3 ms·
One line in the oldest math text hinted at hidden universes [video]
- BWStearns 3y agoI was curious about Bolyai's appendix itself and was intrigued to see it was originally in Latin (https://www.unesco.org/en/memory-world/janos-bolyai-appendix-scientiam-spatii-absolute-veram-exhibens-maros-vasarhelyini-1832 https://www.unesco.org/en/memory-world/janos-bolyai-appendix...). I'm not a math expert by any stretch (nor a historian of math) but I had thought that German had become the lingua franca of mathematics by that point. Does anyone know if Latin was still the default for math in 1832?
- guiraldelli 3y agoLooking at Gauss publications [1], it seems he was publishing in Latin as far as the 1840s. [1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Friedrich_Gauss#Writings https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Carl_Friedrich_Gauss#Writings
- bandie91 3y agoHungary was under Austrian rule (German-speaking) which many disliked, including the lower nobility. Maybe this also played a role in preferring Latin over German.
- macrolocal 3y agoFWIW, that one line is the parallel postulate.
- Agentlien 3y agoI assumed so from the title and almost didn't check out the video when YouTube recommended it yesterday. Really glad I still did. As usual from Veritasium the video included a lot of interesting historical context that I had no idea about.
- thaumasiotes 3y agoThat wouldn't even come close to being "the oldest math text"...?
- bisby 3y agooldest "math text" certainly not. Wikipedia says "Elements is the oldest extant large-scale deductive treatment of mathematics." There is a category for which we can count it as "the oldest" The only older "important publications in math" Wikiepedia has are * "Moscow Mathematical Papyrus" from 1850 BC. This is referred to as a manuscript rather than a "text" though. * "Baudhayana Sulba Sutra" from 8th century BC. Which by all accounts seems to be actually a mass produced text with large reach. But also seems like these general don't contain proofs. and are more like a reference book than an explanation book. So Elements is several hundred years behind the competition, but for a journalist to simplify "Oldest major math book that made an attempt at explaining the core fundamentals of how math works instead of just giving equations and examples" down to "oldest math text" feels fair enough. As far as I can see, any older texts basically fall under "here is how the pythagorean theorem works" and not "here are the intrinsic laws that explain how math works, and thus why/how the pythagorean theorem works". The title is true for some definitions of "math text".
- thaumasiotes 3y ago> "Moscow Mathematical Papyrus" from 1850 BC. This is referred to as a manuscript rather than a "text" though. There's no difference. A manuscript is a written document. A text is a written document.
- fiddlerwoaroof 3y agoI think paleographers think of the text as an abstract object and manuscripts as approximations of it. E.g. you might have a couple hundred manuscripts (and other things like printings, etc) of Aristotle’s Physics, but the text is what you get after you identify and try to correct scribal errors.
- 3y ago
- malephex 3y agoIf you squint and hold it at an angle ...