3 ms·
It often suffices to find one remotely triggerable unsafe memory write in a huge executable to achieve RCE. Memory safe would be 0% unsafe.
by nine_k 3y ago
It often suffices to find one remotely triggerable unsafe memory write in a huge executable to achieve RCE.
Memory safe would be 0% unsafe.
- minitech 3y ago“n% unsafe” here refers to `unsafe` blocks that can’t be automatically guaranteed safe by the Rust compiler, not to actual concrete instances of memory unsafety.
- josephg 3y agoRight. And even if you only work in “safe rust”, a massive part of the software stack you rely on still isn’t formally verified like that. LLVM and rustc aren’t formally verified - and they likely have bugs. The kernel is all “unsafe” code. And the rust standard library is full of unsafe code. And so on. Moving heaven and earth to excise the last 2% of unsafe code in random rust libraries just doesn’t make engineering sense. Especially when doing so comes with a significant performance cost. If reliability is what you’re after, that time is almost certainly better spent adding more tests, fuzz testing and validating your code with Miri and friends.