5 ms·
Lego's packing process isn't perfect
- unwind 15y agoThis part: Along the way, we both learnt some important facts about the Lego manufacturing process made me smile. I'm not sure if it's tongue-in-cheek or not, but the post does go on with quite the analysis (all based on guesses) of how they might have ended up with a set that was missing quite a few pieces. Still, I think the number of humans for which this hand-waving is considered to be both a) important and b) facts is quite limited. :)
- tmh88j 15y ago>I came up with an interesting idea — a missing bag. I would assume that Lego precisely measures the individual bags, not the entire set. What the author said about a missing bag pretty much confirms my suspicion of this. They must have some QA measure to determine the number of bags included, but weighing the entire box will result in less precision than the individual bags. Not to mention, if it does show up as less weight, the entire box needs to be checked out, not just one bag.
- Someone 15y agoThey can measure the bags, but that does not guarantee that those bags end up in the box. Also, there is a series on Discovery called "How it's made" (or so) I remember seeing one about Lego; they did measure the box. That leaves open the risk of exchanging bags. Maybe, they are decreasing that by making sure that all bags hanging around when they are filling boxes for a particular set are different in weight? I do not know whether that makes sense for huge sets, though. The variance in weight between boxes would, at some set size, outstrip the average size of a bag.
- smackfu 15y ago>The first that boggles many Lego builders of such large sets, is the arrangement of pieces within the bags. Actually, a lot of the larger sets now use numbered bags around bags, so that you only have to deal with 1/2 or 1/3 of the parts at once. Not all the large sets though... I just built the VW Bus and it was just a big piles of 1300 bricks.
- seclorum 15y agoI've always wanted to build a lego sorter/filter that is basically a box with various sieve levels inside, where you pour the unsorted pieces in the top, they cascade through the sieves, and out the bottom/along the sides come pieces, sorted by shape/size. The mathematics of this fascinates me, and I think it could be done .. but where to start with the math? Anyone know of anything like this .. ?
- Tichy 15y agoI want to do this ever since my son got his first Lego pieces. It is amazing how quickly you can evoke the impression of chaos with lots of tiny Lego pieces (my machine should also hover the pieces off the floor before sorting them). Hopefully Lego Mindstorms will be up to the task, I still haven't bought one, though. I think easiest would be to sort by weight first. But the pure mechanical approach of a sieve is attractive, too. Might be a good project for trying out a laser cutter.
- seclorum 15y agoI have access to a laser cutter, this is exactly what I had in mind - to create a set of masks that would, layered upon each other, filter out each part until they're sorted. Rather a large effort, though .. and I wonder if there is a way to model this without having to laser-cut a lot of test pieces. Well, I think about it every time we end a Lego Mindstorms session in my house, anyway .. ;)
- tmh88j 15y agoNot to be a downer, but I don't see that working to well for different shapes, only general sizes. 1. It would be nearly impossible to account for length of rectangular pieces. Every rectangular piece of same width x height could go through that hole vertically 2. Smaller pieces could fall through every hole larger than itself. So, unless you're using a multi-tier system it's pointless. Basically, I think it could be easily done for general sizes of pieces, not shapes. I'd love someone to prove me wrong because that would be an awesome tool to have.
- 15y ago