3 ms·
Look at all the other classes people are already sitting through for high school and not learning anything either. What makes you think this one would be any d
by eru 3y ago
Look at all the other classes people are already sitting through for high school and not learning anything either. What makes you think this one would be any different?
Already around the world high schools all have something highfalutin like 'teaching critical thinking' in their curriculum.
- TeMPOraL 3y ago> What makes you think this one would be any different? Because unlike almost all other classes, that one would be immediately beneficial in daily life, in a direct and apparent way.
- smokel 3y agoNo it won't, unless we build infrastructure for them to work with. Even worse, given modern security standards, I wouldn't be surprised if programming and scripting were to be prohibited in the next ten years or so.
- bee_rider 3y agoIt seems like a negative feedback loop or something, nobody uses these sorts of features, so nobody implements them, and then the skills are less useful…
- eru 3y agoMicrosoft Excel (or cloud-based spreadsheets) will always be allowed. Even if they remove scripting abilities, a clever person can remove a lot of office busy work with just basic Excel functionalities like pivot tables.
- eru 3y agoBasic scripting abilities would be beneficial years later for the subset of the kids who become office drones. I would agree with your assessment about 'immediately beneficial in daily life', if you were talking about a course offered to adults who are already working a white collar job.
- bee_rider 3y agoLiteracy rates in the US are pretty high I think, compared to where we were before k-12 schooling became standard. And most people can do basic arithmetic, right? The goal, I think, to start should be to get to the point where an office of 10 or so people has at least one or two who can string together basic scripts.
- onetokeoverthe 3y ago[dead]
- eru 3y ago> Literacy rates in the US are pretty high I think, compared to where we were before k-12 schooling became standard. 'Post hoc ergo propter hoc.' https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Post_hoc_ergo_propter_hoc By and large, kids from well-off parents were always more literate, and they still are. And the US is a lot richer now than it used to be.
- namaria 3y agoSo your reasoning is "elites have always been more educated then average, so standard education cannot have had an effect in average literacy"? It is far more reasonable (and verifiable) to conclude that widespread standard education is more than just correlated with higher average rates of literacy.
- eru 3y agoByran Caplan's Case Against Education might be a good place to start. The author has collected a lot of statistics.
- namaria 3y agoFor the second time in as many days, I find myself saying on HN: your argument only makes sense if you reduce all societal logic to economic logic. What a way to live.
- BeFlatXIII 3y agoAdd it to reach the average-smart kids, those without internal knowledge of where to look or internal motivation to learn (but still will take the advanced classes for a grade).