3 ms·
You could argue that this is actually a good. By leveraging a small processing fee per claim (225), and a small annual maintenance fee (165), the system effecti
by keepamovin 3y ago
You could argue that this is actually a good. By leveraging a small processing fee per claim (225), and a small annual maintenance fee (165), the system effectively doesn't discriminate against small businesses and even individuals who want to seek their fortune mining the land.
The above fees only address the provisional stake holding, and environmental permits must be acquired before any mining commences. While the requirements to obtain EPA permission could be seen as nullifying any advantages to small business from the low prospecting fees, it's also likely that once a prospector finds minerals they could also obtain partners or funding which would help share the cost of any additional permits required.
While it's true that the state does not benefit financially from mineral extraction in the form of royalties, in many cases states are able to collect taxes from the operations of businesses involved in the mining, processing and sale of minerals, as other commenters point out.
It's conceivable that an additional layer of tariffs in the form of royalties may make mining operations more difficult for small businesses and individuals, undermining (pun intended) the intended benefits of the low barriers to entry for prospecting.
It is also possible to make a connection with how large incumbent companies often lobby for more regulations. While a seeming paradox, this behavior actually helps protect their business by introducing additional barriers to entry that help keep out startups and smaller newcomers. These added costs, while affordable for the largest of companies, are often prohibitively expensive and burdensome for would-be competitors.
This shows a paradox: regulations meant to ensure fair business and collective good can sometimes just cement monopolies.
- ethbr1 3y agoAgreed! The article would be stronger if it didn't conflate environmental pollution issues (covered by subsequent EPA approvals) and conveniently leave out corporate taxes. If author thinks royalties should be imposed, make that point! But don't handwave at 'all the bad stuff THEY do' as justification. > Then, as now, corporations could pull unlimited quantities of minerals from their claims without paying a cent of royalties to the minerals’ actual owner — the American public. This amounts to a subsidy of hundreds of millions of dollars per year, mostly to multinational corporations.
- 4RealFreedom 3y agoThe article would be stronger if it stuck to one issue. Is the problem the clean-up, the fact that there's little environmental oversight when exploring, or the fact that the there should be royalties? They've conflated so many issues and didn't give any specifics. How does exploring negatively affect the environment? What does reclamation look like today rather than the 1800s?
- ThomPete 3y agohow does not exploring negatively effect human prosperity and flourishing? That seems to be the question one should ask.
- gremlinunderway 3y agoExcept you're forgetting about the issue of how to incorporate indigenous decision making on their traditional land. This law doesn't require any consent or permission with local indigenous peoples.
- oh_sigh 3y agoWould that entail the entirety of the United States? Indigenous people would have had a say, if the claims were located in the nearby Bears Ears National Monument. But it was just next to it, so why would they get a say?
- landemva 3y agoIn the States where I have experience, nearby property owners due comment about new/changed permits. And they can and do sue the permitting agencies to stop mine development. It's NIMBY when people stop local sand and gravel pits which forces those buildng materials to be trucked in. https://www.pca.state.mn.us/business-with-us/aggregate-sand-and-gravel https://www.pca.state.mn.us/business-with-us/aggregate-sand-...
- keepamovin 3y agoI was forgetting that, I'm sorry for my oversight. You bring up an excellent point! Considering the original owners of the land is absolutely fundamental, and their genuine input into the environmental assessment process is crucial to creating a sustainable use of the environment.
- mizzao 3y ago/s ?
- keepamovin 3y agoIs that how you see it, Andrew, as a bad idea? What makes you say that? As in, what makes you believe that considering original owners would be considered a bad idea and therefore likely to be delivered sarcastically?
- smogcutter 3y agoI’m skeptical that individual prospectors have a meaningful part in modern mining, or even really continue to exist in practice. At least as anything more than hobbyists. This is the kind of thing we can reason about a priori all we want, but the, I suppose, posteriori is very straightforward and knowable: either a population of independent miners benefiting from this rule as you describe exists, or it does not. I don’t know the answer, and don’t really expect much anyone else here to know. But I’d expect that for those connected to the industry it’s very plain. Without facts though, everything else is hot air. Anyway, the only way I’ve really heard of startup mining concerns is as private equity scams targeting rich-but-not-wealthy dentist and chamber of commerce types.
- landemva 3y agoI know people buying and working claims in previously worked hard rock, silver gold. Some do well. Small ball, but good individually. I also know a guy looking for funding to set up a mill for his gold claims with proven lab results. > I’d expect that for those connected to the industry it’s very plain. I respect your humility. Well done. > Without facts though, everything else is hot air. Most opinions on this thread are (kindly) incomplete.
- keepamovin 3y agoYou make a compelling point about the role of expertise in discussions like these. While firsthand experience is valuable, it's also important to note that thoughtful discussion can be insightful even without it. For example, in the context of the U.S. mining history, the 1872 Mining Law was originally designed to encourage individual prospectors to explore the West. Although the mining industry has evolved significantly, the law and its legacy still affect land management and resource extraction policies today. While most of us probably aren't mining industry veterans, discussing these policies can lead to a broader understanding that benefits everyone. While it's hard to say how many small ball operations benefit from these regulations, a lack of opportunist prospectors does not imply there’s a lack of opportunity. It could be argued that it's crucial to preserve this opportunity for future participants even if presently there may be few. It's worth mentioning that limiting discussions to experts could stifle diversity of thought. Take the legal system: many landmark decisions, from Brown v. Board of Education to Roe v. Wade, were influenced not just by legal experts but also by public opinion and social movements. If discussions were closed off to 'experts,' we might miss out on valuable perspectives that can drive change. In short, while it's good to acknowledge the limits of our own knowledge and authority to enjoin discussions, it's equally important to remember that these limitations likely apply to everyone, including those attempting to determine who is permitted to participate in conversations.
- landemva 3y ago> EPA And there are State regulators, though typically just a handful. https://dws.wyo.gov/dws-division/mine-inspections-safety/ https://dws.wyo.gov/dws-division/mine-inspections-safety/ The federal regulator MSHA has massive power and they visit on schedules (often quarterly, depends on mine size) and unannounced. Anyone can call MSHA hotline and file anonymous report, and MSHA investigates and writes citations. MSHA inspector can literally stop work and send staff home with pay. https://arlweb.msha.gov/PROGRAMS/assess/citationsandorders.asp https://arlweb.msha.gov/PROGRAMS/assess/citationsandorders.a... > While it's true that the state does not benefit financially from mineral extraction in the form of royalties Mineral royalties go to feds with a split to States. Wyoming legislature has a flowchart which says in part, "Federal mineral royalties are generally split evenly between the federal government and the state governments of origin ...". https://www.wyoleg.gov/2021/Databook/Operations/Revenue/f-Federal%20Mineral%20Royalties%20Flow%20Chart.pdf https://www.wyoleg.gov/2021/Databook/Operations/Revenue/f-Fe... From HCN article, "The law hasn’t fundamentally changed in 151 years ...". Maybe it works okay and stands the test of time. Along the way extraction pollution (water air noise) and remediation have changed significantly.