8 ms·
Nonprofit hospitals skimp on charity while CEOs reap millions, report finds
- samjohnation111 3y ago[dead]
- cowmix 3y agoFWIW.. my mother's childhood friend is a nun who (successfully) ran a hospital in the Buffalo NY area for years up until the late 90s/early 2000s. She was replaced by a series of "civilian" CEOs after that. AFAIK, the quality of care OR the finances of the place didn't improve one iota.
- anon291 3y agoThis is exactly it. Many charity hospitals were started by religious orders sworn to poverty. Things change the moment the laity step in. Lay ceos want to make money. Nuns cannot.
- 6510 3y agoIIRC there was a phase in between with a hierarchy based on salaries. Surgeons were in charge. They created a salary scale above filled with people who know nothing about healthcare. Not to forget about investors in stead of public funds and donations.
- tyree731 3y agoSo CEO compensation there is excessive for sure. That said, charity care is probably better measured vs a hospital’s net income absent any such care. My understanding is these hospitals are squeezed on both sides of the healthcare system by insurance and health equipment and drug providers, so they don’t have a lot of net income to spare for charity care.
- LanceH 3y agoI imagine there is an enormous amount of charity care (in dollar terms at least) from people going to the ER and never paying.
- ffgjgf1 3y agoHow do you calculate net income when they can just increase costs (CEO pay amongst infinite other things) to decrease it?
- bombcar 3y agoYou could somehow come up with a "standard accepted income" for given professions (these are totally from the arse, of course, but the idea holds) like CEO, 1 million, surgeon, 500k, general practitioner, 250k, nurse 60k, whatever. How you come to those numbers is left to the reader. You'd also generate 'baseline' for other expenses. Then you compare given hospitals to those numbers and where they exceed them, that is counted as "income" - if they're paying the CEO 2m vs the 1m expected, that's 1m of income.
- Workaccount2 3y agoHospitals are all non-profit so they can reap tax benefits. In order to avoid profit but still maintain growth, they shovel all their profits into network expansion. New hospitals, clinics, outpatient centers, wellness centers, all that in order to avoid lowering costs for patients. This is why it seems each locale is packed with care all from one central hospital. They have to keep growing to maintain "non-profit" status.
- tssva 3y agoHCA operates 168 hospitals and is ranked #66 on the Fortune 500. Tenet operates 65 hospitals. These are the 2 largest for profit hospital operators in the US. There are others.
- ceejayoz 3y agoNon-profits don't have to avoid profit. The difference is what they do with any profits; they can't distribute it as dividends to owners/shareholders.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoI think the point is the same, and somewhat interesting. Do most hopspital non-profits channel their profit into growth or price discounts. In my opinion, it is fairly common for non-profits to adopt growth as a goal in of itself, and try to extract as much value as possible from customers to further it
- ceejayoz 3y agoIt's an important distinction. Non-profits are not obligated to hide/spend their profits. They're allowed to accumulate fabulous wealth if they want (see, for example, Harvard's $50B endowment). Non-profits, in theory, serve a societal/community purpose rather than existing to make a profit for their shareholders. You're not wrong that some of these lose sight of these purposes in favor of a bunch of MBAs telling them "growth! growth! growth!" (and the CEO salaries that come from such growth), but it's not because the IRS requires them to. The problem isn't tax law; it's the "everything must always grow or it's a failure" economy we've set up.
- hrdwdmrbl 3y agoThis phenomenon is not limited to hospitals.
- deleted 3y ago[deleted]
- jonathan-adly 3y agoThe article is a bit misleading in that it uses revenue. Typical margins in a health-system is slim. 3-6%. So, actual 1-2% charity care of revenue is quite significant. The thesis is correct that a health-system CEO shouldn’t make $17m/yr. It’s a non-profit largely funded by tax payers and maintains its market share by government regulations. Just the charity care component is a bit misleading.
- s1artibartfast 3y ago>It’s a non-profit largely funded by tax payers. Is it actually government funded, or does it sell services which the government pays for? I dont know if it is Baader–Meinhof phenomenon, but it seems like I increasingly see funded used to describe revenue for services rendered. It seems like a bit of a bait and switch, because the word funded often carries come connotation of ownership, obligation, or charity.
- felipemnoa 3y ago>>Is it actually government funded, Maybe indirectly. As a charity they get lots of benefits that allows them to save money.
- s1artibartfast 3y agoNot taxing money =/= giving money. Some of the impacts are identical, but they have other fundamental differences. I pay less than 100% tax, but I wouldn't say that the government is funding my lifestyle
- prasadjoglekar 3y agoBoth. The govt gives them a break on taxes. They also pay the hospital thru Medicare and Medicaid.
- LordDragonfang 3y agoI'm not sure the latter holds. That's like saying grocery stores are "government funded" because they take food stamps - or for that matter, that private retirement homes are "government funded" because the retirees get their income from Social Security. And for that matter, the former definitely doesn't hold, because nearly every entity gets some tax break. Every homeowner is "government funded".
