4 ms·
I, for one, love pseudo-science. I dig UFO studies (what better way to learn about the process of learning?), world religions (what drives people to vary their
by DanielBMarkham 18y ago
I, for one, love pseudo-science. I dig UFO studies (what better way to learn about the process of learning?), world religions (what drives people to vary their beliefs so widely yet cling to each detail?), reincarnation (are those strange stories true or just crap?) and all sorts of things that involve reason, creativity, and some sort of evidential and symbolic modeling process.
But I know it ain't science. It's fun, it's speculative, and it's entertaining. It ain't science.
What I don't like is when religion joins with theories that can not be reliably tested and scare-mongering under the rubric of science. Then they deny being the pseudo science that they are. Seems like it combines the worst of everything: end-of-days, a call for repentance, smearing the critics, and smarmy self-righteousness.
That's just my opinion, mind you. I really think if you've only got one earth, a hugely complex environment and some kind of computer modeling system that a little degree of humility probably is a good idea. I'm happy with saying "I don't know." Seems like even (or especially) if you take a large grant that should be a fine response.
Global warming may be true and deadly. But that still doesn't make it science.
I'm looking forward to the new Czech pol. Discussion and skepticism is a good thing, especially when it comes to science.
- dejb 18y ago> Global warming may be true and deadly. But that still doesn't make it science. What is science but the study of physical truth? Isn't the ultimate aim of science to be able understand the way the things work so that it is possible to project the conseqences of different actions into the future? Your position is irrational and stupid.
- emmett 18y agoI agree with you, but "Your position is irrational and stupid" is abusive, and likely to cause people to believe that you are in the wrong. Which is unfortunate, because in this instance you are right.
- dejb 18y agoI think it is an unfortunate situation where insulting a stupid proposition is seen as worse than proposing it in the first place. My belief is that thinking people should take a tougher line on ignorance, irrationality and stupidity. By choosing to engage with these type of opinions with a 'neutral stance' you are giving strength and legitimacy to their arguments. You are essentially saying 'Although your argument seems reasonable, I disagree for the following reasons'. So maybe I went too far. But I do think there should be a cost for making spurious arguments. Also I feel the casual viewer of arguments shyould be left in no doubt as to the validity of the original statement.
- lutorm 18y ago"What I don't like is when religion joins with theories that can not be reliably tested and scare-mongering under the rubric of science. Then they deny being the pseudo science that they are. Seems like it combines the worst of everything: end-of-days, a call for repentance, smearing the critics, and smarmy self-righteousness." So what you are saying is that if scientists comment on the apparent societal consequences of their research, it is religion or pseudoscience? At the same time, if someone who's not a scientist comments on those things, people will say that they are unqualified and doesn't know what they are talking about. That's a nice recipe for making science irrelevant to society, it seems to me.
- MaysonL 18y agoThing is - global warming is indubitably happening, and, although the mix of causes is unclear, human fossil fuel usage is one of them. Getting off fossil fuels is also the economically sensible thing to do.