3 ms·
The greatest missed opportunity of organic content ranking is a robust mechanism for human feedback. Google has attempted to rank the trustworthiness/quality of
by xnx 3y ago
The greatest missed opportunity of organic content ranking is a robust mechanism for human feedback. Google has attempted to rank the trustworthiness/quality of content with almost no feedback from search users. About the only crude feedback that a search user can provide to Google is to return to search results and click on another result. Even that signal is largely ambiguous in meaning. Google has a team of trusted raters, but their work has not been sufficient to match the scale of bad actors manipulating content. With the advent of LLMs, there's another chance to get human-feedback right. This is being done now with RLHF, but that human-feedback system will need to be more aggressively designed against adversarial input as that feedback signal becomes more significant (and therefore profitable) to those who would distort it. TikTok is a good example of how effective a system with simple ranking rules can be when there is a tremendous volume of active and passive feedback from users (likes, subscribes, shares, total watch time, blocks/reports, etc.)
- Kim_Bruning 3y agoBack in the day, google recognized that people linking to other people on the open web was in fact a form of human feedback. Of course, these days many users don't have their own personal websites anymore. (or in % terms, probably less than when google first started). But that's a story for another day.
- xnx 3y agoExactly. The original thesis of Google assumed humans creating earnest links between related/valuable content. In the modern web that realistically only happens in closed and semi-closed social networks. The vast majority of links on public web pages must now be assumed to be for calculated SEO value. There's a slim sliver of hope that a more open/federated system will replace Twitter (and ideally Facebook/Instagram too). I wish Google would do more to encourage this via Blogger or other mechanisms.
- brucethemoose2 3y agoIf Google ran a Tiktok-like system for long enough, it would be gamed too. Honestly, Google search probably needs to burn to the ground to get better. That seems to be the most reliable antidote to enshittification.
- xnx 3y ago> If Google ran a Tiktok-like system for long enough, it would be gamed too. There would certainly be huge incentive to try to manipulate/game signals to boost rankings, but walled gardens (like TikTok) benefit the huge advantage of having logged-in identities for both content creators and content viewers.
- verdverm 3y agoThey most certainly took human actions into account, did you click on a search results and then come back? Did you click on multiple, or stay on one for a while? Not all feedback needs to be direct and specific, though this is a feature I've long hoped for in Google Search. While I expect it to be useful, it would also be gamed by the SEO industry. They have a paper that talks about many of the complexities: https://research.google/pubs/pub43146/ https://research.google/pubs/pub43146/
- chomp 3y agoGood insight into what feedback from (technical) search users looks like: https://kagi.com/stats https://kagi.com/stats > "Domain Insights"