- ww520 3y agoAren’t hospitals being nonprofit just in name only? They do it for tax purpose, not for charity.
- Guvante 3y ago501.3(c) exemptions for Hospitals require charity is why it comes up. Non-profits are required to provide community benefits to preserve their tax free status. Community benefits for hospitals are about promoting community health. https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-hospitals-general-requirements-for-tax-exemption-under-section-501c3 https://www.irs.gov/charities-non-profits/charitable-hospita...
- vsareto 3y agoThere is a not-for-profit designation as well, which has different requirements, and hospitals can be either of those or for-profit (and probably more)
- bigtex 3y agoIf you see cranes outside of a non-profit hospital you know they are not hurting.
- adolph 3y agoDo people believe that "nonprofit" is a category related to benevolence? It's just an accounting and corporate structure difference.
- wahnfrieden 3y agoLikewise with philanthropic foundations
- giardini 3y agoYes. And we should eliminate nonprofits entirely: 1. Churches, hospitals et al should all pay taxes just as do other corporations. They are built on the same social structure as other entities, have the same protection of government and benefit from the social system. I pay; so should they. 2. Campaign Finance Reform: Secondly, laws should be changed so that corporations are no longer "persons". That is Citizens_United_v._FEC should be revoked.: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Citizens_United_v._FEC Then only real people and not corporations could put money into campaigns/politics. Otherwise, in the near future (if not already) people will cease to be true participants.
- NegativeK 3y ago> I pay; so should they. I feel like that's oversimplifying the distinction between a non-profit and us? If we donate all of our income to charity, we don't pay taxes. That's because taxes are used to incentivize and disincentivize specific behaviors. We, as a society, want cheaper healthcare for people -- especially those who can't afford it. That means incentivizing hospitals (via tax) to help those people. I'm up for a removing non-profit status from hospitals if we otherwise pay for people's healthcare, but nobody really seems to be making progress there. (I'm not addressing your comments on campaign finance because I agree with you that it's broken and I think it's off-topic for this thread.)
- carlosjobim 3y ago> I pay; so should they. They don't pay and neither should you. Why is it that when people are oppressed, their biggest desire is never to be free, but to see others suffer the same as them?
- linuxftw 3y agoThere is some kind of cartel in the health care industry. They are absolutely not going to pay nurses more, and they are absolutely going to keep staffing at the minimum level. There is some kind of gentleman's agreement to not compete for labor. If everyone is paying 'market rate' and they all seem to know exactly what that rate is, there is collusion.
- ceejayoz 3y agoLabor's finally waking up to this; the nurses at my area's second-largest hospital just unionized last year and won a hard-fought contract this week.
- toomuchtodo 3y agohttps://nurse.org/articles/nurse-strikes-list/ https://nurse.org/articles/nurse-strikes-list/ (Nurse Strike Updates 2023, Full List) https://medcitynews.com/2023/07/pandemic-nurse-labor-union-workforce-shortage/ https://medcitynews.com/2023/07/pandemic-nurse-labor-union-w... ("Nurse unions and labor experts agree that the pandemic was a turning point that catalyzed nurses to fight for improved working conditions and overall better treatment from their employers. By negotiating new contracts with their employers, unions are working hard to both uphold patient safety and mitigate the nursing field’s debilitating workforce shortage.") https://www.incrediblehealth.com/blog/state-nurses-unions/ https://www.incrediblehealth.com/blog/state-nurses-unions/ ("A Comprehensive Guide of State-by-State Nursing Unions")
- linuxftw 3y agoThat's great news. I know quite a few nurses where I live, and they are being fed the anti-union propaganda from their employers. The hospital industry around here is getting nervous, they have been quite comfortable for a while. Unfortunately, the nurses don't seem to want the union, even though it will practically double their wages overnight.
- ceejayoz 3y agoOh yeah, the hospital's anti-union posters were quite something; just transparently bullshit/misleading. Stuff like "your union can't promise you a raise!" - well, neither is the hospital.
- RcouF1uZ4gsC 3y agoIsn’t Mozilla a non-profit? The CEO also reaps millions. And I bet it is much harder running a health care system than it is running Mozilla.
- ceejayoz 3y agoMozilla's CEO doesn't make anywhere close to billions, lol.
- quaxj 3y ago[flagged]
- Brian_K_White 3y agoAnd? Do you mean to imply it's OK for Mozilla and thus there is a double standard? But who said it was OK for Mozilla? And even if someone does want to say it's OK for Mozilla, you could argue that Mozilla doesn't put anyone in the position of choosing destitution or death, and Mozilla's millions come from Google who gets it from advertisers, while the hospitals millions are practically blood diamonds.
