2 ms·
I'm much more inclusionist than deletionist. And find there's a lot of both randomness and irony in what qualifies as notable, especially given that notability
by ghaff 3y ago
I'm much more inclusionist than deletionist. And find there's a lot of both randomness and irony in what qualifies as notable, especially given that notability can be a very local thing. On the other hand, it's probably fair that not everyone who has ever had their name in print or has a website should have a Wikipedia entry.
- bombcar 3y agoThey need something like "wikipedia adjacent" to allow for inclusionism without authority - it's not like they're limited by the size of a bound encyclopedia.
- ethbr1 3y agoWikipedia is an excellent example of something that would benefit from an upstream, less-authoritative, more-comprehensive source. Unfortunately, it seems so ossified that that work can only be done within Wikipedia (notable article, standards, etc). A far more reasonable approach would have been to have CommonPedia... and then regularly pull qualifying information into Wikipedia.
- hk__2 3y ago> They need something like "wikipedia adjacent" to allow for inclusionism without authority This is called "The Web". You’re free to write whatever you want, it’s just not on Wikipedia. > it's not like they're limited by the size of a bound encyclopedia. No, but articles still require maintainance, so it’s false to say that just because this is "in the cloud" you can have an infinite number of articles.
- ethbr1 3y agoThe ugliest edit war I've seen involved a less-known adult film star. Her legal name had appeared in some public court filings, and some user had added it to her Wikipedia page with the reference. Someone else (purportedly one of her co-stars) had requested removal. A Wikipedia editor then got involved, and refused to budge from the position the original actress was notable enough to merit inclusion of her legal name. Cue months of back-and-forth deletions and reversions. Finally, I think a year later, someone quietly edited the legal name out and it stuck. Sometimes people with a little power are the greatest assholes. Probably because they sought the little power.
- sumtechguy 3y agoWhat is worse is the people who went thru the trouble to make those edits in the first place will conclude that it is not worth the trouble to fix this. Then go on to not make other edits because 'of that last time'. That sort of fight you basically have to stay at until someone gives up. As neither side is going to budge. Then you can do like what happened here. Let the other side think they won. Wait a year and put what you want and it would probably stand as they moved on ages ago.
- permo-w 3y agothere's a certain free-to-play multiplayer game I used to play that is absolutely full of cheaters. on one server some people built a base opposite me, and for a while I sat in my sniper's nest and took pot-shots at them. then suddenly they absolutely got my number (turned on their cheats) and I couldn't walk inside my base without getting headshot through walls. I tried my best to kill them but I realised that they were staying online just for the sake of killing me. so I logged off, came back on after an hour and blew their base to fucking kingdom come. wikipedia seems to be the same. people feed off the conflict, and if you just let the conflict die, eventually you can come and take the spoils unopposed
- avar 3y agoAn actress notable enough to merit her own Wikipedia article didn't want her name known, but her name was a matter of public record? I don't know about this case, but it seems entirely reasonable that to argue for including the name, or not. Plenty of public personas have aliases they wish to be known by, but their Wikipedia article prominently notes their real name.
- permo-w 3y agosurely people should have a right to privacy wrt this kind of thing?
- avar 3y agoWikipedia isn't a primary source, and it needs to be verifiable. So by definition it's not exposing any information you can't find in other public sources. Whether it's notable and something that should be included is another matter. In any case, I'm saying that if you look at the articles for Madonna, Bono, Jenna Jameson, Marilyn Manson etc. you'll find their real name displayed prominently. We can't form our own opinion in this case, as the GP is deliberately keeping the specific article in question hidden. But in general this seems like a thing two editors could reasonably disagree about.