3 ms·
That's an excellent and important question. And the answer is that prices will probably be expected to go up to some degree as a one-time thing, in a way that
by crazygringo 3y ago
That's an excellent and important question.
And the answer is that prices will probably be expected to go up to some degree as a one-time thing, in a way that would be approximately a wash for those already with plenty of income, but where it still makes a huge difference for those with little/no income, which is precisely the point.
For example if it's a one-time inflation bump of 10% and UBI of $10K/yr., then:
Person A with income $100,000/yr, now makes $110,000/yr., worth $100,000 in previous dollars
Person B with income $10,000/yr, now makes $20,000/yr., worth $18,182 in previous dollars
Person C with income $0/yr, now makes $10,000/yr., worth $9,091 in previous dollars
Again, this is precisely the goal: the extra income isn't supposed to mean anything for those who already have plenty of income. It's supposed to help those who don't, or those who lose their jobs, etc. Without a big government bureaucracy trying to determine who qualifies or not.
And it's important to realize that the inflation is a one-time event. Prices will rise but then they'll stop rising. And if it were 10% inflation over a year, that's the same as the usual targeted 2% inflation rate but compressed from 5 years. (And the central bank might very well target 0% inflation over the following 4 years to compensate.)
- hnfong 3y ago> And it's important to realize that the inflation is a one-time event What's the basis of that? The UBI is on-going, and inflation has a tendency to "stick".
- crazygringo 3y agoYes, the UBI is on-going, but it's a one-time shift in income levels, which is what generates the one-time inflation. The extra money keeps on getting spent each year -- it doesn't affect the economy in a cumulative way. The person who used to have $0, and now has $10K to spend this year, still only has $10K next year, and still only has $10K the year after. Inflation would only continue if that person received $10K in year one, $20K in year two, $30K in year three, etc. And inflation is a complicated thing, but it doesn't tend to stick when its causes are known, and known to be temporary. Inflation is governed by expectations, and those expectations are often unknown. In the case of UBI, it's extremely known. (Also remember that the UBI is not new money injected into the economy -- it's generally proposed as redistribution in the form of taxation. Which according to the simplest theory wouldn't generate any inflation at all, but because of the resulting shifts in consumption patterns, that's what generates the one-time inflation among basic consumer goods, housing, etc.)
- hnfong 3y agoI see. Makes sense (at least for first order effects). Thanks!