7 ms·
I agree with your analysis. I think news is generally accurately reported. I agree there can be some slant and distortion in the telling, and in my opinion it c
by jauntywundrkind 3y ago
I agree with your analysis. I think news is generally accurately reported. I agree there can be some slant and distortion in the telling, and in my opinion it calls for response; I love efforts like alas shuttered Newstrition that would display a news nutrition label, with things like a "spin" factor. I think there are layers we can and should be getting better at to temper ourselves as consumers. https://ijnet.org/en/story/newstrition-labels-aim-help-readers-identify-misinformation https://ijnet.org/en/story/newstrition-labels-aim-help-reade...
However, the bulk of the parents argument wasn't about the veracity of the news, albeit your quote did show a strong dig from the parent. The parent was chiefly arguing that being aware of the world seems to be a bad thing, and that globally we would be better people by not being aware at all of the world. No matter what the news looked like, the parent argued, we shouldn't read it.
It feels like some crazy dark world shit to me. I can't imagine a return to the darkness, to being unaware of each other & the happenings of this planet. It's a burden, yes, and I think there's a ton to recommend about finding balance where local matters and our own lives aren't so entirely outshadowed or even sandblasted away by the enormity of the acts unfolding upon the global stage. But I just think of ignorant easy to manipulate peasants & awful fuedal systems, when we can't or won't consider the setting & events of this planet.
We are a better species for this noospheric connection we have, and rather than fret about whether we should go back, I'd like to figure out how to progress forwards, like to figure out how we can do it better.
- smeej 3y agoParent here. I don't think I said we would be better off with no awareness of the broader world. I said we would be better off without Google News and the kind of megacorp news networks it features. I also said that our awareness of issues we can actually affect should outweigh our awareness of things we can't. If you know ten of your neighbors by name, you're in a vanishingly small minority in much of the Western world today. I would happily take a bet saying no one in this thread can name ten of their neighbors, what they do for work, and two things those people care about, without counting more than two from the same household. That is "some crazy dark world shit" to me. People don't know the people who spend half their lives within a mile of them, and yet they can spout of random information about dozens celebrities or conflicts or politicians thousands of miles away. Humanity is weaker because of this. Only when we can do this better can we afford to try to extend our awareness.