3 ms·
> I think people forget just how bad compatibility was a decade ago. I think you're forgetting how long ago the issues were. It was pretty bad in the 2.7-2.9 d
by lmm 3y ago
> I think people forget just how bad compatibility was a decade ago.
I think you're forgetting how long ago the issues were. It was pretty bad in the 2.7-2.9 days, but a decade ago was already into the 2.10 era.
> This led to the ironic situation that it was easier to use Java JARs from Scala than to use Scala JARs. If the ecosystem had used source dependencies instead of binary dependencies, this could have been avoided, even if compile times may have been horrendous.
I don't think that would've been worth it. Binary dependencies work great given that libraries cross-build; the real issue was back when source compatibility was broken often enough that that wasn't practical.
> For an example I'm sure many people here will remember viscerally, Lift Web kept making substantial backwards-incompatible changes regularly even after they knew they had commercial users who faced real-world costs for churn.
I don't think there'll be many remembering that. Lift was big, what, 15 years ago? It was already fading by the time I started Scala back in 2011.
- fl0ki 3y agoThat's just the thing, Scala and its ecosystem had these problems right at the height of its popularity, meaning that the situation was the worst right when the most people were around to experience it, and understandably many never looked back. Even if many individuals can look past it, it's become a very hard sell to teams. It's the same story with any kind of merit vs trust. When you have a clean slate, you can build trust based on your merit, but once you break trust, merit alone isn't enough to win it back. In this industry in particular, far too many other options are already holding and building trust. I truly wish Scala had indeed become the mainstream industry language instead of say Go. I hope Rust polishes off its rough edges and succeeds where Scala failed and where Go doesn't go far enough. But I don't see any future where Scala regains industry relevance, not even if both Go and Rust self-destruct as well.
- lmm 3y agoMeh. OCaml spent over a decade underappreciated, fixed a few sticking points like package management, and then underwent a resurgence. I'd like to think that merit will ultimately win through.