2 ms·
> lot of historical fiction is indeed made-up stuff All of it is made up. That is why it is called fiction. Authors are pretty open about that fact. It can no
by watwut 3y ago
> lot of historical fiction is indeed made-up stuff
All of it is made up. That is why it is called fiction. Authors are pretty open about that fact. It can not possibly "go deeper" then sourced factual history - because it uses sourced history as its only source of information about past.
Historical fiction writers read a lot of sourced history and then combine, modify, remove and add to make compeling story that would satisfy the audience.
- denton-scratch 3y ago> It can not possibly "go deeper" then sourced factual history Honestly, I think that's wrong. "Proper" historians make up a lot of stuff; they tell stories, because otherwise their work would simply be lists of citations. What they do is called history, because they are professional acaemic historians. But professional story-tellers can make up stories based on the same citations. > It can not possibly "go deeper" then sourced factual history. OK, well I think "factual history" is a dodgy concept. "Facts" about the past change every decade or so. The past becomes foggy immediately, then it turns into legend, then into myth.
- watwut 3y agoThis is really not true. It is not even true that historical books would actually write stories. Nor is it true that historical fiction would be limited to what was true about history. They literally intentionally make stuff up. That is what they are even expected to do.