and open. Even within the nation of immigrants, there was a huge amount of migration to populate "the west". - The US has a very weak central government, by design of the Constitution, and it never had a state church. There's no centralizing cultural force.
- ecshafer 3y agoThis is one of the reasons that I think Kant's ideas on Deontology (also Confucian philosophy around relationships) is the correct one for a functioning society. There is a framework of "Right" and "Wrong" that exists outside of "Good" and "Bad". Doing what is beneficial for society, and what is expected of society is right, regardless of the Good nature of it. If society expects you to fight in a war, and you kill someone, that is "Right" regardless of the fact that killing is "bad". But to bring this back to the topic on hand. It is right to study and work hard at school, it is right to be disciplined and not disrupt class, it is right to work a job and do well at the job. This is separate from the fact that you are may be a good person (nice, charitable, etc). A teenager who is good, but not working hard is being wrong. A large part of this is putting wants aside to do what is right.
- TerrifiedMouse 3y agoIt’s pretty much collectivism vs individualism. The West has mostly leaned towards individualism (aka “it's a free country”) while the East Asia under the influence of Confucianism is most collective. Collectivism has its downsides. It can be suffocating. Society also doesn’t always take into consideration an individual’s limitations when it comes to meeting societal obligations - a moot point in more individualistic societies.
- rayiner 3y ago> Collectivism has its downsides. Collectivism also has upsides. I’m fascinated by Mormons because they seem to me to be the most Asian white people. Mormon men have a life expectancy almost 10 years longer than other white men. They have among the highest social mobility in the country. They, along with Jews, top the charts in measures of mental well being. And this is all happening within the context of America. They deal with the same Obamacare, seem to have basically the same school systems, etc.
- MandieD 3y agoStrong, socially-enforced taboos against alcohol and tobacco consumption are probably a major driver of the longevity difference.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]