3 ms·
> Virgin and Child Surrounded by Angels, right panel of the diptych. So many of these paintings portray human faces in near-photorealistic detail... and then t
by pavel_lishin 3y ago
> Virgin and Child Surrounded by Angels, right panel of the diptych.
So many of these paintings portray human faces in near-photorealistic detail... and then the woman's chest looks like a piece of stretched-out vellum with two hemispheres glued onto it.
- Steven420 3y agoLooks like a botched boob job
- itsthebiz 3y agoIt looks like the beginning of a paper titled “Historical argument for the existence of Breast Augmentation” much in the same vein of “Jesus is real because Judaea existed” or “Spiderman is real because New York is a real city”.
- kirubakaran 3y agoPerhaps it was the artist, not the subject, that was the virgin
- mcpackieh 3y agoThe two men have realistic skin tones, but the woman and baby look like they're carved out of marble or covered in chalk. I guess the latter reflect what the artist considered to be an aesthetic ideal and aren't intended to be true-to-life realistic.
- pvaldes 3y agoCreating contrast between the ugly real world, with all its pain, suffering and grotesque details, and the spiritual world of gods where everybody is rewarded with an inner glow in their perfect skins. An universally employed narrative
- unmole 3y agoYou see something similar in Hindu iconography. Humans are painted brown, the colour of the earth. Gods like Rama, Krishna and Shiva are painted blue, the colour of the heavens.
- NHQ 3y agoThe contrast tells us "the right side is obviously stylized, and this illustrates that the left side is rendered with realistic perspective". Which means the rock is round and proves the authors incorrect because they overlook this obvious perspective to claim the rock is flat and axe-like to make their comparison. Their theory rests entirely on the rock in the painting being flat, which could only be true if the perspective was flat. The painter made sure we can see that is not the case. The painter is telling us there is a narrative and a reality. They baby appears unconvinced and suspicious, as if he knows there is an alternate truth to the story. He appears to be pointing at rock. The baby is telling us he is not the subject, the rock is.
- pavel_lishin 3y agoIsn't the rock on the left, "realistic", side?
- NHQ 3y agoThe rock is shown in realistic perspective, indicating depth. However, the authors presume that we are looking at the exact front of a flat object, such as an axe blade. The realistic perspective disqualifies that presumption. If the rock was flat and blade-like, the painter could have shown this explicitly by painting the rock at an angle, like the corner of the wall behind them men.
- pvaldes 3y agoIs a divinity, so either is a stylized image of "perfection" (whatever it meant in their cultural context); or they tried deliberately to depict the most "non sexually exciting" image possible, while keeping the symbolic aspects
- oh_sigh 3y agothe artist might have been working with a male model
- lostlogin 3y agoMy (high school) art history taught me that this was a thing. Then they added breasts by sort of guessing. You’d think that adding them in the armpit region would be obviously wrong, but at the same time, it’s better than any painting I’ll ever attempt in my lifetime. The babies have all got much more natural looking chests. It’s got a surreal feel with the colour palette and plastic feel.
- analog31 3y agoThe mens' fingers are also unrealistically long. And I don't think the painter was unskilled.
- every 3y agoThis is early Northern Renaissance and still retains a number of Gothic themes and motifs. He nailed the vanishing point though...