3 ms·
This is something of a useless article as a discussion point, since it discusses the conclusions the book argues for and the controversy, but not much of the ac
by dragonwriter 3y ago
This is something of a useless article as a discussion point, since it discusses the conclusions the book argues for and the controversy, but not much of the actual argument, particularly its factual basis (assuming there is one) beyond post hoc ergo propter hoc.
Its worth noting that this issue has been discussed for a long time, and while the article acts as if the promotion of marriage in the face of trends the other way on a “think about the children” basis was a novel suggestion of the author, this is not at all the case; it’s been suggested for decades, been the basis of vast amounts of unsuccessful, even at the “step one” of actually influencing the marriage trend, public policy at the state and federal level (the latter as far back as the 1996 Personal Responsibility and Work Opportunity Reconciliation Act).
And there has been lots of analysis suggesting that marriage, per se, is not driving most of the difference, but things like income and parenting style are [0], and that those correlate with propensity to marry (but are not themselves driven by marriage), so promoting marriage is likely barking up the wrong tree.
[0] e.g., https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-marriage-effect-money-or-parenting/ https://www.brookings.edu/articles/the-marriage-effect-money...