3 ms·
SMS has become a huge pain to send, because of spam. I ran into this with my steampunk telegraph office. We ran a telegraph office at steampunk conventions, whe
by Animats 3y ago
SMS has become a huge pain to send, because of spam. I ran into this with my steampunk telegraph office. We ran a telegraph office at steampunk conventions, where attendees could send in a message via SMS, and it was typed out on an antique teletype machine. A messenger at the con would then deliver a proper telegram in person.[1] I recruited some young actors to run the office, and it was a hit.
This used Twilio. Users sent an SMS to Twilio. Twilio then made an HTTP request to our server, which queued the message for the Teletype machine and replied to the sender with an SMS message. This is what Twilio calls inbound SMS - text comes in, reply goes back in the HTTP reply. You can't send unsolicited SMS via the inbound system. It's a unit transaction.
This now has to be registered as an "advertising campaign". There's an additional per-month fee, and a vetting process. You have to have an identifiable company. I could go through all that to comply, but steampunk is pretty much over and we stopped doing cons when COVID hit.
The spam industry effectively defines a "transactional message" as someone messaged in once, so now you can spam them forever. ("Now you can buy more of that thing you bought last year!") Regulation now works on that basis. So even services that are inherently one request/reply are regulated as "ad campaigns."
This is why we can't have nice things.
[1] https://vimeo.com/124065314 https://vimeo.com/124065314
- ianhawes 3y agoYes but now that the telcos have collected the monthly fee, we don't have anymore spam problems! /s
- Xorakios 3y agoWow what an awesomely nice thing to have that bridge at a steampunk. Never would have thought of it but now makes me want to send a telegram and shock the recipient with the retro-ness!
- Animats 3y agoThat was a fun project, from the TechShop/maker era. "Anyone can be punk, but to be steampunk you need a good tailor and access to a machine shop."
- simfree 3y agoThis is almost certainly a Peer to Peer use case, despite what The Campaign Registry might claim. 1 to 1 conversations where the user is contacting you is hard to argue as anything but P2P, you would be best off with a P2P texting enablement provider or toll free texting.