- sebtron 3y agoThe Mozilla Foundation[0] is a non-profit, the Mozilla Corporation[1] is not. [0]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Foundation [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Mozilla_Corporation
- iancmceachern 3y agoThis is true for Blue Shield also. They're all non profits and many, like Blue Shield if California are complete disasters. Blue shield of California has a lower review on Yelp than the San Francisco DMV
- jackfoxy 3y agoThink of nonprofit not as another term for benevolent or charitable organization (which is what people instinctively think), but as an alternative tax accounting scheme. Excess revenue gets funneled to the insiders at the top so that at tax year end there is no profit. Presumably these insiders are paying income tax. I once knew a guy who worked in the field of providing services to non-profits, and he described to me the lavish retreats provided to people in the industry, the first-class air travel and five-star hotels provided for travel. He called it the charitable industrial complex. Take a hard look at the tooth to tail ratio of the organization the next time you make a charitable contribution.
- bombcar 3y agoIt's quite likely that if you have two organizations - one setup as a for-profit company, one setup as a non-profit, that the government gets more taxes from the non-profit because the for-profit company can "reinvest profits" into whatever, driving the share prices up, which is (if done right) is a non-taxable event for everyone, as long as the shareholders don't sell. Whereas the non-profit that funnels excess into income for the insiders has that income taxed at income-tax levels.
- carlosjobim 3y agoCan non-profits not reinvest income just as any other business?
- bombcar 3y agoThey can - what (at least some) cannot do is stockpile cash at more than a certain amount (which I don't know what it is, but something like 1x yearly run-rate or something). So buying equipment or spending it on marketing, OK. Saving millions in the bank or investing - not OK.
- carlosjobim 3y agoThanks for the explanation! So that means they can reinvest and grow their business just as much as for-profit businesses, then? If a for-profit saves millions in the banks, that will be taxed, as it is a profit at that stage.
- daft_pink 3y agoI don't understand at all why people donate money or volunteer at hospitals like it's a charity or charity work. It really doesn't seem like a charity to me.
- bombcar 3y agoIt makes them feel good and (if you're a big enough donor) you can get your name on a plaque or building. And I daresay if you're a big enough donor you're going to get pretty darn good treatment.
- kingkawn 3y ago[flagged]
- csharpminor 3y agoCEO salaries should be understood in relationship to the resources that they control. For example, this CEO chose to spend $85M on travel nurses to counter the union strike happening at a hospital in their network. Presumably the CEO thinks that this gamble is worth it in forcing the union’s hand. That may be a terrible decision, but it shows the extent of resources a CEO of a $6bn organization commands. This is one choice out of tens to hundreds of 8-figure choices that this “super manager” will make in a year. If you’re on the board of an organization like that, settling for a second-best CEO to save a 7-figure sum just doesn’t make sense. I raise this for two reasons: 1) I find that people have no concept of how to consider whether or not executive pay is reasonable. One of my neighbors was outraged that our Mayor makes $450k. “Could she really be working 6x harder than me?” But our mayor oversees thousands of employees and makes decisions that influence hundreds of millions of dollars of spending. I’d consider her quite underpaid in proportion to what she manages. 2) Shaming organizations into lowering exec comp probably won’t work: there’s a strong economic incentive to pay competitively. Just bend the income tax contribution curve so that individuals who make more continue to pay more.
- BariumBlue 3y agoWasn't there analysis that company performance is inversely correlated to CEO compensation? I remember seeing a chart, though I don't remember whether the analysis was well done & researched or not
- prerok 3y agoI have not seen it but, to me, it kind of makes sense if you put an average overall. I think companies making a lot of money are in a world of trouble: sweet trouble, to be sure, but still trouble. Sustaining the same percentage growth is incredibly difficult once you are big. So, what is there to do? Expand to new markets, create new products with the potential to destroy your existing ones, fire people you think are no longer needed? Decisions that will either make more money or destroy the company. And, no matter what anyone else would say, I think their decisions are worse than half chance. In the end we praise the CEOs that made the "right" choice. But it was the right choice only in hindsight, it could easily have gone in the other direction, as many many examples of previously successful CEOs have shown. Nobody stays on top forever and that's just how it is. Now, as for the CEOs' salaries: they are the same regardless of their successful choices. So, when you average it out, it would look like it is inversely proportional, simply because more companies tank than stay on top.
- Fin_Code 3y agoThe purpose of non profits is to handle all the cost centers. Everything that is expensive is billed under the non profit. Then they have exclusive deals with their other for profit entities in all high margin areas. Thus the whole non profit becomes a loss lead for other services to be pushed and offered. Its a good thing for them their cost center is not taxed.
- thinkerswell 3y agoTime to get rid of the certificate of need system
- AlbertCory 3y agoAttempting to analyze hospitals in particular, or healthcare in general, as if they were "normal" businesses is a fool's errand. "Who pays?" and "who benefits?" are hopelessly complicated. And corrupt. As for the CEO salary: it's probably shaped by competition for those few slick operators who really understand how to milk the system.
- ughitsaaron 3y agoThis reminds me of an investigation by the Times from September 2022 into Providence health system’s training of employees, with the aid of McKinsey, to “[wring] money out of patients — even those who were supposed to receive free care because of their low income.” https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/24/business/nonprofit-hospitals-poor-patients.html https://www.nytimes.com/2022/09/24/business/nonprofit-hospit...