3 ms·
> Couldn't you easily (try to) argue this for essentially any industry? Yes you can and some do. Harvest trees on national forest land? Permit required. Grazin
by cratermoon 3y ago
> Couldn't you easily (try to) argue this for essentially any industry?
Yes you can and some do. Harvest trees on national forest land? Permit required. Grazing cattle on BLM land? Gotta pay grazing fees.
Of course, those fees haven't been increased in decades. In the case of grazing fees, the fee is lower than in 1981. https://www.hcn.org/articles/south-public-lands-whats-getting-more-expensive-everything-but-grazing-fees https://www.hcn.org/articles/south-public-lands-whats-gettin...
I see another comment asserting that low fees ensure the system "doesn't discriminate against small businesses and even individuals", but ignores the true barriers to entry, meaning that in practice the only folks who pay these fees are companies for which the expense amounts to proverbial pocket change. Sure, I could file a mining claim for $225 and afford the $165/annually, pretty much as long as I live. Would I ever be able to do anything with my claim? Unlikely. Best I could hope for is that a global mining conglomerate would offer to buy it off me.
- jandrewrogers 3y agoThe limiter on those grazing fees is water availability and water rights, which are usually owned by private parties or the State. Any grazing land without water isn't worth much and leasing water rights isn't that cheap.