5 ms·
> Shooting on a camera locked at 24fps is not equal to shooting 24fps. Care to explain? I know quite a bit about camera technology and don't have the slightes
by crazygringo 3y ago
> Shooting on a camera locked at 24fps is not equal to shooting 24fps.
Care to explain?
I know quite a bit about camera technology and don't have the slightest idea of what you mean with this sentence.
- ZiiS 3y agoThe only generous interpretation I can see is that Aronofsky uses extremely innovative techniques yet has long publicly voiced that he prefers to use analog film. For instance some of his signature style is short shots taken with cameras mounted on actors in dark conditions which vastly easier to realize with digital yet he has repeatedly chosen to use film. Whilst it is perfectly consistent that what would change his mind is an extremely powerful digital camera; it is also possible that the resulting PR spin causes some frustration to a generation of professionals who have been working in digital for 20 years and not been given shiny 18K cameras to play with.
- spacecadet 3y agoHe only did that in Pi. Maybe thats all he is known for, but I wouldn't call it his style anymore.
- ZiiS 3y agoAnd Requiem but yes that was only one example, he has an amazing and varied output.
- spacecadet 3y agoIt has nothing to do with tech. The same reason Daren shoots film is why I still shoot film, at any speeds. Since almost no one chooses to shoot true 24fps anymore, everything is sampled down and so everything I watch looks like shit. Sharp, but jittery shit. Use the tool for the situation. I actually respect the tech behind the sphere and 18k cameras, because it's purpose built and I imagine looks lovely in its native speed and fov. But Daren... this piece is gross man.
- crazygringo 3y agoYou still haven't defined what "true 24fps" is, and the idea that it "has nothing to do with tech" makes no sense. 24 fps is a technical term, no more and no less. And everyone here is left baffled because it seems to be some personal notion of yours, as opposed to what it is universally and clearly understood to mean. I literally have no idea what you mean when you talk about things being "sampled down" or "sharp, jittery shit". The only thing sampled down in most modern TV/film production is a usually a 4K source down into 1080p or less for distribution. But I can't possibly imagine you're objecting to that. And frame rates aren't "sampled down". Meanwhile, by "jittery" I can only guess you mean shutter speed, not frame rate? Normal shutter angle is 180°, and that has been standard for many, many decades, identical between film and digital, and which has never been jittery. Sometimes action scenes use a smaller angle (faster speed), which you're free to call jittery, but that's not the norm. Generally just for action scenes, or for occasional other artistic effect. If you want to have any kind of productive conversation on HN, I suggest you start explaining what you actually mean rather than throwing around terms with idiosyncratic personal definitions you simply invent, that have nothing to do with how the terms are generally understood.
- clnq 3y agoI never thought about this, but what if you shoot at 30 fps and want to produce 24? How do you map 30 onto 24 time-wise? In 30, each frame lasts 33.33ms. In 24 it’s 41.66. So if the first frame is synced, the second frame of something captured in 30 and transformed to 24 would show up 8.3ms too late. The third - 16.ms, and so on. It’s not possible to properly sync video to 24fps if it was shot at 30 without interpolation, right?
- Kirby64 3y agoIt’s commonly done the other way, actually. Converting 24fps to 30fps for converting film (typically shot at 24fps) to TV broadcast ready, which is 29.97 fps in the US/NTSC region. That said, you can go the other way. Basically, you interlace certain frames. Wikipedia has a great article on this. https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-two_pull_down#2:3 https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/Three-two_pull_down#2:3