3 ms·
>reliable mainstream sources at the national level And does anyone actually believe this is applied consistently? I'm willing to bet that there are countless
by ghaff 3y ago
>reliable mainstream sources at the national level
And does anyone actually believe this is applied consistently?
I'm willing to bet that there are countless Wikipedia articles about people in technical, academic, local political, etc., etc. roles/positions that wouldn't meet that criterion.
- starkparker 3y agoNo Wikipedia policy is applied consistently. They're applied when editors want to apply them to justify a decision. That's how every individual decision on Wikipedia works; precedent doesn't even apply.
- johnnyanmac 3y agonope, but that's the neat part (well, neat in the "morbidly scary" sort of way). They don't need to. If a topic is niche enough there won't be enough wiki editors well versed enough to argue for nor against the obviously asinine requirements. they can quash women's football for lacking a national mainstream source but then pull out some esoteric source for their own pet project uninhibited (again, assuming the topic is niche enough to go under the "mainstream editor" radar). Classic lawful evil behavior.
- hk__2 3y agoOf course it’s not 100% consistent, just like any rule in any project where tens of thousands of people work together. That’s what makes Wikipedia great: you don’t have to get your article validated by some random comitee of 20 persons; you just read the rules and try to respect them. It won’t be perfect, but you can always ask someone with more experience to review the article.